One of the greatest challenges in the manufacturing and development of nanotechnologies is the requirement for robust, reliable, and accurate characterization data. Presented here are the results of an interlaboratory comparison (ILC) brought about through multiple rounds of engagement with NanoSight Malvern and ten pan-European research facilities. Following refinement of the nanoparticle tracking analysis (NTA) technique, the size and concentration characterization of nanoparticles in liquid suspension was proven to be robust and reproducible for multiple sample types in monomodal, binary, or multimodal mixtures. The limits of measurement were shown to exceed the 30–600 nm range (with all system models), with percentage coefficients of variation (% CV) being calculated as sub 5% for monodisperse samples. Particle size distributions were also improved through the incorporation of the finite track length adjustment (FTLA) algorithm, which most noticeably acts to improve the resolution of multimodal sample mixtures. The addition of a software correction to account for variations between instruments also dramatically increased the accuracy and reproducibility of concentration measurements. When combined, the advances brought about during the interlaboratory comparisons allow for the simultaneous determination of accurate and precise nanoparticle sizing and concentration data in one measurement.
Benchmark of Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis on Measuring Nanoparticle Sizing and Concentration
AMBER Centre and CRANN Institute,
Trinity College Dublin,
Dublin 2, Ireland;
Trinity Centre for Health Sciences,
Trinity Translational Medicine Institute,
St. James's Hospital,
James Street,
Dublin 8, Ireland
e-mail: cmmaguir@tcd.ie
Minton Park, London Road,
Amesbury SP4 7RT, Wiltshire, UK
e-mail: ksillence@hotmail.co.uk
Laboratory for Particles—Biology Interactions,
EMPA,
Lerchenfeldstrasse 5,
St. Gallen CH-9014, Switzerland
e-mail: matthias.roesslein@empa.ch
Minton Park, London Road,
Amesbury SP4 7RT, Wiltshire, UK
e-mail: clairehannell@gmail.com
Institute for Work and Health (IST),
Rte de la Corniche 2, 1066 Epalinges,
Lausanne 1011, Switzerland
e-mail: guillaume.suarez@chuv.ch
Institute for Work and Health (IST),
Rte de la Corniche 2, 1066 Epalinges,
Lausanne 1011, Switzerland
e-mail: jean-jacques.sauvain@hospvd.ch
1415 Washington Heights, Room 6611,
Ann Arbor, MI 48109
e-mail: sonja.capracotta@malvern.com
Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST),
41, rue du Brill,
Belvaux L-4422, Grand-duchy of Luxembourg
e-mail: servane.contal@list.lu
Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST),
41, rue du Brill,
Belvaux L-4422, Grand-duchy of Luxembourg
e-mail: sebastien.cambier@list.lu
MILK, Norwegian Institute for Air Research,
Instituttveien 18, P.O. Box 100,
Kjeller NO-2027, Norway
e-mail: elyamani.naouale@nilu.no
MILK, Norwegian Institute for Air Research,
Instituttveien 18, P.O. Box 100,
Kjeller NO-2027, Norway
e-mail: maria.dusinska@nilu.no
Natural History Museum,
Cromwell Road,
London SW7 5BD, UK
e-mail: a.dybowska@nhm.ac.uk
Mendelstrasse 11,
Münster 48149, Germany
e-mail: vennemann@ibe-ms.de
Conway Institute,
University College Dublin,
Belfield,
Dublin 4, Ireland
e-mail: laura000cooke@gmail.com
German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR),
Max-Dohrn-Strasse 8-10,
Berlin 10589, Germany
e-mail: andrea.haase@bfr.bund.de
German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR),
Max-Dohrn-Strasse 8-10,
Berlin 10589, Germany
e-mail: andreas.luch@bfr.bund.de
Mendelstrasse 11,
Münster 48149, Germany
e-mail: martin.wiemann@ibe-ms.de
Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST),
41, rue du Brill,
Belvaux L-4422, Grand-duchy of Luxembourg
e-mail: arno.gutleb@list.lu
Sackler School of Medicine,
Tel Aviv 69978, Israel
e-mail: korens@post.tau.ac.il
Institute of Occupational Medicine Singapore Pte. Ltd.,
30 Raffles Place, #17-08 Chevron House,
Singapore 048622, Singapore
e-mail: michael.riediker@iom-world.sg
Laboratory for Particles—Biology Interactions,
Lerchenfeldstrasse 5,
St. Gallen CH-9014, Switzerland
e-mail: peter.wick@empa.ch
