Abstract

Even as better materials are developed for protective clothing, NFPA data indicate the number of burn related fire fighter deaths and severe injuries is increasing. These injuries are unexpected for the most part. As a result, questions arise about Thermal Protective Performance (TPP) ratings and whether performance changes are due to use or the effects of aging. As part of a NIST-sponsored Small Business Innovative Research project, current TPP test techniques were evaluated. Some changes and extensions are suggested.

In TPP tests, dry fabric samples or ensembles are exposed to heat flux of 83 kW/m2 with nominally 50% radiative and 50% convective heat transfer. Heat transmission through the test sample is measured with a copper calorimeter. The TPP Rating is the time in seconds required for a 2nd degree burn.

Current problems include:

1) Current test methods overestimate time to 2nd degree burn.

2) No information is provided on maximum potential burn damage.

3) No information is provided on heat transfer or fabric properties.

4) No information is provided on how performance changes with use.

Suggested changes and extensions include:

1) Change the heat source — use a modified radiant protective performance technique.

2) Replace the copper calorimeter with a thermal skin simulant sensor.

3) Estimate burn damage using a two step analysis method.

4) Obtain both dry and damp thermal properties for modeling clothing performance.

Issue Section:
Research Papers
Keywords:
thermal protective performance, thermal skin simulant, test, burn damage, heat flux

References

1.
ASTM Standard E 1354, “
Standard Test Methods for Heat and Visible Smoke Release Rates for Materials and Products Using an Oxygen Consumption Calorimeter
,”
ASTM International
,
West Conshohocken, PA
.
2.
Beck
,
J. V.
 and
McMasters
,
R. L.
, “
Users Manual for Prop1D — Program for Estimating Thermal Properties from Transient Temperature and Heat Flux Measurements
,” Version 7.0, and, “
Users Manual for IHCP1D — Program for Calculating Surface Heat Fluxes from Transient Temperatures Inside Solids
,”
Beck Engineering Consultants Co.
,
Okemos, MI
.
3.
Duck
,
F. A.
,
Physical Properties of Tissue — A Comprehensive Reference Book
,
Academic Press
,
1990
, ISBN 0-12-222800-6.
4.
Gagnon
,
B. D.
, “
Evaluation of New Test Methods for Fire Fighting Clothing
,” Master's Thesis,
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
,
05
2000
.
5.
Gagnon
,
B. D.
,
Dembsey
,
N. A.
, and
Keltner
,
N. R.
, “
Preliminary Results from New Methods for Evaluation of Fire Fighting Clothing
,”
Fire and Materials Conf.
,
San Francisco
,
2001
.
6.
Henriques
,
F. C.
, Jr., “
Studies of Thermal Injury V. The Predictability and the Significance of Thermally Induced Rate Processes Leading to Irreversible Epidermal Injury
,”
Archives of Pathology
 0363-0153, Vol.
43
,
1947
, pp.
489
-
502
.
7.
Keltner
,
N. R.
, et al, “
New Methods for Evaluating Thermal Performance of Protective Clothing for Fire Fighters — Phase I
,”
Ktech Corporation
, Technical Report TR98-01,
01
1998
.
8.
Keltner
,
N. R.
, et al, “
New Methods for Evaluating Thermal Performance of Protective Clothing for Fire Fighters — Phase II
,”
Ktech Corporation
, Technical Report TR00-15,
11
2000
.
9.
Knox
, ,
F. S.
 III, et al, “
User's Manual for BRNSIM/BURNSIM — a Burn Hazard Assessment Model
,”
Wright-Patterson AFB
,
OH
,
03
1992
.
10.
Lawson
,
J. R.
, “
Thermal Performance and Limitations of Bunker Gear
,”
Fire Engineering
,
08
1998
.
11.
Mell
,
W. E.
 and
Lawson
,
J. R.
, “
A Heat Transfer Model for Fire Fighter's Protective Clothing
,”
U.S. Department of Commerce
, NISTIR 99-6299,
08
1999
.
12.
NFPA 1971
,
Protective Clothing Ensemble for Structural Fire Fighting
, 1997 ed.,
National Fire Protection Association
,
Quincy, MA
,
1996
.
13.
NFPA 1977
,
Protective Clothing and Equipment for Wildland Fire Fighting
, 1993 ed.,
National Fire Protection Association
,
Quincy, MA
,
1996
.
14.
Quintiere
,
James
, “
Radiative Characteristics of Fire Fighter's Coat Fabrics
,”
Fire Technology
 0015-2684, Vol.
10
, No.
2
,
05
1974
, pp.
153
-
161
.
15.
Reed
,
R. P.
, “
Convolution & Deconvolution in Measurement and Control
,”
Measurements & Control
, Eight Part Professional Course, April 1997–September 1998.
16.
SFPE Task Group on Engineering Practices
, “
Predicting 1st and 2nd Degree Skin Burns from Thermal Radiation
,”
Society of Fire Protection Engineers
,
Bethesda, MD
,
2000
.
17.
Stoll
,
A. M.
 and
Chianta
,
M. A.
, “
Method and Rating System for Evaluation of Thermal Protection
,”
Aerospace Medicine
 0001-9402, Vol.
40
,
1968
, pp.
1232
-
1238
.
18.
Stoll
,
A. M.
 and
Greene
 
L. C.
, “
Relationship Between Pain and Tissue Damage Due to Thermal Radiation
,”
Journal of Applied Physiology
 8750-7587, Vol.
14
,
1959
, pp.
373
-
382
.
19.
Stoll
,
A. M.
 and
Chianta
,
M. A.
, “
Heat Transfer through Fabrics as Related to Thermal Injury
,”
Transactions-New York Academy of Sciences
, Vol.
33
, No.
7
,
1971
, pp.
649
-
670
.
20.
Torvi
,
D. A.
 and
Dale
,
J. D.
, “
Numerical Models for Use in the Design of Protective Clothing for Firefighters
,”
ICFRE 3
,
Chicago
,
1999
.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.