The intercooled cycle (IC) is a simplified novel proposal for generation IV nuclear power plants (NPP) based on studies demonstrating efficiencies of over 45%. As an alternative to the simple cycle recuperated (SCR) and the intercooled cycle recuperated (ICR), the main difference in configuration is no recuperator, which reduces its size. It is expected that the components of the IC will not operate at optimum part power due to seasonal changes in ambient temperature and grid prioritization for renewable sources. Thus, the ability to demonstrate viable part load performance becomes an important requirement. The main objective of this study is to derive off-design points (ODPs) for a temperature range of −35 °C to 50 °C and core outlet temperatures (COTs) between 750 °C and 1000 °C. The ODPs have been calculated using a tool designed for this study. Based on the results, the intercooler changes the mass flow rate and compressor pressure ratio (PR). However, a drop of ∼9% in plant efficiency, in comparison to the ICR (6%) was observed for pressure losses of up to 5%. The reactor pressure losses for IC have the lowest effect on plant cycle efficiency in comparison to the SCR and ICR. Characteristic maps are created to support first-order calculations. It is also proposed to consider the intercooler pressure loss as a handle for ODP performance. The analyses brings attention to the IC an alternative cycle and aids development of cycles for generation IV NPPs specifically gas-cooled fast reactors (GFRs) and very-high-temperature reactors (VHTRs), using helium.

The generic concept of security controls, as initially deployed in the information security domain, is gradually used in other business domains, including industrial security for critical infrastructure and cybersecurity of nuclear safety instrumentation & control (I&C). A security control, or less formally, a security countermeasure can be any organizational, technical, or administrative measure that helps in reducing the risk imposed by a cybersecurity threat. The new IAEA NST036 lists more than 200 such countermeasures. NIST SP800-53 Revision 4 contains about 450 pages of security countermeasure descriptions, which are graded according to three levels of stringency. In order to facilitate and formalize the process of developing, precisely describing, distributing, and maintaining more complex security controls, the application security controls (ASC) concept is introduced by the new ISO/IEC 27034 multipart standard. An ASC is an extensible semiformal representation of a security control (extensible markup language or javascript object notation-based), which contains a set of mandatory and optional parts as well as possible links to other ASCs. A set of ASCs may be developed by one company and shipped together with a product of another company. ISO/IEC 27034-6 assumes that ASCs are developed by an organization or team specialized in security and that the ASCs are forwarded to customers for direct use or for integration into their own products or services. The distribution of ASCs is supported and formalized by the organization normative frameworks (ONFs) and application normative frameworks (ANFs) deployed in the respective organizational units. The maintenance and continuous improvement of ASCs is facilitated by the ONF process and ANF process. This paper will explore the applicability of these industry standards based ASC lifecycle concepts for the nuclear domain in line with IEC 62645, IEC 62859, and the upcoming IEC 63096. It will include results from an ongoing bachelor thesis and master thesis, mentored by two of the authors, as well as nuclear-specific deployment scenarios currently being evaluated by a team of cybersecurity Ph.D. candidates.

In an emergency condition of nuclear power plant, operators have to mitigate the accident in order to remove the decay heat and to prevent the release of radioactive material to the environment following the emergency operating procedures (EOPs). The action of operators on a component, for example, changing the parameter level of a component, which is described in a procedure step, will impact other components of the plant and the plant behavior. Nowadays, the advanced main control rooms have been equipped with the computer-based procedures (CBPs) which provide some features and benefits which are not available in paper-based procedures. However, most of CBPs do not provide information of the impact of the counteractions on each procedure step (components influenced and future plant behavior) although it is useful for operators to understand the purpose of the procedure steps before making decisions and taking the actions. This paper discusses the functional information and the method to generate the information using multilevel flow modeling (MFM) model of operator actions on some procedure steps of a simplified EOP of pressurized water reactor (PWR) plant, as an example.