Minton Park, London Road,
Amesbury SP4 7RT, Wiltshire, UK
e-mail: patrick.hole@malvern.com
AMBER Centre and CRANN Institute,
Trinity College Dublin,
Dublin 2, Ireland;
Trinity Centre for Health Sciences,
Trinity Translational Medicine Institute,
St. James's Hospital,
James Street,
Dublin 8, Ireland
e-mail: prinamea@tcd.ie
AMBER Centre and CRANN Institute,
Trinity College Dublin,
Dublin 2, Ireland;
Trinity Centre for Health Sciences,
Trinity Translational Medicine Institute,
St. James's Hospital,
James Street,
Dublin 8, Ireland
e-mail: cmmaguir@tcd.ie
Minton Park, London Road,
Amesbury SP4 7RT, Wiltshire, UK
e-mail: ksillence@hotmail.co.uk
Laboratory for Particles—Biology Interactions,
EMPA,
Lerchenfeldstrasse 5,
St. Gallen CH-9014, Switzerland
e-mail: matthias.roesslein@empa.ch
Minton Park, London Road,
Amesbury SP4 7RT, Wiltshire, UK
e-mail: clairehannell@gmail.com
Institute for Work and Health (IST),
Rte de la Corniche 2, 1066 Epalinges,
Lausanne 1011, Switzerland
e-mail: guillaume.suarez@chuv.ch
Institute for Work and Health (IST),
Rte de la Corniche 2, 1066 Epalinges,
Lausanne 1011, Switzerland
e-mail: jean-jacques.sauvain@hospvd.ch
1415 Washington Heights, Room 6611,
Ann Arbor, MI 48109
e-mail: sonja.capracotta@malvern.com
Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST),
41, rue du Brill,
Belvaux L-4422, Grand-duchy of Luxembourg
e-mail: servane.contal@list.lu
Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST),
41, rue du Brill,
Belvaux L-4422, Grand-duchy of Luxembourg
e-mail: sebastien.cambier@list.lu
MILK, Norwegian Institute for Air Research,
Instituttveien 18, P.O. Box 100,
Kjeller NO-2027, Norway
e-mail: elyamani.naouale@nilu.no
MILK, Norwegian Institute for Air Research,
Instituttveien 18, P.O. Box 100,
Kjeller NO-2027, Norway
e-mail: maria.dusinska@nilu.no
Natural History Museum,
Cromwell Road,
London SW7 5BD, UK
e-mail: a.dybowska@nhm.ac.uk
Mendelstrasse 11,
Münster 48149, Germany
e-mail: vennemann@ibe-ms.de
Conway Institute,
University College Dublin,
Belfield,
Dublin 4, Ireland
e-mail: laura000cooke@gmail.com
German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR),
Max-Dohrn-Strasse 8-10,
Berlin 10589, Germany
e-mail: andrea.haase@bfr.bund.de
German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR),
Max-Dohrn-Strasse 8-10,
Berlin 10589, Germany
e-mail: andreas.luch@bfr.bund.de
Mendelstrasse 11,
Münster 48149, Germany
e-mail: martin.wiemann@ibe-ms.de
Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST),
41, rue du Brill,
Belvaux L-4422, Grand-duchy of Luxembourg
e-mail: arno.gutleb@list.lu
Sackler School of Medicine,
Tel Aviv 69978, Israel
e-mail: korens@post.tau.ac.il
Institute of Occupational Medicine Singapore Pte. Ltd.,
30 Raffles Place, #17-08 Chevron House,
Singapore 048622, Singapore
e-mail: michael.riediker@iom-world.sg
Laboratory for Particles—Biology Interactions,
Lerchenfeldstrasse 5,
St. Gallen CH-9014, Switzerland
e-mail: peter.wick@empa.ch
Minton Park, London Road,
Amesbury SP4 7RT, Wiltshire, UK
e-mail: patrick.hole@malvern.com
AMBER Centre and CRANN Institute,
Trinity College Dublin,
Dublin 2, Ireland;
Trinity Centre for Health Sciences,
Trinity Translational Medicine Institute,
St. James's Hospital,
James Street,
Dublin 8, Ireland
e-mail: prinamea@tcd.ie
Contributed by the Manufacturing Engineering Division of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF MICRO- AND NANO-MANUFACTURING. Manuscript received January 24, 2017; final manuscript received June 12, 2017; published online September 28, 2017. Assoc. Editor: Rajiv Malhotra.
Maguire, C. M., Sillence, K., Roesslein, M., Hannell, C., Suarez, G., Sauvain, J., Capracotta, S., Contal, S., Cambier, S., El Yamani, N., Dusinska, M., Dybowska, A., Vennemann, A., Cooke, L., Haase, A., Luch, A., Wiemann, M., Gutleb, A., Korenstein, R., Riediker, M., Wick, P., Hole, P., and Prina-Mello, A. (September 28, 2017). "Benchmark of Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis on Measuring Nanoparticle Sizing and Concentration." ASME. J. Micro Nano-Manuf. December 2017; 5(4): 041002. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4037124
Download citation file: