ABSTRACT

The pharmaceutical industry took over 20 years to change from the qualitative monitoring of a small group of heavy metals to finally arrive at regulations for 24 elemental impurities in drug products, classified by their permitted daily exposure limits and categorized by toxicological impact and method of administration (oral, parenteral, inhalation, transdermal). The entire premise was based on carrying out a comprehensive risk assessment study of their toxicity and the likelihood of finding them somewhere in the drug manufacturing process, which was fully documented in International Council for Harmonization of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use Q3C guidelines for elemental impurities. The cannabis industry cannot move beyond the big four heavy metals until this type of risk assessment study is carried out. The objective of this paper is to offer guidance as to which elemental contaminants are worthy of consideration, based on likely sources derived from the cultivation, extraction, processing, packaging, and delivery of cannabis and hemp consumer products and to explore how this well-established pharmaceutical risk assessment process could be adapted by the cannabis industry. It will be broken down into four main sections, which are outlined as follows: the pharmaceutical risk assessment approach; whether risk analysis can be adapted for the cannabis industry; sources of elemental contaminants derived from cultivation practices; and contributions from the cannabis manufacturing process.

References

1.
Marijuana Policy Project
, “
State Policy
,” Marijuana Policy Project,
2023
, https://www.mpp.org/states/
2.
R.
 
Thomas
, “
The Importance of Measuring Heavy Metal Contaminants in Cannabis and Hemp
,” Analytical Cannabis,
2021
, https://cdn.technologynetworks.com/ac/Resources/pdf/the-importance-of-measuring-heavy-metal-contaminants-in-cannabis-and-hemp-312957.pdf
3.
R.
 
Thomas
, “
A Recap of ASTM’s Workshop on Measuring Elemental Contaminants in Cannabis and Hemp Consumer Products
,” Analytical Cannabis,
2021
, https://www.analyticalcannabis.com/articles/a-recap-of-astms-workshop-on-measuring-elemental-contaminants-in-cannabis-and-hemp-consumer-313229
4.
National Institute of Standards and Technology
, “
NIST Tools for Cannabis Laboratory Quality Assurance
,” National Institute of Standards and Technology,
2019
, https://www.nist.gov/programs-projects/nist-tools-cannabis-laboratory-quality-assurance
5.
United States Pharmacopeia
, “
Elemental Impurities Updates: General Chapter <232>Elemental Impurities – Limits
,” United States Pharmacopeia,
2020
, https://www.usp.org/impurities/elemental-impurities-updates
6.
United States Pharmacopeia
, “
Elemental Impurities Updates: General Chapter <233>Elemental Impurities – Procedures
,” United States Pharmacopeia,
2020
, https://www.usp.org/impurities/elemental-impurities-updates
7.
International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use
, “
ICH Guideline Q3D (R1) on Elemental Impurities
,” European Medicine Agency,
2019
, https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/scientific-guideline/international-conference-harmonisation-technical-requirements-registration-pharmaceuticals-human-use-ich-q3d-elemental-impurities-step-5-revision-1_en.pdf
8.
International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use
, “
ICH Guideline Q3D (R2) on Elemental Impurities
,” European Medicine Agency,
2020
, https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/scientific-guideline/draft-ich-guideline-q3d-r2-elemental-impurities-step-2b_en.pdf
9.
World Health Organization & Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
, “
Dose-Response Assessment and Derivation of Health Based Guidance Values
,” in
Environmental Health Criterion 240: Principles and Methods for the Risk Assessment of Chemicals in Food
(
Geneva, Switzerland
:
World Health Organization
,
2009
),
5-1
5-115
.
10.
United States Environmental Protection Agency
, “
Basic Information About the Integrated Risk Information System
,” United States Environmental Protection Agency,
2021
, https://www.epa.gov/iris/basic-information-about-integrated-risk-information-system
11.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration
, “
Guidance for Industry and Other Stakeholders: Toxicological Principles for the Safety Assessment of Food Ingredients
,” U.S. Food and Drug Administration,
2000
, https://www.fda.gov/files/food/published/Toxicological-Principles-for-the-Safety-Assessment-of-Food-Ingredients.pdf
12.
D. R.
 