The continuous generation of graphite dust particles in the core of a high-temperature reactor (HTR) is one of the key challenges of safety during its operation. The graphite dust particles emerge from relative movements between the fuel elements or from contact to the graphitic reflector structure and could be contaminated by diffused fission products from the fuel elements. They are distributed from the reactor core to the entire reactor coolant system. In case of a depressurization accident, a release of the contaminated dust into the confinement is possible. In addition, the contaminated graphite dust can decrease the life cycle of the coolant system due to chemical interactions. On one hand, the knowledge of the behavior of graphite dust particles under HTR conditions using helium as the flow medium is a key factor to develop an effective filter system for the discussed issue. On the other hand, it also provides a possibility to access the activity distribution in the reactor. The behavior can be subdivided into short-term effects like transport, deposition, remobilization and long-term effects like reactions with material surfaces. The Technische Universität Dresden has installed a new high-temperature test facility to study the short-term effects of deposition of graphite dust particles. The flow channel has a length of 5 m and a tube diameter of 0.05 m. With helium as the flow medium, the temperature can be up to 950 °C in the channel center and 120 °C on the sample surface, the Reynolds number can be varied from 150 up to 1000. The particles get dispersed into the accelerated and heated flow medium in the flow channel. Next, the aerosol is passing a 3 m long adiabatic section to ensure homogenous flow conditions. After passing the flow straightener, it enters the optically accessible measurement path made from quartz glass. In particular, this test facility offers the possibility to analyze the influence of the thermophoretic effect separately. For this, an optionally cooled sample can be placed in the measuring area. The thickness of the particle layer on the sample is estimated with a three-dimensional laser scanning microscope. The particle concentration above the sample is measured with an aerosol particle sizer (APS). Particle image velocimetry (PIV) detects the flow-velocity field and provides data to estimate the shear velocity. In combination with the measured temperature-field, all necessary information for the calculation of the particle deposition and particle relaxation times are available. The measurements are compared to results of theoretical works from the literature. The experimental database is relevant especially for computational fluid dynamics (CFD)-developers, for model development, and model verification. A wide range of phenomena like particle separation, local agglomeration of particles with a specific particle mass, and selective remobilization can be explained in this way. Thus, this work contributes to a realistic analysis of nuclear safety.

In a natural circulation boiling water reactor (BWR), the core power varies in both axial and radial directions inside the reactor core. The variation along the axial direction is more or less constant throughout the reactor; however, there exists variation of reactor power in the radial direction. The channels located at the periphery have low power compared to the center of the core and are equipped with orifices at their inlet. This creates nonuniformity in the radial direction in the core. This study has been performed in order to understand the effect of this radial variation of power on the stability characteristics of the reactor. Four channels of a pressure tube type natural circulation BWR have been considered. The reactor has been modeled using RELAP5/MOD 3.2. Before using the model, it was first benchmarked with experimental measurements and then the characteristics of both low power and high power oscillations, respectively, known as type-I and type-II instability, have been investigated. It was observed that the type-I instability shows slight destabilizing effect of increase in power variation among different channels. However, in the case of type-II instability, it was found out that the oscillations get damped with an increase in power variation among the channels. A similar effect was found for the presence of orifices at the inlet in different channels. However, the increase in number of orificed channels showed stabilizing effect for both type-I and type-II instabilities.

The Great East Japan Earthquake on Mar. 11, 2011 triggered huge tsunami waves that attacked Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant (Fukushima-1). Units 1, 3, and 4 had hydrogen explosions. Units 1–3 had core meltdowns and released a large amount of radioactive material. Published investigation reports did not explain how the severity of the accident could have been prevented. We formed a study group to find: (A) Was the earthquake-induced huge tsunami predictable at Fukushima-1? (B) If it was predictable, what preparations at Fukushima-1 could have avoided the severity of the accident? Our conclusions were: (a) The tsunami that hit Fukushima-1 was predictable, and (b) the severity could have been avoided if the plant had prepared a set of equipment, and most of all, had exercised actions to take against such tsunami. Necessary preparation included: (1) a number of direct current (DC) batteries, (2) portable underwater pumps, (3) portable alternating current (AC) generators with sufficient gasoline supply, (4) high voltage AC power trucks, and (5) drills against extended loss of all electric power and seawater pumps. This set applied only to this specific accident. A thorough preparation would have added (6) portable compressors, (7) watertight modification to reactor core isolation cooling system (RCIC) and high pressure coolant injection system (HPCI) control and instrumentation, and (8) fire engines for alternate low pressure water injection. Item (5), i.e., to study plans and carry out exercises against the tsunami would have identified all other necessary preparations.

