Abstract

Samples containing DNA from two or more individuals can be difficult to interpret. Even ascertaining the number of contributors can be challenging and associated uncertainties can have dramatic effects on the interpretation of testing results. Using an FBI genotypes dataset, containing complete genotype information from the 13 Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) loci for 959 individuals, all possible mixtures of three individuals were exhaustively and empirically computed. Allele sharing between pairs of individuals in the original dataset, a randomized dataset and datasets of generated cousins and siblings was evaluated as were the number of loci that were necessary to reliably deduce the number of contributors present in simulated mixtures of four or less contributors. The relatively small number of alleles detectable at most CODIS loci and the fact that some alleles are likely to be shared between individuals within a population can make the maximum number of different alleles observed at any tested loci an unreliable indicator of the maximum number of contributors to a mixed DNA sample. This analysis does not use other data available from the electropherograms (such as peak height or peak area) to estimate the number of contributors to each mixture. As a result, the study represents a worst case analysis of mixture characterization. Within this dataset, approximately 3% of three-person mixtures would be mischaracterized as two-person mixtures and more than 70% of four-person mixtures would be mischaracterized as two- or three-person mixtures using only the maximum number of alleles observed at any tested locus.

References

1.
Edwards
A
,
Hammond
HA
,
Lin
J
,
Caskey
CT
,
Chakraborty
R
.
Genetic variation at five trimeric and tetrameric tandem repeat loci in four human population groups
.
Genomics
 0888-7543
1992
;
12
:
241
53
.
2.
Frégeau
CJ
,
Fourney
RM
.
DNA typing with fluorescently tagged short tandem repeats: a sensitive and accurate approach to human identification
.
BioTechniques
 0736-6205
1993
;
15
:
100
19
.
3.
Krenke
BE
,
Tereba
A
,
Anderson
SJ
,
Buel
E
,
Culhane
S
,
Finis
CJ
,
Tomsey
CS
,
Zachetti
JM
,
Sprecher
CJ
.
Validation of a 16-locus fluorescent multiplex system
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2002
;
47
(
4
):
773
85
.
4.
Moretti
TR
,
Baumstark
AL
,
Defenbaugh
DA
,
Keys
KM
,
Smerick
JB
,
Budowle
B
.
Validation of short tandem repeats (STRs) for forensic usage: performance testing of fluorescent multiplex STR systems and analysis of authentic and simulated forensic samples
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
(
3
):
647
60
.
5.
Moretti
TR
,
Baumstark
AL
,
Defenbaugh
DA
,
Keys
KM
,
Brown
AL
,
Budowle
B
.
Validation of STR typing by capillary electrophoresis
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
(
3
):
661
76
.
6.
Frégeau
CJ
,
Bowen
KL
,
Fourney
RM
.
Validations of highly polymorphic fluorescent multiplex short tandem repeat systems using two generations of DNA sequencers
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1999
;
44
(
1
):
133
66
.
7.
Perlin
MW
,
Szabady
B
.
Linear mixture analysis: a mathematical approach to resolving mixed DNA samples
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2001
;
46
(
6
):
1372
7
.
8.
Wang
T
,
Xue
N
,
Rader
M
,
Birdwell
JD
.
Least square deconvolution (LSD) of STR/DNA mixtures
.
7th CODIS User's Conference
. Available at http://www.lit.net/presentations2/wang lest_ square%20STRDNA 2001 3.pdf.
2001
.
9.
Gill
P
,
Sparkes
R
,
Klimpton
C
.
Development of guidelines to designate alleles using an STR multiplex system
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0022-1198
1997
;
89
(
3
):
185
97
.
10.
Budowle
B
,
Moretti
TR
,
Baumstark
AL
,
Defenbaugh
DA
,
Keys
KM
.
Population data on the thirteen CODIS core short tandem repeat loci in African Americans, U.S. Caucasians, Hispanics, Bahamians, Jamaicans, and Trinidadians
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1999
;
44
(
6
):
1277
86
.
13.
Presciuttini
S
,
Ciampini
F
,
Alu
M
,
Cerri
N
,
Dobosz
M
,
Domenici
R
,
Peloso
G
,
Pelotti
S
,
Piccinini
A
,
Ponzano
E
,
Ricci
U
,
Tagliabracci
A
,
Baley-Wilson
JE
,
De Stefano
F
,
Pascali
V
.
Allele sharing in first-degree and unrelated pairs of individuals in the Ge.F.I. AmpFlSTR® Profiler Plus database
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
2003
;
131
(
2–3
):
85
9
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.