Virtual reality (VR) interfaces have the potential to enhance the engineering design process, but before industry embraces them, the benefits must be understood and documented. The current research compared two software applications, one which uses a traditional human-computer interface (HCI) and one which uses a virtual reality HCI, that were developed to aid engineers in designing complex three-dimensional spherical mechanisms. Participants used each system to design a spherical mechanism and then evaluated the different interfaces. Participants rated their ability to interact with the computer images, their feelings about each interface, and their preferences for which interface device to use for certain tasks. The results indicated that participants preferred a traditional interface for interaction tasks and a VR interface for visual tasks. These results provide information about how to improve implementation of VR technology, specifically for complex three-dimensional design applications.

1.
Alba, J. W., and Hasher, L., 1983, “Is Memory Schematic?” Psychological Bulletin, 93, pp. 203–231.
2.
Ascension Technology Corporation, 1996, The Flock of Birds Position and Orientation Measurement System Installation and Operation Guide, Burlington, VT. Author.
3.
Barfield, W., and Furness, T., 1995, Virtual Environment and Advanced Interface Design, New York, Oxford University Press.
4.
Barfield, W., Hendrix, C., and Bystrom, K., 1997, “Visualizing the Structure of Virtual Objects Using Head Tracked Stereoscopic Displays,” Proceedings of the IEEE 1997 Virtual Reality Annual International Symposium, pp. 114–120, Los Alamitos, CA, IEEE Computer Society Press.
5.
Burdea, G., and Coiffet, P., 1994, Virtual Reality Technology, New York, John Wiley & Sons.
6.
Chuang
J. C.
,
Strong
R. T.
, and
Waldron
K. J.
,
1981
,
Implementation of Solution Rectification Techniques in an Interactive Linkage Synthesis Program
,
ASME Journal of Mechanical Design
, Vol.
103
, no.
7
, pp.
657
664
.
7.
Erdman, A. G., and Gustafson, J. E., 1997, “LINCAGES: Linkages Interactive Computer Analysis and Graphically Enhanced Synthesis Package,” ASME paper 77-DET-5. ASME Design Engineering Technical Conference Proceedings.
8.
Erdman, A. G., and Sandor, 1991, Mechanism Design, Analysis and Synthesis, 2nd Ed. New Jersey, Prentice-Hall.
9.
Fabiani, L., Burdea, G., Langrana, N., and Gomez, D., 1996, “Human Interface Using the Rutgers Master II Force Feedback Interface,” Proceeding of the IEEE 1996 Virtual Reality Annual International Symposium, pp. 54–59. Los Alamitos, CA: IEEE Computer Society Press.
10.
Fakespace, Inc., 1995, Fakespace Pinch, “Glove System Installation Guide and User Handbook, (Document GL-9001, Revision A). Menlo Park, CA, Author.
11.
Gilkey
R.
, and
Weisenberg
J.
,
1995
, “
The Sense of Presence for the Suddenly Deafened Adult; Implications for Virtual Environments
,”
Presence
, 4, Vol.
4
, no.
4
, pp.
357
363
.
12.
Hendrix
C.
, and
Barfield
W.
,
1996
a, “
Presence Within Virtual Environment as a Function of Visual Display Parameters
,”
Presence
, Vol.
5
, no.
3
, pp.
274
289
.
13.
Hendrix
C.
, and
Barfield
W.
,
1996
b, “
The Sense of Presence Within Auditory Virtual Environments
,”
Presence
, Vol.
5
, no.
3
, pp.
290
301
.
14.
Kaufman, R. E., 1978, “Mechanism Design by Computer,” Machine Design, Oct. 26, pp. 94–100.
15.
Kota
S.
, and
Erdman
A. G.
,
1997
, “
Motion Control in Product Design
,”
Mechanical Engineering
, Vol.
119
, no.
8
, pp.
73
77
.
16.
Kraal, J., 1996, An Application of Virtual Reality to Engineering Design: Synthesis of Spherical Mechanisms,” Unpublished master's thesis, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa.
17.
Larochelle, P., Dooley, J., Murray, A., and McCarthy, J. M., 1993, “Sphinx-Software for Synthesizing Spherical Mechanism,” Proceedings of the 1993 NSF Design and Manufacturing Systems Conference, pp. 607–612, Dearborn, MI, Society of Manufacturing Engineers.
18.
Mahoney
D.
,
1997
, “
VR Drives Chrysler’s New Cars
,”
Computer Graphics World
, Vol.
20
, no.
7
, pp.
61
62
.
19.
Neisser, U., 1976, Cognition and Reality. San Francisco, Freeman.
20.
Osborn, S. W., and Vance, J. M., 1995, “A Virtual Environment for Synthesizing Spherical Four-Bar Mechanisms,” ASME Design Engineering Technical Conference Proceedings, ASME paper DE-83, pp. 885–892.
21.
Pimentel, K., and Teixeira, K., 1993, Virtual Reality: Through the New Looking Glass. New York, McGraw Hill.
22.
Shiffrin, R. M., and Schneider, W., 1977, “Controlled and Automatic Human Information Processing; II. Perceptual Learning, Automatic Attending, and a General Theory” Psychological Review, 84, pp. 127–190.
23.
Stanney, K., 1995, “Realizing the Full Potential of Virtual Reality: Human Factors Issues that Could Stand in the Way,” IEEE Virtual Reality Annual International Symposium Proceedings, March 11–15, 1995, Research Triangle Park, NC, pp. 28–34.
24.
StereoGraphics Corporation, 1992, CrystalEYES® Stereographic System User’s Manual, San Rafael, CA.
25.
Steur
J.
,
1992
, “
Defining Virtual Reality: Dimensions Determining Telepresence
,”
Journal of Communication
, Vol.
42
, no.
4
, pp.
73
93
.
26.
Studt
T.
,
1998
, “
VR Speeds Up Car Designs
,”
R&D Magazine
, Vol.
40
, no.
4
, p.
74
74
.
27.
Vance, J., 1998, “Current Applications of Virtual Reality to Engineering Problems,” ACM Siggraph Course Notes, Course 14, 25th International Conference on Computer Graphics and Interactive Techniques, July 19–24, 1998, Orlando, Fl, 9-2: pp. 9–15.
28.
Wann
J.
, and
Mon-Williams
M.
,
1996
, “
What Does Virtual Reality Need?: Human Factors Issues in the Design of Three-Dimensional Computer Environments
,”
International Journal of Human-Computer Studies
,
44
, pp.
829
847
.
29.
Zeltzer, D., and Pitch, N. J., 1996, “Validation and Verification of Virtual Environment Training Systems,” IEEE Virtual Reality Annual International Symposium Proceedings, March 30–April 3, 1996, Santa Clara, CA, pp. 123–130.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.