Jenke
,
C. L. M.
 
Stults
,
D. M.
 
Paskiet
,
D. J.
 
Ball
, and
L. M.
 
Nagao
, “
Materials in Manufacturing and Packaging Systems as Sources of Elemental Impurities in Packaged Drug Products: A Literature Review
,”
PDA Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology
69
, no. 
1
(January/February
2015
):
1
48
.
13.
D.
 
Jenke
,
C.
 
Rivera
,
T.
 
Mortensen
,
P.
 
Amin
,
M.
 
Chacko
,
T.
 
Tran
, and
J.
 
Chum
, “
A Compilation of Metals and Trace Elements Extracted from Materials Relevant to Pharmaceutical Applications Such as Packaging Systems and Devices
,”
PDA Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology
67
, no. 
4
(July/August
2013
):
354
375
.
14.
G.
 
Li
,
D.
 
Schoneker
,
K. L.
 
Ulman
,
J. J.
 
Sturm
,
L. M.
 
Thackery
, and
J. F.
 
Kauffman
, “
Elemental Impurities in Pharmaceutical Excipients
,”
Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences
104
, no. 
12
(December
2015
):
4197
4206
.
15.
ECA Foundation
, “
Elemental Impurities - A Database to Facilitate the Risk Assessment of Active Ingredients and Excipients
,” ECA Foundation,
2015
, https://www.gmp-compliance.org/gmp-news/elemental-impurities-a-database-to-facilitate-the-risk-assessment-of-active-ingredients-and-excipients
16.
Center for Drug Evaluation and Research and Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research
, “
Elemental Impurities in Drug Products Guidance for Industry
,” U.S. Food and Drug Administration,
2018
, https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/elemental-impurities-drug-products-guidance-industry
17.
L.
 
Bengyella
,
M.
 
Kuddus
,
P.
 
Mukherjee
,
D. J.
 
Fonmboh
, and
J. E.
 
Kaminski
, “
Global Impact of Trace Non-essential Heavy Metal Contaminants in Industrial Cannabis Bioeconomy
,”
Toxin Reviews
41
, no. 
4
(
2022
):
1215
1225
.
18.
M. M.
 
Lasat
, “
The Use of Plants for the Removal of Toxic Metals from Contaminated Soil
,” American Association for the Advancement of Science,
2000
, https://clu-in.org/download/remed/lasat.pdf
19.
R.
 
Ahmad
,
Z.
 
Tehsin
,
S. T.
 
Malik
,
S. A.
 
Asad
,
M.
 
Shahzad
,
M.
 
Bilal
,
M. M.
 
Shah
, and
S. A.
 
Khan
, “
Phytoremediation Potential of Hemp (Cannabis sativa L.): Identification and Characterization of Heavy Metals Responsive Genes
,”
Clean Soil Air Water
44
, no. 
2
(February
2016
):
195
201
.
20.
D. V.
 
Gauvin
, “
A ‘Budding’ Cannabis Cottage-Industry Has Set the Stage for an Impending Public Health Crisis
,”
Pharmaceutical Regulatory Affairs: Open Access
7
, no. 
1
(
2018
):
1
16
.
21.
D. V.
 
Gauvin
,
Z. J.
 
Zimmermann
,
J.
 
Yoder
, and
R.
 
Tapp
, “
Marijuana Toxicity: Heavy Metal Exposure through State-Sponsored Access to ‘la Fee Verte’
,”
Pharmaceutical Regulatory Affairs: Open Access
7
, no. 
1
(
2018
):
1
10
.
22.
M.
 
Khan
,
A.
 
Wajid
,
S.
 
Noor
,
F. K.
 
Khattak
,
S.
 
Akter
, and
I. U.
 
