https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1765-429X
Abstract
There is significant difference between the loading conditions used to certify equestrian helmets and the environment in which they are commonly used. This may affect their ability to provide adequate protection against head injury during a riding accident. The efficacy of helmet performance under real-world riding conditions can be judged by examining physical damage to the helmet during an impact, along with details of any head injury that may have been sustained by the rider. The present study considered the influence of different impact events on helmet damage sustained during real-world equestrian racing and eventing accidents. Video analysis of the accidents and assessment of the corresponding helmets allowed helmet damage to be matched to impacts. From a total of 1,119 accident videos and 218 inspected helmets, there was a total of 18 cases for which both the helmet and unobstructed video views of the accident sequence were available, along with details of any injuries sustained by the rider. All 18 cases involved the riders falling from their horses and impacting their heads against the turf. For 7 of the 18 cases, head impacts occurred in which a rider’s head was also either kicked, crushed, or stomped on by a horse: those subsequent impacts led to significant helmet damage, suggesting that the helmets provided protection for the riders during those secondary and tertiary impacts. Surprisingly, 11 of the 18 cases involved only a fall for which none of the helmets had any evident damage, despite 6 of those cases involving diagnosed concussions and 1 hematoma. This indicates that traumatic brain injury can occur in equestrian sports even while the rider wears a helmet, which suggests that there is scope to further improve the ability of equestrian helmets to protect against concussion when riders fall and impact their head against turf.
Issue Section:
Technical Papers
References
1.
Bixby-Hammett
D.
and Brooks
W. H.
, “Common Injuries in Horseback Riding. A Review
,” Sports Medicine
9
, no. 1
(January 1990
): 36
–47
. https://doi.org/10.2165/00007256-199009010-000042.
Press
J. M.
, Davis
P. D.
, Wiesner
S. L.
, Heinemann
A.
, Semik
P.
, and Addison
R. G.
, “The National Jockey Injury Study: An Analysis of Injuries to Professional Horse-Racing Jockeys
,” Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine
5
, no. 4
(October 1995
): 236
–240
. https://doi.org/10.1097/00042752-199510000-000053.
McCrory
P.
, Turner
M.
, LeMasson
B.
, Bodere
C.
, and Allemandou
A.
, “An Analysis of Injuries Resulting from Professional Horse Racing in France during 1991-2001: A Comparison with Injuries Resulting from Professional Horse Racing in Great Britain during 1992-2001
,” British Journal of Sports Medicine
40
, no. 7
(July 2006
): 614
–618
. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsm.2006.0284494.
Balendra
G.
, Turner
M.
, McCrory
P.
, and Halley
W.
, “Injuries in Amateur Horse Racing (Point to Point Racing) in Great Britain and Ireland during 1993–2006
,” British Journal of Sports Medicine
41
, no. 3
(March 2007
): 162
–166
. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsm.2006.0338945.
Rueda
M. A.
, Halley
W. L.
, and Gilchrist
M. D.
, “Fall and Injury Incidence Rates of Jockeys while Racing in Ireland, France and Britain
,” Injury
41
, no. 5
(May 2010
): 533
–539
. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2009.05.0096.
Foote
C.
, McIntosh
A.
, V’Landys
P.
, and Bulloch
K.
, Health and Safety in Australian Horse Racing, RIRDC Publication No. 10/067
(Wagga Wagga, Australia
: Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation
, 2011
).7.
Bond
G. R.
, Christoph
R. A.
, and Rodgers
B. M.
, “Pediatric Equestrian Injuries: Assessing the Impact of Helmet Use
,” Pediatrics
95
, no. 4
(April 1995
): 487
–489
. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-4375(96)86979-98.
Harrison
T. R.
, Mills
N. J.
, and Turner
M. S.
, “Jockeys’ Head Injuries and Skull Cap Performance
” (paper presentation, IRCOBI Conference, Dublin, Ireland, September 11
–13
, 1996
).9.
Fleming
P. R.
, Crompton
J. L.
, and Simpson
D. A.
, “Neuro‐Ophthalmological Sequelae of Horse‐Related Accidents
,” Clinical & Experimental Ophthalmology
29
, no. 4
(August 2001
): 208
–212
. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1442-9071.2001.00430.x10.
Holland
A. J.
, Roy
G. T.
, Goh
V.
