In the five decades since the founding of the ASME Design Engineering Division, the important problem of vibration isolation has been attacked first through the design of passive spring-damper suspensions and later by the use of active and semi-active elements. This paper reviews the historical development of theoretical concepts necessary for the design of isolation systems and indicates how control theory began to influence vibration isolation in the last half of this period. Practical active and semi-active suspensions have only recently become possible with the advent of powerful but relatively inexpensive signal processors. To illustrate these developments for engineers who have not been intimately involved with active systems, only simple vibrational system models will be discussed, although some modern hardware will be shown which is now being applied to complex systems. Instead of attempting to review the many theoretical concepts which have been proposed for active systems, this article will focus on a relatively simple idea with which the author has been associated over the past thirty years; namely the “skyhook” damper. This idea came through purely theoretical studies but is now used in combination with other concepts in production suspension systems. Two quite different application areas will be discussed. The first involves stable platforms to provide extreme isolation for delicate manufacturing operations against seismic inputs and the second involves automotive suspensions. Although similar concepts are found in these two application areas, the widely varying requirements result in very different suspension hardware. The special case of the semi-active damper, which requires very little control power and is presently reaching production, will also be discussed.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
1.
Allen, R., and Karnopp, D., 1975, “Semi-Active Control of Ground Vehicle Structural Dynamics,” AIAA Paper No. 75–821.
2.
Akatsu, Y., Fukushima, N., Takahashi, K., Satoh, M., and Kawarazaki, Y., 1990, “An Active Suspension Employing an Electrohydraulic Pressure Control System,” SAE Paper 905123.
3.
Anon., 1989, “Nissan Active Hydraulic Suspension,” Nissan Motor Co. Ltd., Tokyo.
4.
Anon., 1992, “Computerized Electronic Suspension,” Yamaha-O¨hlins HS Project Division Report.
5.
Anon., 1993, “Newport Neutralizer Active Vibration Isolation System,” Newport Corporation, Irvine, CA.
6.
Anon., 1994a, “The Nissan AQ-X,” Automotive Engineering, SAE, Feb., p. 43.
7.
Anon., 1994b, “Active Damper Suspension,” Automotive Engineering, SAE, Feb., p. 16.
8.
Anon., 1994c, “Electrodamp Active Vibration Control System,” Barry Controls, Brighton, MA.
9.
Beard, A. M., Schubert, D. W., and von Flowtow, A. H., 1994, “A Practical Product Implementation of an Active/Passive Vibration Isolation System,” Proc. IUTAM Symposium on the Active Control of Vibration, Bath, U.K., 12 pp.
10.
Bender, E. K., 1967a, “Optimization of the Random Vibration Characteristics of Vehicle Suspensions,” Sc.D. Thesis, Dept. of Mech. Eng., MIT, Cambridge, MA.
11.
Bender, E. K., 1967b, “Optimal Linear Control of Random Vibration,” Proc. JACC, pp. 135–144.
12.
Bender, E. K., 1968, “Optimal Linear Preview Control with Application to Vehicle Suspension,” ASME Journal of Basic Engineering, pp. 213–221.
13.
Bender, E. K., Karnopp, D. C., and Paul, I., 1967, “On the Optimization of Vehicle Suspensions Using Random Process Theory,” ASME Paper 67 TRAN12, 13 pp.
14.
Brodersen, E., 1974, “Stabilization of a Seismic Isolation Block Inertial Instrument Testing,” AIAA Paper No. 74-857, 10 pp.
15.
Chalasani, R. M., 1986, “Ride Performance Potential of Active Suspension Systems—Part I: Simplified Analysis Based on a 1/4 Car Model,” ASME Monograph, AMD, V. 80, DSC-Vol. 2.
16.
Crandall, S. H., and Mark, W. D., 1963, Random Vibration in Mechanical Systems, Academic Press, NY.
17.
Crosby, M. J., and Karnopp, D. C., 1973, “The Active Damper—A New Concept for Shock and Vibration Control,” Forty-Third Shock and Vibration Bulletin, Part 4, pp. 119–133.
18.
Csere, C., 1991, “Future Shocks-A Head to Head Comparison of Active and Passive Infinity Q45s,” Car and Driver, Nov., pp. 171–177.
19.
Decker, H., Schramm, W., and Kallenbach, R., 1988, “A Practical Approach Towards Advanced Semi-Active Suspension Systems,” Proc. IMechE Conf. on Adv. Sus., pp. 93–99.
20.
Den Hartog, J. P., 1947, Mechanical Vibrations, McGraw Hill, NY.
21.
ElBeheiry, E. M., Karnopp, D. C., ElAraby, M. E., and AbdElraaouf, A. M., 1994, “Advanced Ground Vehicle Suspension Systems—A Classified Bibliography,” Vehicle System Dynamics, in press.
22.
Emura, J., Kakizaki, S., Yamaoka, R., and Kakamura, M., 1994, “Development of the Semi-Active Suspension System Based on a Sky-Hook Damper Theory,” SAE Paper 940863 in SP-1031, Vehicle Suspension System Advancements, pp. 17–26.
23.
Federspiel-Labrosse, J. M., 1954, “Contribution of l’Etude et au Perfectionement de la Suspension des Vehicules,” J. de la SIA, (Soc. Ing. Auto), FISITA, pp. 427–436.
24.
Federspiel-Labrosse, J. M., 1955, “Beitrag zum Studium und zur Vervollkommnung der Aufha¨ngung der Fahrzeuge,” Automobiltechnische Zeitschrift, No. 3, pp. 63–70.