Rahman
, “
Effect of Soil Contamination on Some Heavy Metals Content of Cannabis sativa
,”
Journal of the Chemical Society of Pakistan
30
, no. 
6
(December
2008
):
805
809
.
23.
V.
 
Masindi
and
K. L.
 
Muedi
, “
Environmental Contamination by Heavy Metals
,” in
Heavy Metals
, ed.
H. E.-D. M.
 
Saleh
and
R. F.
 
Aglan
(
London
:
IntechOpen
,
2018
):
115
133
. https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.76082
24.
A. H.
 
Ahkami
,
R. A.
 
White
III
,
P. P.
 
Handakumbura
, and
C.
 
Jansson
, “
Rhizosphere Engineering: Enhancing Sustainable Plant Ecosystem Productivity
,”
Rhizosphere
3
, no. 
2
(June
2017
):
233
243
.
25.
G.
 
Bode
, “
Back to the Root-The Role of Botany and Plant Physiology in Cannabis Testing, Part I: Understanding Mechanisms of Heavy Metal Uptake in Plants
,”
Cannabis Science and Technology
3
, no. 
2
(March
2020
):
26
29
, 45.
26.
B. J.
 
Alloway
, ed.,
Heavy Metals in Soils: Trace Metals and Metalloids in Soils and Their Bioavailability
(
Dordrecht, the Netherlands
:
Springer
,
2013
). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-4470-7
27.
C.
 
Stephan
and
R.
 
Thomas
, “
Single-Particle ICP-MS: A Key Analytical Technique for Characterizing Nanoparticles
,”
Spectroscopy
32
, no. 
3
(March
2017
):
12
25
.
28.
X.
 
Zhang
,
H.
 
Wang
,
L.
 
He
,
K.
 
Lu
,
A.
 
Sarmah
,
J.
 
Li
,
N. S.
 
Bolan
,
J.
 
Pei
, and
H.
 
Huang
, “
Using Biochar for Remediation of Soils Contaminated with Heavy Metals and Organic Pollutants
,”
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
20
, no. 
12
(December
2013
):
8472
8483
.
29.
R.
 
Thomas
, “
The Impact of Illegal Artisanal Gold Mining on the Peruvian Amazon: Benefits of Taking a Direct Mercury Analyzer into the Rain Forest to Monitor Mercury Contamination
,”
Spectroscopy
34
, no. 
2
(February
2019
):
22
32
.
30.
L. D.
 
Lacerda
, “
Global Mercury Emissions from Gold and Silver Mining
,”
Water, Air, and Soil Pollution
97
, no. 
3
(July
1997
):
209
221
.
31.
R.
 
Singh
,
N.
 
Gautam
,
A.
 
Mishra
, and
R.
 
Gupta
, “
Heavy Metals and Living Systems: An Overview
,”
Indian Journal of Pharmacology
43
, no. 
3
(May–June
2011
):
246
253
.
32.
United States Environmental Protection Agency
, “
Which Radionuclides Are Found at Superfund Sites?
” United States Environmental Protection Agency,
2022
, https://www.epa.gov/radiation/which-radionuclides-are-found-superfund-sites
33.
United States Environmental Protection Agency
, “
Coal Ash Basics
,” United States Environmental Protection Agency,
2023
, https://www.epa.gov/coalash/coal-ash-basics
34.
Y.
 
Cabrera
, “
Urban Children Are Playing in Toxic Dirt
,” Think Progress,
2017
, https://archive.thinkprogress.org/urban-children-are-playing-in-toxic-dirt-41961957ff23/
35.
United States Environmental Protection Agency
, “
Mercury and Air Toxics Standards (MATS)
,” United States Environmental Protection Agency,
2023
, https://www.epa.gov/mats
36.
C. K.
 
Wong
,
C. E.
 
Renshaw
,
X.
 
Feng
, and
S.
 