, Ross
F. I.
, Keneally
J. P.
, and Cass
D. T.
, “Horse-Related Injuries in Children
,” Medical Journal of Australia
175
, nos. 11–12
(December 2001
): 609
–612
. https://doi.org/10.5694/j.1326-5377.2001.tb143746.x11.
Abu-Zidan
F. M.
and Rao
S.
, “Factors Affecting the Severity of Horse-Related Injuries
,” Injury
34
, no. 12
(December 2003
): 897
–900
. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0020-1383(03)00054-812.
Northey
G.
, “Equestrian Injuries in New Zealand, 1993-2001: Knowledge and Experience
,” New Zealand Medical Journal
116
, no. 1182
(September 2003
): U601.13.
Lim
J.
, Puttaswamy
V.
, Gizzi
M.
, Christie
L.
, Croker
W.
, and Crowe
P.
, “Pattern of Equestrian Injuries Presenting to a Sydney Teaching Hospital
,” ANZ Journal of Surgery
73
, no. 8
(August 2003
): 567
–571
. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1445-2197.2003.02707.x14.
Petridou
E.
, Kedikoglou
S.
, Belechri
M.
, Ntouvelis
E.
, Dessypris
N.
, and Trichopoulos
D.
, “The Mosaic of Equestrian-Related Injuries in Greece
,” Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery
56
, no. 3
(March 2004
): 643
–647
. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.TA.0000053470.38129.F415.
Bier
G.
, Bongers
M. N.
, Othman
A.
, Hempel
J.-M.
, Vieth
V.
, Heindel
W.
, Ernemann
U.
, and Burg
M. C.
, “Impact of Helmet Use in Equestrian-Related Traumatic Brain Injury: A Matched-Pairs Analysis
,” British Journal of Neurosurgery
32
, no. 1
(February 2018
): 37
–43
. https://doi.org/10.1080/02688697.2017.140987416.
Helmets for Equestrian Use
, PAS 015:2011 (London, UK
: British Standards Institution
, 2011
). https://doi.org/10.3403/3020455317.
Standard Specification for Protective Headgear Used in Horse Sports and Horseback Riding
, ASTM F1163-15 (West Conshohocken, PA
: ASTM International
, approved October 1, 2015
). https://doi.org/10.1520/F1163-1518.
Helmets for Equestrian Activities
, BS EN 1384:2017 (London, UK
: British Standards Institution
, 2017
). https://doi.org/10.3403/3029040619.
Mills
N. J.
and Whitlock
M. D.
, “Performance of Horse-Riding Helmets in Frontal and Side Impacts
,” Injury
20
, no. 4
(July 1989
): 189
–192
. https://doi.org/10.1016/0020-1383(89)90108-320.
Hunt
H.
and Mills
N. J.
, “The Protection of Horse Riders in Impacts with the Ground
” (paper presentation, IRCOBI Conference, Stockholm, Sweden, September 13–15, 1989
).21.
Rueda
M. A. F.
, Cui
L.
, and Gilchrist
M. D.
, “Optimisation of Energy Absorbing Liner for Equestrian Helmets. Part I: Layered Foam Liner
,” Materials & Design
30
, no. 9
(October 2009
): 3405
–3413
. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2009.03.03722.
Clark
J. M.
, Post
A.
, Hoshizaki
T. B.
, and Gilchrist
M. D.
, “Protective Capacity of Ice Hockey Helmets against Different Impact Events
,” Annals of Biomedical Engineering
44
, no. 12
(December 2016
): 3693
–3704
. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-016-1686-323.
Clark
J. M.
, Hoshizaki
T. B.
, and Gilchrist
M. D.
, “Protective Capacity of an Ice Hockey Goaltender Helmet for Three Events Associated with Concussion
,” Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering
20
, no. 12
(September 2017
): 1299
–1311
. https://doi.org/10.1080/10255842.2017.134197724.
Clark
J. M.
, Hoshizaki
T. B.
, and Gilchrist
M. D.
, “Assessing Women’s Lacrosse Head Impacts Using Finite Element Modelling
,” Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
80
(April 2018
): 20
–26
. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmbbm.2018.01.02025.
Hurt
H. H.
, Ouellet
J. V.
, and Wagar
I. J.
, “Analysis of Accident Involved Motorcycle Safety Helmets
,” in 20th Annual Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine
(Lake Bluff, IL
: American Association for Automotive Medicine
, 1976
), 187
–197
.26.