The United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission (USNRC) has approved several extended power uprates (EPU) for Boiling Water Reactors (BWRs). In some of the BWRs, operating at the higher EPU power levels and flow rates led to high-cycle fatigue damage of Steam Dryers, including the generation of loose parts. Since those failures occurred, all BWR owners proposing EPUs have been required by the USNRC to ensure that the steam dryers would not experience high-cycle fatigue cracking. This paper provides an overview of BWR steam dryer design; the fatigue failures that occurred at the Quad Cities (QC) nuclear power plants and their root causes; a brief history of BWR EPUs; and a discussion of steam dryer modifications/replacements, alternating stress mechanisms on steam dryers, and structural integrity evaluation methods (static and alternating stress).

The intermittency of renewable power generation systems on the low carbon electric grid can be alleviated by using nuclear systems as quasi-storage systems. Nuclear air-Brayton systems can produce and store hydrogen when electric generation is abundant and then burn the hydrogen by co-firing when generation is limited. The rated output of a nuclear plant can be significantly augmented by co-firing. The incremental efficiency of hydrogen to electricity can far exceed that of hydrogen in a standalone gas turbine. Herein, we simulate and evaluate this idea on a 50 MW small modular liquid metal/molten salt reactor. Considerable power increases are predicted for nuclear air-Brayton systems by co-firing with hydrogen before the power turbine.

An important requirement for Generation IV Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) design is the control system, which enables part power operability. The choices of control system methods must ensure variation of load without severe drawbacks on cycle performance. The objective of this study is to assess the control of the NPP under part power operations. The cycles of interest are the simple cycle recuperated (SCR) and the intercooled cycle recuperated (ICR). Control strategies are proposed for NPPs but the focus is on the strategies that result in part power operation using the inventory control method. First, results explaining the performance and load limiting factors of the inventory control method are documented; subsequently, the transient part power performances are also documented. The load versus efficiency curves were also derived from varying the load to understand the efficiency penalties. This is carried out using a modeling and performance simulation tool designed for this study. Results show that the ICR takes ∼102% longer than the SCR to reduce the load to 50% in design point (DP) performance conditions for similar valve flows, which correlates with the volumetric increase for the ICR inventory tank. The efficiency penalties are comparable for both cycles at 50% part power, whereby a 22% drop in cycle efficiency was observed and indicates limiting time at very low part power. The analyses intend to aid the development of cycles for Generation IV NPPs specifically gas cooled fast reactors (GFRs) and very high-temperature reactors (VHTRs), where helium is the coolant.

Nondestructive testing (NDT) techniques are widely used as a reliable way for preventing failures and helping in the maintenance design and operation of critical infrastructures and complex industrial plants as nuclear power plants (NPPs). Among the NDT techniques, guided waves (GWs) are a very promising technology for such applications. GWs are structure-borne ultrasonic waves propagating along the structure confined and guided by its geometric boundaries. Testing using GWs is able to find defect locations through long-range screening using low-frequency waves (from 5 to 250 kHz). The technology is regularly used for pipe testing in the oil and gas industry. In the nuclear industry, regulators are working to standardize monitoring and inspection procedures. To use the technology inside an active plant, operators must solve issues like high temperatures (up to more than 300 °C inside a light-water reactor's primary piping), high wall thickness of components in the primary circuit, and characteristic defect typologies. Magnetostrictive sensors are expected to overcome such issues due to their physical properties, namely, robust constitution and simplicity. Recent experimental results have demonstrated that magnetostrictive transducers can withstand temperatures close to 300 °C. In this paper, the GW technology will be introduced in the context of NPPs. Some experimental tests conducted using such a methodology for steel pipe having a complex structure will be described, and open issues related to high-temperature guided wave applications (e.g., wave velocity or amplitude fluctuations during propagation in variable temperature components) will be discussed.