Sturup
, “
New Hampshire Apple Orchards as a Source of Arsenic Contamination
,” in
American Geophysical Union, Spring Meeting 2002
(
Washington, DC
:
American Geophysical Union
,
2002
).
37.
C. E.
 
Renshaw
,
B. C.
 
Bostick
,
X.
 
Feng
,
C. K.
 
Wong
,
E. S.
 
Winston
,
R.
 
Karimi
,
C. L.
 
Folt
, and
C. Y.
 
Chen
, “
Impact of Land Disturbance on the Fate of Arsenical Pesticides
,”
Journal of Environmental Quality
35
, no. 
1
(January
2006
):
61
67
.
38.
A. Y.-Y.
 
Chen
and
T.
 
Olsen
, “
Chromated Copper Arsenate-Treated Wood: A Potential Source of Arsenic Exposure and Toxicity in Dermatology
,”
International Journal of Women’s Dermatology
2
, no. 
1
(March
2016
):
28
30
.
39.
Sabiha-Javied
,
T.
Mehmood,
M. M.
 
Chadhury
,
M.
 
Tufail
, and
N.
 
Irfan
, “
Heavy Metal Pollution from Phosphate Rock Used for the Production of Fertilizer in Pakistan
,”
Microchemical Journal
91
, no. 
1
(January
2009
):
94
99
.
40.
M. S. A.
 
Ahmad
and
M.
 
Ashraf
, “
Essential Roles and Hazardous Effects of Nickel in Plants
,” in
Reviews of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology
(
New York
:
Springer
,
2012
),
125
167
. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-0668-6_6
41.
T.
 
Buechel
, “
Role of Nickel in Plant Culture
,” Promix,
2023
, https://www.pthorticulture.com/en/training-center/role-of-nickel-in-plant-culture/
42.
L.
 
Sumpter
, “
How to Use Silica to Grow Healthier Cannabis Plants
,” Royal Queen Seeds,
2021
, https://www.royalqueenseeds.com/blog-using-silicon-supplements-to-cultivate-healthier-cannabis-plants-n199
43.
N.
 
Defarge
,
J.
 
Spiroux de Vendômois
, and
G. E.
 
Séralini
, “
Toxicity of Formulants and Heavy Metals in Glyphosate-Based Herbicides and Other Pesticides
,”
Toxicology Reports
5
(
2018
):
156
163
.
44.
The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
, “
Hexavalent Chromium
,” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
2019
, https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/hexchrom/default.html
45.
J.
 
Worland
, “
America’s Clean Water Crisis Goes Far Beyond Flint. There’s No Relief in Sight
,” TIME,
2020
, https://time.com/longform/clean-water-access-united-states/
46.
United States Environmental Protection Agency
, “
Flint Drinking Water Response
,” EPA,
2024
, https://www.epa.gov/flint
47.
United States Environmental Protection Agency
, “
Learn About Lead
,” United States Environmental Protection Agency,
2023
, https://www.epa.gov/lead/learn-about-lead
48.
Q.
 
Chen
,
S.
 
Wang
,
Y.
 
Li
,
N.
 
Zhang
,
B.
 
Zhao
,
Y.
 
Zhuo
, and
C.
 
Chen
, “
Influence of Flue Gas Desulfurization Gypsum Amendments on Heavy Metal Distribution in Reclaimed Sodic Soils
,”
Environmental Engineering Science
32
, no. 
6
(June
2015
):
470
478
.
49.
United States Pharmacopeia
, “
It’s Time to Hold Cannabinoid Products to the Highest Standard: USP Cannabis Panel Statement on Delta8-THC
,” United States Pharmacopeia,
2021
, https://www.usp.org/sites/default/files/usp/document/our-science/usp-delta-8-final-12-2-21.pdf
50.
J.
 
Meehan-Atrash
and
I.
 
