A common recommendation when designing for disassembly is to develop more modular products. The common belief is that an increase in modularity will systematically reduce the time required in order to disassemble the product, reducing the cost of the process. This paper studies the statistical relationship between these two concepts by comparing 15 different electrical products. Modularity and disassembly performance are assessed by different indicators each and their correlation is analyzed. The results show that the aforementioned relationship cannot be statistically proven and, for some of the cases, even inverse correlation is found. Factors such as product structure or selected end-of-life strategy are more important than modularity in end-of-life performance. Systematic modularization can even result in products with a worse behavior: For most electrical equipment, generating modules from a functional or manufacturing point of view will most probably result in worse end-of-life performance. It is only for modules with very specific properties that performance can be guaranteed.

1.
European Commission
, 2003, “
Directive 2002/96/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 January 2003 on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE)
,” Official Journal of the European Union, L37/26.
2.
Rose
,
C.
, 2000, “
Design for Environment: A Method for Formulating End-of-Life Strategies
,” Ph.D. thesis, Stanford University, CA.
3.
Bryant
,
C. R.
,
Sivaramkrishnan
,
K. L.
,
Van Wie
,
M.
,
Stone
,
R. B.
, and
McAdams
,
D. A.
, 2004, “
A Modular Design Approach to Support Sustainable Design
,”
Proceedings of the ASME 2004 Design Engineering Technical Conference and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference
, Salt Lake City, UT.
4.
Newcomb
,
P. J.
,
Bras
,
B.
, and
Rosen
,
D. W.
, 1998, “
Implications of Modularity on Product Design for the Life Cycle
,”
ASME J. Mech. Des.
0161-8458,
120
, pp.
483
490
.
5.
Gu
,
P.
, and
Sosale
,
S.
, 1999, “
Product Modularization for Life Cycle Engineering
,”
Rob. Comput.-Integr. Manufact.
0736-5845,
15
, pp.
387
401
.
6.
Gershenson
,
J. K.
,
Prasad
,
G. J.
, and
Zhang
,
Y.
, 2003, “
Product Modularity: Definitions and Benefits
,”
J. Eng. Design
0954-4828,
14
(
3
), pp.
295
313
.
7.
Zhang
,
Y.
, and
Gershenson
,
J. K.
, 2002, “
Questioning the Direct Relation Between Product Modularity and Retirement Cost
,”
Journal of Sustainable Product Design
1573-1588,
2
, pp.
53
68
.
8.
Zhang
,
Y.
, and
Gershenson
,
J. K.
, 2003, “
An Initial Study of Direct Relationships Between Life-Cycle Modularity and Life-Cycle Cost
,”
Concurr. Eng. Res. Appl.
1063-293X,
11
(
2
), pp.
121
128
.
9.
Gershenson
,
J. K.
,
Prasad
,
G. J.
, and
Zhang
,
Y.
, 2004, “
Product Modularity: Measures and Design Methods
,”
J. Eng. Design
0954-4828,
15
(
1
), pp.
33
51
.
10.
Sosa
,
M. E.
,
Eppinger
,
S. D.
, and
Rowles
,
C. M.
, 2003, “
Identifying Modular and Integrative Systems and Their Impact on Design Team Interactions
,”
ASME J. Mech. Des.
0161-8458,
125
, pp.
240
252
.
11.
Güngör
,
A.
, and
Gupta
,
S. M.
, 2002, “
Disassembly Line in Product Recovery
,”
Int. J. Prod. Res.
0020-7543,
40
(
11
), pp.
2569
2589
.
12.
Tonnelier
,
P.
,
Millet
,
D.
,
Richir
,
S.
, and
Lecoq
,
M.
, 2005, “
Is it Possible to Evaluate the Recovery Potential Earlier in the Design Process? Proposal of a Qualitative Evaluation Tool
,”
J. Eng. Design
0954-4828,
16
(
3
), pp.
297
309
.
13.
Ardente
,
F.
,
Beccali
,
G.
, and
Cellura
,
M.
, 2003, “
Eco-Sustainable Energy and Environmental Strategies in Design for Recycling: The Software ‘ENDLESS’
,”
Ecol. Modell.
0304-3800,
163
, pp.
101
118
.
14.
Hula
,
A.
,
Jalali
,
K.
,
Haniza
,
K.
,
Skerlos
,
S. J.
, and
Saitou
,
K.
, 2003, “
Multi-Criteria Decision-Making for Optimization of Product Disassembly Under Multiple Situations
,”
Environ. Sci. Technol.
0013-936X,
37
(
23
), pp.
5303
5313
.
15.
Rios
,
P.
,
Blyler
,
L.
,
Tieman
,
L.
,
Stuart
,
J. A.
, and
Grant
,
E.
, 2003, “
A Symbolic Methodology to Improve Disassembly Process Design
,”
Environ. Sci. Technol.
0013-936X,
37
(
23
), pp.
5417
5423
.
16.
Güngör
,
A.
, and
Gupta
,
S. M.
, 2001, “
Disassembly Sequence Plan Generation Using Branch-and-Bound Algorithm
,”
Int. J. Prod. Res.
0020-7543,
39
(
3
), pp.
481
509
.
17.
Lambert
,
A. J. D.
, 2002, “
Determining Optimal Disassembly Sequences in Electronic Equipment
,”
Comput. Ind. Eng.
0360-8352,
43
, pp.
553
575
.
18.
Di Marco
,
P.
,
Eubanks
,
C. F.
, and
Ishii
,
K.