The control system for generation IV nuclear power plant (NPP) design must ensure load variation when changes to critical parameters affect grid demand, plant efficiency, and component integrity. The objective of this study is to assess the load following capabilities of cycles when inventory pressure control is utilized. Cycles of interest are simple cycle recuperated (SCR), intercooled cycle recuperated (ICR), and intercooled cycle without recuperation (IC). First, part power performance of the IC is compared to results of the SCR and ICR. Subsequently, the load following capabilities are assessed when the cycle inlet temperatures are varied. This was carried out using a tool designed for this study. Results show that the IC takes ∼2.7% longer than the ICR to reduce the power output to 50% when operating in design point (DP) for similar valve flows, which correlates to the volumetric increase for the IC inventory storage tank. However, the ability of the IC to match the ICR's load following capabilities is severely hindered because the IC is most susceptible to temperature variation. Furthermore, the IC takes longer than the SCR and ICR to regulate the reactor power by a factor of 51 but this is severely reduced, when regulating NPP power output. However, the IC is the only cycle that does not compromise reactor integrity and cycle efficiency when regulating the power. The analyses intend to aid the development of cycles specifically gas-cooled fast reactors (GFRs) and very high temperature reactors (VHTRs), where helium is the coolant.

To respond to the urgent needs of verification, training, and drill for full scope severe accident management guidelines (FSSAMG) among nuclear regulators, utilities, and research institutes, the FSSAMG verification and drill system is developed. The FSSAMG includes comprehensive scenarios under power condition, shutdown condition, spent fuel pool (SFP) condition, and refueling conditions. This article summarized the research and development of validation and drill system for FSSAMG by using the severe accident analysis computer code modular accident analysis program 5 (MAAP5). Realistic accident scenarios can be verified and exercised in the developed system to support FSSAMG training, drill, examination, and verification.

Novel genetic algorithms (GAs) are developed by using state-of-the-art selection and crossover operators, e.g., rank selection or tournament selection instead of the traditional roulette (fitness proportionate (FP)) selection operator and novel crossover and mutation operators by considering the chromosomes as permutations (which is a specific feature of the loading pattern (LP) problem). The algorithm is applied to a representative model of a modern pressurized water reactor (PWR) core and implemented using a single objective fitness function (FF), i.e., k eff . The results obtained for some reference cases using this setup are excellent. They are obtained using a tournament selection operator with a linear ranking (LR) selection probability method and a new geometric crossover operator that allows for geometrical, rather than random, swaps of gene segments between the chromosomes and control over the sizes of the swapped segments. Finally, the effect of boundary conditions (BCs) on the symmetry of the obtained best solutions is studied and the validity of the “symmetric loading patterns” assumption is tested.

Inspections of pressure tubes in CANDU ® reactors are a key part of maintaining safe operating conditions. The current inspection system, the channel inspection and gauging apparatus for reactors (CIGAR), performs the job well but is limited by the fact that it can only inspect one channel at a time. A multidisciplinary team is currently developing a novel robotic inspection system. As part of this work, a Monte Carlo N-particle (MCNP) model has been developed in order to predict the dose rates that the improved inspection system will be exposed to and, from this, predict the component lifetime. This MCNP model will be capable of predicting in-core dose rates at any location within the reactor, and as such could be used for other situations where the in-core dose rate needs to be known. Based on estimates from this model, it is expected that at 7 days after shutdown, the improved inspection system could survive in core for approximately 7 h, providing it uses a tungsten shield 2.5 cm in thickness around the integrated circuit components. This is expected to be sufficient to perform a single inspection.

The aim of this paper is to summarize authors' experience in adaptation of an existing plant-specific VVER-1000/V320 model for simulation of a rare example of a Kalinin 3 nuclear power plant (NPP) transient of “switching-off of one of the four operating main circulation pumps at nominal reactor power” with an asymmetric core configuration. The fidelity and accuracy of simulation with emphasis on reactor core model is illustrated through comparison with plant-specific data. Simulation results concerning fuel assembly (FA) power and axial power distribution during the transient are compared with records from Kalinin 3 in-core monitoring system (ICMS). Main operating parameters of nuclear steam supply system of a VVER-1000/V320 series units vary to a considerable degree. While Kalinin 3 benchmark specification contains very good description of the transient, as well as record of many parameters of the unit, the document provides only superficial description of the reference unit. In such a case, an approach based on a “generic” V320 model by default introduces deviations which are difficult to quantify. There are several examples which warrant discussion. Some of the most important lessons learned are as follows. (1) individual characteristics of all the main circulation pumps and the reactor coolant loops are quite important for the quality of simulation and should be accounted for in the model; (2) variations in fuel assembly characteristics should be accounted for not only in terms of macroscopic cross section library but also in terms of local pressure loss coefficients and mixing factors in the case of mixed core loads; (3) comprehensive plant-specific model of dynamic response of instrumentation and control (I&C) systems is a necessity; dynamic characteristics of individual measurement channels (nuclear instrumentation, pressure, temperature) should be accounted for; and (4) comprehensive plant-specific model of balance-of-plant equipment, instrumentation, and control is a necessity. Above requirements impose a difficult task to comply with. Nevertheless, any individual nuclear power unit is supposed to maintain a detailed design database and data requirements for plant-specific model development should be considered.

The potential for high turbine entry temperature (TETs) turbines for nuclear power plants (NPPs) requires improved materials and sophisticated cooling. Cooling is critical for maintaining mechanical integrity of the turbine for temperatures >1000 °C. Increasing TET is one of the solutions for improving efficiency after cycle optimum pressure ratios have been achieved but cooling as a percentage of mass flow will have to increase, resulting in cycle efficiency penalties. To limit this effect, it is necessary to know the maximum allowable blade metal temperature to ensure that the minimum cooling fraction is used. The main objective of this study is to analyze the thermal efficiencies of four cycles in the 300–700 MW class for generation IV NPPs, using two different turbines with optimum cooling for TETs between 950 and 1200 °C. The cycles analyzed are simple cycle (SC), simple cycle recuperated (SCR), intercooled cycle (IC), and intercooled cycle recuperated (ICR). Although results showed that deterioration of cycle performance is lower when using improved turbine material, the justification to use optimum cooling improves the cycle significantly when a recuperator is used. Furthermore, optimized cooling flow and the introduction of an intercooler improve cycle efficiency by >3%, which is >1% more than previous studies. Finally, the study highlights the potential of cycle performance beyond 1200 °C for IC. This is based on the IC showing the least performance deterioration. The analyses intend to aid development of cycles for deployment in gas-cooled fast reactors (GFRs) and very high-temperature reactors (VHTRs).

A pipe-wall thinning measurement is a key inspection to ensure the integrity of the piping system in nuclear power plants. To monitor the integrity of the piping system, a number of ultrasonic thickness measurements are manually performed during the outage of the nuclear power plant. Since most of the pipes are covered with an insulator, removing the insulator is necessary for the ultrasonic thickness measurement. Noncontact ultrasonic sensors enable ultrasonic thickness inspection without removing the insulator. This leads to reduction of the inspection time and reduced radiation exposure of the inspector. The inductively-coupled transducer system (ICTS) is a noncontact ultrasonic sensor system which uses electromagnetic induction between coils to drive an installed transducer. In this study, we investigated the applicability of an innovative ICTS developed at the University of Bristol to nuclear power plant inspection, particularly pipe-wall thinning inspection. The following experiments were performed using ICTS: thickness measurement performance, the effect of the coil separation, the effect of the insulator, the effect of different inspection materials, the radiation tolerance, and the measurement accuracy of wastage defects. These initial experimental results showed that the ICTS has the possibility to enable wall-thinning inspection in nuclear power plants without removing the insulator. Future work will address the issue of measuring wall-thinning in more complex pipework geometries and at elevated temperatures.