25.
Hedrick, J. K., and Butsuen, M. S., 1988, “Invariant Properties of Automotive Suspensions,” IMechE Paper C423/88.
26.
Hillebrecht, P., Konik, D., Pfeil, D., Wallentowitz, H., and Zieglmeier, F., 1992, “The Active Suspension Between Customer Benefit and Technological Competition,” IMechE Paper C389/378 925099.
27.
Hrovat
D.
1993
, “Applications of Optimal Control to Advanced Automotive Suspension Design
,” ASME Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control
, Vol. 115
, pp. 328
–343
.28.
Karnopp
D. C.
1968
, “Continuum Model Study of Preview Effects in Actively Suspended Long Trains
,” J. Franklin Inst.
Vol. 285
, No. 4
, pp. 251
–260
.29.
Karnopp, D. C., 1973, “Active and Passive Isolation of Random Vibration,” Isolation of Mechanical Vibration Impact and Noise, AMD Vol. 1, No. 1, J. C. Snowdon and E. E. Ungar, eds., ASME Monograph, pp. 64–86.
30.
Karnopp
D. C.
1983
, “Active Damping in Road Vehicle Suspension Systems
,” Vehicle System Dynamics
, Vol. 12
, No. 6
, pp. 291
–311
.31.
Karnopp
D.
1987
, “Active Suspensions Based on Fact Acting Load Levelers
,” Vehicle System Dynamics
Vol. 16
, No. 5–6
, pp. 355
–380
.32.
Karnopp
D.
1988
, “Design Principles for Vibration Control Systems Using Semi-Active Dampers
,” ASME Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control
, Vol. 112
, pp. 448
–455
.33.
Karnopp, D., 1992, “Active and Semi-Active Vehicle Suspension,” The Automotive Technology for Safety and Environment, Proc. Kia Academic Seminar, pp. 123–147.
34.
Karnopp
D.
Allen
R.
1975
, “Semi-Active Control for Multimode Vibratory Systems Using the ILSM Concept
,” ASME Journal of Engineering for Industry
, Vol. 98
, No. 4
, pp. 914
–918
.35.
Karnopp, D., Crosby, M. J., and Harwood, R. A., 1974, “Vibration Control Using Semi-Active Force Generators,” ASME Journal of Engineering for Industry, pp. 619–626.
36.
Karnopp
D.
Heess
G.
1991
, “Electronically Controllable Vehicle Suspensions
,” Vehicle System Dynamics
, Vol. 20
, No. 3–4
, pp. 207
–217
.37.
Karnopp, D. C., and Crosby, M. J., 1974, “System for Controlling the Transmission of Energy Between Spaced Members,” U.S. Patent 3,807,678.
38.
Karnopp
D. C.
Trikha
A. K.
1969
, “Comparative Study of Optimization Techniques for Shock and Vibration Isolation
,” ASME Journal of Engineering for Industry
, Vol. 91
, No. 4
, pp. 1128
–1132
.39.
Kunica, S., 1965, “Servo-Controlled Pneumatic Isolators—Their Properties and Applications,” ASME Paper 65-WA/MD-12.
40.
Leatherwood, J. D., and Dixon, G. V., 1968, “Active Vibration Isolation for Flexible Payloads,” IES Proc., pp. 407–413.
41.
Obson, W. O., and Allen, L. R., 1965, “Active Suspension for Automotive Military Vehicles,” Westinghouse Research Laboratory Scientific Paper 65-IDI-HYDRA-PI.
42.
O¨hlin, K., 1988, “Means for a Shock-Absorber,” U.S. Patent 4,732,408. Schubert, D. W., 1992, “Active Vibration Isolation System,” United States Patent Number Re. 33,937.
43.
Smith
R. E.
Lum
E. L. S.
1968
, “Linear Optimal Theory Applied to Active Structural Bending Control
,” AIAA J. of Aircraft
, Vol. 5
, No. 5
, pp. 475
–479
.44.
Tillback, L. R., and Brodd, S., 1989, “Active Suspension—The Volvo Experience,” Proc. Autotechnologies Conference P-221, pp. 59–67.
45.
Wallentowitz, H., 1991, “Von der Niveauregulierung zur Aktiven Federung: Erkennbare Entwicklungstendensen,” Aktive Fahrwerktechnik Vieweg Verlag, Braunschweig, pp. 150–191.
46.
Whittaker, E. T., 1904, A Treatise on the Analytical Dynamics of Particles and Rigid Bodies, Paperback Edition, 1961, Cambridge University Press, p. 177.
47.
Wright, P. G., and Williams, D. A., 1989, “The Case for an Irreversible Active Suspension System,” Proc. Autotechnologies, P-221, Paper 890081, pp. 41–48.
48.
Williams, D., and Wright, P., 1984, “Vehicle Suspension Arrangements,” Group Lotus Car Companies European Patent PLC EP O 142 947.
49.
Witt, D. C., 1976, “Improvements In or Relating to Vehicle Suspension Systems,” Patent Specification 1 450 765, The Patent Office, London.
50.
Yokoya, Y., Asami, K., Hamajima, T., and Nakashima, N., 1984, “Toyota Electronic Modulated Suspension (TEMS) System for the 1983 Soarer,” SAE Paper 840341.
51.
Yokoya, Y., Kizu, R., Kawaguchi, H., and Ohashi, K., 1990, “Integrated Control System Between Active Control Suspension and Four Wheel Steering for the 1989 CELICA,” SAE Paper 901748.
This content is only available via PDF.
Copyright © 1995
by The American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