Williams
M.
, “The Protective Performance of Bicyclists’ Helmets in Accidents
,” Accident Analysis & Prevention
23
, nos. 2–3
(April–June 1991
): 119
–131
. https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-4575(91)90043-527.
Smith
T. A.
, Tees
D.
, Thom
D. R.
, and Hurt Jr
H. H.
., “Evaluation and Replication of Impact Damage to Bicycle Helmets
,” Accident Analysis & Prevention
26
, no. 6
(December 1994
): 795
–802
. https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-4575(94)90055-828.
Ching
R. P.
, Thompson
D. C.
, Thompson
R. S.
, Thomas
D. J.
, Chilcott
W. C.
, and Rivara
F. P.
, “Damage to Bicycle Helmets Involved with Crashes
,” Accident Analysis & Prevention
29
, no. 5
(September 1997
): 555
–562
. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0001-4575(97)00008-029.
Ingemar Johnson
G.
, “A Comparison of Results on Helmet Impact Testing
,” Journal of Testing and Evaluation
31
, no. 1
(January 2003
): 79
–90
. https://doi.org/10.1520/jte12357j30.
Yamaguchi
G.
, Dainty
D.
, Lam
T.
, and Watson
H.
, “Performance of Certified Climbing Helmets during Simulated Climbing Falls
,” Journal of Testing and Evaluation
42
, no. 5
(September 2014
): 1257
–1277
. https://doi.org/10.1520/JTE2013012231.
Pinnoji
P. K.
and Mahajan
P.
, “Analysis of Impact-Induced Damage and Delamination in the Composite Shell of a Helmet
,” Materials & Design
31
, no. 8
(September 2010
): 3716
–3723
. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2010.03.01132.
Connor
T. A.
, Clark
J. M.
, Jayamohan
J.
, Stewart
M.
, McGoldrick
A.
, Williams
C.
, Seemungal
B. M.
, Smith
R.
, Burek
R.
, and Gilchrist
M. D.
, “Do Equestrian Helmets Prevent Concussion? A Retrospective Analysis of Head Injuries and Helmet Damage from Real-World Equestrian Accidents
,” Sports Medicine – Open
5
(May 2019
): 19. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-019-0193-033.
Pellman
E. J.
, Viano
D. C.
, Tucker
A. M.
, Casson
I. R.
, and Waeckerle
J. F.
, “Concussion in Professional Football: Reconstruction of Game Impacts and Injuries
,” Neurosurgery
53
, no. 4
(October 2003
): 799
–814
. https://doi.org/10.1093/neurosurgery/53.3.79934.
Mihalik
J. P.
, Guskiewicz
K. M.
, Jeffries
J. A.
, Greenwald
R. M.
, and Marshall
S. W.
, “Characteristics of Head Impacts Sustained by Youth Ice Hockey Players
,” Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Sports Engineering and Technology
222
, no. 1
(March 2008
): 45
–52
. https://doi.org/10.1243/17543371jset435.
Fréchède
B.
and McIntosh
A. S.
, “Numerical Reconstruction of Real-Life Concussive Football Impacts
,” Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise
41
, no. 2
(February 2009
): 390
–398
. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0b013e318186b1c536.
Crisco
J. J.
, Fiore
R.
, Beckwith
J. G.
, Chu
J. J.
, Brolinson
P. G.
, Duma
S.
, McAllister
T. W.
, Duhaime
A.-C.
, and Greenwald
R. M.
, “Frequency and Location of Head Impact Exposures in Individual Collegiate Football Players
,” Journal of Athletic Training
45
, no. 6
(November–December 2010
): 549
–559
. https://doi.org/10.4085/1062-6050-45.6.54937.
Hutchison
M. G.
, Comper
P.
, Meeuwisse
W. H.
, and Echemendia
R. J.
, “A Systematic Video Analysis of National Hockey League (NHL) Concussions, Part II: How Concussions Occur in the NHL
,” British Journal of Sports Medicine
49
, no. 8
(2015
): 552
–555
. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2013-09223538.
O’Sullivan
D.
, Roe
M.
, and Blake
C.
, “Analysis of Head Impacts during Sub-Elite Hurling Practice Sessions
,” Journal of Sports Science
36
, no. 11
(June 2018
): 1256
–1261
. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640414.2017.1373196
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.