Probabilistic safety assessment (PSA) of nuclear power plants is performed to yield insights into the safety, design, and performance of the plants and their potential environmental effects. This includes the identification of dominant risk contributors, determination of the vulnerabilities of plant and containment systems, and comparison of options for risk reduction. Three levels of PSA are recognized. Level-1 addresses the identification of plant failures leading to core damage and their frequencies of occurrence. Level-2 addresses the assessment of containment response leading together with level-1 results to the determination of containment release frequencies. A level-2 PSA analyses the challenges to the containment, the possible containment responses and their estimated probabilities, and an assessment of the consequent releases to the environment. Level-3 is the assessment of off-site consequences leading, together with the results of level-2 analysis, for estimation of public risks. A comprehensive level-2 PSA study of a 220 MW e Indian Pressurized Heavy Water Reactor (IPHWR) is performed to assess the challenges to the containment, the possible containment responses and their estimated probabilities, and consequent releases to the environment. The dominating sequences consist of small-break loss of coolant accident (SBLOCA) and station black out (SBO) followed by containment isolation failure. The results of this are used as an input for developing the severe accident management guidelines (SAMG) measures. All the SAMG measures incorporated in this study have been found as beneficial and resulted in reduced large early release frequency (LERF).

In selecting the materials for the Canadian supercritical water-cooled reactor (SCWR), the effects and extent of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) on candidate alloys of construction, under various operational conditions, must be considered. Several methods of applying stress to a corroding material are available for investigating SCC and each have their benefits and drawbacks; for simplicity of the experimental setup at University of New Brunswick (UNB), a constant load C-ring assembly has been used with Inconel 718 Belleville washers acting as a spring to deliver a near-constant load to the sample. To predict the stress at the apex of the C-ring, a mechanistic model has been developed to determine the force applied by the spring due to the thermal expansion of each component constrained within a fixed length when the temperature of the assembly is increased from ambient conditions to SCWR operational temperatures. In an attempt to validate the mechanistic model, trials to measure the force applied by the washers as the assembly thermally expanded were performed using an Instron machine and an environmental chamber. Accounting for the thermal expansion of the pull rods, the force was measured as temperature was increased while maintaining a constant displacement between the platens holding the C-ring. Results showed the initial model to be insufficient as it could not predict the force measured through this simple experiment. The revised model presented here considers the thermal expansion of the C-ring and all the components of the testing apparatus including the tree, backing washers, and Belleville washers. Further validation using the commercial finite element (FE) package abaqus is presented, as are preliminary results from the use of the apparatus to study the SCC of a zirconium-modified 310 s SS exposed to supercritical water.

Small modular nuclear reactors (SMRs) are designed for long-term operation with minimum outages and for possible deployment in remote locations. To achieve this operational goal, the SMRs may require remote and continuous monitoring of performance parameters that contribute to operation and maintenance. This feature is also important in monitoring critical parameters during severe accidents and for postaccident recovery. Small integral light water reactors have in-vessel space constraints, and many of the traditional instrumentation are not practical in these systems. To investigate this issue, analytical and experimental researches were carried out using a flow test loop to characterize the relationship among process variables (flow rate and pressure) and pump motor signatures. The findings of this research are presented, with implications in relating electrical signatures to pump parameters. The relationship between the electrical signatures and the process variables is discussed with reference to the experimental results. The results of this work may be used for monitoring process variables in small modular reactor systems.