Rahman
, “
Novel Δ8-Tetrahydrocannabinol Vaporizers Contain Unlabeled Adulterants, Unintended Byproducts of Chemical Synthesis, and Heavy Metals
,”
Chemical Research in Toxicology
35
, no. 
1
(January
2022
):
73
76
.
51.
A Beadle
, “
Advances in Whole Plant Cannabis Extraction
,” Analytical Cannabis,
2019
, https://www.analyticalcannabis.com/articles/advances-in-whole-plant-cannabis-extraction-312087
52.
D.
 
Hodes
, “
New Extraction Technologies Lining Up to Be Game-Changers
,”
Cannabis Science and Technology
3
, no. 
4
(May
2020
):
14
27
.
53.
L.
 
Macri
, “
The Presence and Transmission of Heavy Metals in Plant Fertilizers
,” Maximum Yield,
2016
, https://www.maximumyield.com/the-presence-and-transmission-of-heavy-metals-in-plant-fertilizers/2/2640
54.
D. P.
 
Krabbenhoft
and
D. A.
 
Rickert
, “
Fact Sheet 216-95: Mercury Contamination of Aquatic Ecosystems
,” U.S. Geological Survey,
2018
, https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/1995/fs216-95/
55.
Environment and Climate Change Canada
, “
Mercury in the Food Chain
,” Government of Canada, https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/pollutants/mercury-environment/health-concerns/food-chain.html
56.
L. M.
 
Dryburgh
,
N. S.
 
Bolan
,
C. P. L.
 
Grof
,
P.
 
Galettis
,
J.
 
Schneider
,
C. J.
 
Lucas
, and
J. H.
 
Martin
, “
Cannabis Contaminants: Sources, Distribution, Human Toxicity and Pharmacologic Effects
,”
British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology
84
, no. 
11
(November
2018
):
2468
2476
.
57.
N.
 
Seltenrich
, “
Cannabis Contaminants: Regulating Solvents, Microbes, and Metals in Legal Weed
,”
Environmental Health Perspectives
127
, no. 
8
(August
2019
):
082001
.
58.
B.
 
Whittle
,
C. A.
 
Hill
,
I. R.
 
Flockhart
,
D. V.
 
Downs
,
P.
 
Gibson
, and
G. W.
 
Wheatley
. Extraction of pharmaceutically active components from plant materials. US Patent 7,344.736, filed August 14,
2002
, and issued March 18,
2008
.
59.
M. P.
 
Lazarjani
,
O.
 
Young
,
L.
 
Kebede
, and
A.
 
Seyfoddin
, “
Processing and Extraction Methods of Medicinal Cannabis: A Narrative Review
,”
Journal of Cannabis Research
3
, no. 
1
(
2021
):
32
.
60.
D.
 
Picket
and
S.
 
Giovinazzi
, “
Heavy Metals in Hemp Extract Products
,” Analytical Cannabis,
2021
, https://www.analyticalcannabis.com/videos/heavy-metals-in-hemp-extract-products-313423
61.
R.
 
Newman
, “
Heavy Metals Contamination: Is Cannabis Packaging to Blame
?” Analytical Cannabis,
2020
, https://www.analyticalcannabis.com/articles/heavy-metals-contamination-is-cannabis-packaging-to-blame-312246
62.
R. S.
 
Pappas
,
M. R.
 
Fresquez
,
N.
 
Martone
, and
C. H.
 
Watson
, “
Toxic Metal Concentrations in Mainstream Smoke from Cigarettes Available in the USA
,”
Journal of Analytical Toxicology
38
, no. 
4
(May
2014
):
204
211
.
63.
N. U.
 
Benson
,
W. U.
 
Anake
,
A. E.
 
Adedapo
,
O. H.
 
Fred-Ahmadu
, and
O. O.
 
Ayejuyo
, “
Toxic Metals in Cigarettes and Human Health Risk Assessment Associated with Inhalation Exposure
,”
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
189
, no. 
12
(December
2017
):
619
.
64.
P.
 
Ziarati
,
Z.
 
Mousavi
, and
S.
 
Pashapour
, “
Analysis of Heavy Metals in Cigarette Tobacco
,”
Journal of Medical Discovery
2
, no. 
1
(February
2017
):
jm16006
.
65.
N.
 
Gray
,
M.
 
Halstead
,
N.
 
Gonzalez-Jimenez
,
L.
 
Valentin-Blasini
,
C.
 
Watson
, and
R. S.
 
Pappas
, “
Analysis of Toxic Metals in Liquid from Electronic Cigarettes
,”
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
16
, no. 
22
(November
2019
):
4450
.
66.
C. A.
 
Hess
,
P.
 
Olmedo
,
A.
 
Navas-Acien
,
W.
 
Goessler
,
J. E.
 
Cohen
, and
A. M.
 
Rule
, “
Study: Toxic Metals Found in E-Cigarette Liquids
,” Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health,
2017
, https://publichealth.jhu.edu/2017/study-toxic-metals-found-in-e-cigarette-liquids
67.
R. S.
 
Pappas
,
N.
 
Gray
,
M.
 
Halstead
,
L.
 
Valentin-Blasini
, and
C.
 
Watson
, “
Toxic Metal-Containing Particles in Aerosols from Pod-Type Electronic Cigarettes
,”
Journal of Analytical Toxicology
45
, no. 
4
(May
2021
):
337
347
.
68.
A.
 
Beadle
, “
Heavy Metals Can Leach into Cannabis Vape Oils and Aerosols, New Study Warns
,” Analytical Cannabis,
2021
, https://www.analyticalcannabis.com/news/heavy-metals-can-leach-into-cannabis-vape-oils-and-aerosols-new-study-warns-313479
69.
R.
 
Thomas
, “
The Challenges of Measuring Heavy Metal Contaminants in Cannabis Vaping Aerosols
,” Analytical Cannabis,
2021
, https://cdn.technologynetworks.com/ac/Resources/pdf/the-challenges-of-measuring-heavy-metal-contaminants-in-cannabis-vaping-aerosols-313041.pdf
70.
S. R.
 
Mallampati
,
C.
 
McDaniel
, and
A. R.
 
Wise
, “
Strategies for Nonpolar Aerosol Collection and Heavy Metals Analysis of Inhaled Cannabis Products
,”
ACS Omega
6
, no. 
26
(July
2021
):
17126
17135
.
71.
N.
 
Gonzalez-Jimenez
,
N.
 
Gray
,
R. S.
 
Pappas
,
M.
 
Halstead
,
E.
 
Lewis
,
L.
 
Valentin-Blasini
,
C.
 
Watson
, and
B.
 
Blount
, “
Analysis of Toxic Metals in Aerosols from Devices Associated with Electronic Cigarette, or Vaping, Product Use Associated Lung Injury
,”
Toxics
9
, no. 
10
(October
2021
):
240
.
72.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
, “
Outbreak of Lung Injury Associated with the Use of E-Cigarette, or Vaping, Products
,” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
2020
, https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/basic_information/e-cigarettes/severe-lung-disease.html
73.
S. L.
 
Meyers
, “
China Cashes in on the Cannabis Boom
,” New York Times,
2019
, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/04/world/asia/china-cannabis-cbd.html
74.
G.
 
Shih
, “
China: Toxic Trails from Metal Production Harms Health of Poor Communities Amid Soaring Global Demand for Gadgets
,” Washington Post,
2020
, https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/china-toxic-trails-from-metal-production-harms-health-of-poor-communities-amid-soaring-global-demand-for-gadgets-2/
75.
R.
 
Thomas
and
T.
 
Destefano
, “
Understanding Sources of Heavy Metals in Cannabis and Hemp: Benefits of a Risk Assessment Strategy
,” Analytical Cannabis,
2022
, https://www.analyticalcannabis.com/white-papers/understanding-sources-of-heavy-metals-in-cannabis-and-hemp-benefits-of-a-risk-assessment-strategy-314044
You do not currently have access to this content.