, 1994, “
Compatibility Analysis of Product Design for Recyclability and Reuse
,”
Proceedings of the ASME 1994 Design Engineering Technical Conference and Computers in Engineering Conference
, Minneapolis, MN.
19.
Rai
,
R.
,
Rai
,
V.
,
Tiwari
,
M. K.
, and
Allada
,
C.
, 2002, “
Disassembly Sequence Generation: A Petri Net Based Heuristic Approach
,”
Int. J. Prod. Res.
0020-7543,
40
(
13
), pp.
3183
3198
.
20.
Dini
,
G.
,
Faili
,
F.
, and
Santochi
,
M.
, 2001, “
A Disassembly Planning Software System for the Optimization of Recycling Processes
,”
Prod. Plann. Contr.
,
12
(
1
), pp.
2
12
.
21.
Moore
,
K. E.
,
Güngör
,
A.
, and
Gupta
,
S. M.
, 2001, “
Petri Net Approach to Disassembly Process Planning for Products With Complex AND/OR Relationships
,”
Eur. J. Oper. Res.
0377-2217,
135
, pp.
428
449
.
22.
Kuo
,
T. C.
, 2000, “
Disassembly Sequence and Cost Analysis for Electromechanical Products
,”
Rob. Comput.-Integr. Manufact.
0736-5845,
16
, pp.
43
54
.
23.
Ishii
,
K.
, 1998, “
Modularity: A Key Concept in Product Life-Cycle Engineering
,”
Handbook of Life-cycle Engineering
,
A.
Molina
,
J. M.
Sánchez
, and
A.
Kusiak
, eds.,
Kluwer
,
Dordrecht
.
24.
Pahl
,
G.
, and
Beitz
,
W.
, 1996,
Engineering Design: A Systematic Approach
,
1st ed.
,
Springer-Verlag
,
Berlin
.
25.
Ulrich
,
K. T.
, and
Eppinger
,
S. D.
, 1995,
Product Design and Development
,
1st ed.
,
McGraw-Hill
,
New York
.
26.
Kota
,
S.
,
Sethuraman
,
K.
, and
Miller
,
R.
, 2000, “
A Metric for Evaluating Design Commonality in Product Families
,”
ASME J. Mech. Des.
0161-8458,
122
, pp.
403
410
.
27.
Suh
,
N. P.
, 1990,
The Principles of Design
,
Oxford University Press
,
New York
.
28.
Ullman
,
D. G.
, 1997,
The Mechanical Design Process
,
2nd ed.
,
McGraw-Hill
,
New York
.
29.
Tanskanen
,
P.
, and
Takala
,
R.
, 2006, “
A Decomposition of the End of Life Process
,”
J. Cleaner Prod.
0959-6526,
14
, pp.
1326
1332
.
30.
Kusiak
,
A.
, 2002, “
Integrated Product and Process Design: A Modularity Perspective
,”
J. Eng. Design.
,
13
(
3
), pp.
223
231
.
31.
Huang
,
C. C.
, and
Kusiak
,
A.
, 1998, “
Modularity in Design of Products and Systems
,”
IEEE Trans. Syst. Man Cybern. A Syst. Hum.
,
28
(
1
), pp.
66
77
.
32.
Jones
,
N.
,
Harrison
,
D.
,
Hussein
,
H.
,
Billete
,
E.
, and
Chiodo
,
J.
, 2003, “
Towards Self-Disassembling Vehicles
,”
Journal of Sustainable Product Design
1573-1588,
3
, pp.
59
74
.
33.
Shalaby
,
M.
, and
Saitou
,
K.
, 2009, “
High-Stiffness, Lock-and-Key Heat-Reversible Locator-Snap Systems for the Design for Disassembly
,”
ASME J. Mech. Des.
0161-8458,
131
(
4
), pp.
041005
-1–041005-
9
.
34.
Shalaby
,
M.
, and
Saitou
,
K.
, 2008, “
Design for Disassembly With High-Stiffness Heat-Reversible Locator-Snap Systems
,”
ASME J. Mech. Des.
0161-8458,
130
(
12
), pp.
121701
-1–121701-
7
.
35.
Johnson
,
M. R.
, and
Wang
,
M. H.
, 1998, “
Economical Evaluation of Disassembly Operations for Recycling, Remanufacturing and Reuse
,”
Int. J. Prod. Res.
0020-7543,
36
(
12
), pp.
3227
3252
.
36.
Pnueli
,
Y.
, and
Zussman
,
E.
, 1997, “
Evaluating the End-of-Life Value of a Product and Improving It by Redesigning
,”
Int. J. Prod. Res.
0020-7543,
35
(
4
), pp.
921
942
.
37.
Lee
,
S. G.
,
Lye
,
S. W.
, and
Khoo
,
M. K.
, 2001, “
A Multi-Objective Methodology for Evaluating Product End-of-Life Options and Disassembly
,”
Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol.
0268-3768,
18
, pp.
148
156
.
38.
Collado-Ruiz
,
D.
, 2007, “
Propuesta prescriptiva para la integración del ecodiseño y el diseño para el reciclaje en el proceso de desarrollo de productos
,” Ph.D. thesis, Universidad Politécnica de Valencia, Spain.
39.
Leech
,
N. L.
,
Barrett
,
K. C.
, and
Morgan
,
G. A.
, 2004,
SPSS for Intermediate Statistics: Use and Interpretation
,
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
,
London
.
40.
Morgan
,
G. A.
,
Leech
,
N. L.
,
Gloeckner
,
G. W.
, and
Barrett
,
K. C.
, 2004,
SPSS for Introductory Statistics: Use and Interpretation
,
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
,
London
.
You do not currently have access to this content.