Abstract
The authors report on their macro- and microscopy study of bone lesions made by a sharp force instrument (a single blade knife), and a sharp-blunt instrument classified as a chopping weapon (a hatchet). The aim of this work was to attempt to identify the instrument by analyzing the general class characteristics of the cuts. Each weapon was used on human bones. The results indicate that macroscopic analysis is more problematic. The microscopic analysis assessed that characteristics examined were effective in distinguishing sharp from sharp-blunt injury to the bone. The microscope facilitates analysis unachievable with macroscopic methods, some three-dimensional characteristics not visible to the naked eye being clearly defined with its use. Emphasis has been placed on the value of SEM as an anthropologist's tool in bone lesion injuries.
Issue Section:
Technical Notes
References
1.
Somogyi
E
, Soótonyi
P
. On the possibilities of application of scanning electron microscopy in the forensic medicine
. Z Rechtsmed
0044-3433 1977
;80
:205
–19
.2.
Rawson
R B
, Starich
G H
, Rawson
R D
. Scanning electron microscopic analysis of skin resolution as an aid in identifying trauma in forensic investigations
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 2000
;45
(5
):1023
–7
.3.
Katterwe
H
, Goebel
R
, Grooss
K D
. The comparison scanning electron microscope within the field of forensic science
. Scan Electron Microsc
0586-5581 1982
;2
:499
–504
.4.
Tucker
B K
, Hutchinson
D L
, Gilliland
MF M
, Charles
T M
, Daniel
H J
, Wolfe
L D
. Microscopic Characteristics of hacking trauma
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 2001
;46
(2
):234
–40
.5.
Jakobsen
J
, Holmen
L
, Fredebo
L
, Sejrsen
B
. Scanning electron microscopy, a useful tool in forensic dental work
. J Forensic Odontostomatol
0258-414X 1995
;13
(2
):36
–40
.6.
Teaford
M F
. Scanning electron microscope diagnosis of wear patterns versus artefacts on fossil teeth
. Scanning Microsc
0891-7035 1988
;2
(2
):1176
–5
.7.
Maas
M C
. A scanning electron microscopic study of in vitro flake of mammalian tooth enamel under compressive loads
. Arch Oral Biol
0003-9969 1994
;39
(1
):1
–11
.8.
Quatrehomme
G
, Bolla
M
, Muller
M
, Rocca
J P
, Grevin
G
, Bailet
P
, Ollier
A
. Experimental single controlled study of burned bones : contribution of scanning electron microscopy
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 1998
;43
(2
):417
–22
.9.
Muller
M
, Bertrand
M F
, Quatrehomme
G
, Bolla
M
, Rocca
J P
. Macroscopic and microscopic aspects of incinerated teeth
. J Forensic Odontostomatol
0258-414X 1998
;6
,16(1
):1
–7
.10.
Burd
D Q
, Gilmore
A E
. Individual and class characteristics of tools
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 1968
;13
:390
–6
.11.
Humphrey
J H
, Hutchinson
L H
. Macroscopic characteristics of hacking trauma
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 2001
;46
(2
):228
–33
.12.
Davis
J E
. Striated tool marks
. In: Thomas
C C
, editor. An introduction to tool marks, firearms and the striagraph
. Springfield Illinois USA
, 1958
;26
–68
.13.
Reichs
K J
. Postmortem dismemberment : recovery, analysis and interpretation
. In: Reichs
K J
, editor. Forensic osteology: advances in the identification of human remains
, Second Edition. Springfield
: Charles C. Thomas
, 1998
;353
–88
.14.
Symes
S A
, Berryman
H E
, Smith
O C
. Saw marks in bone: introduction and examination of residual kerf contour
. In: Reichs
K J
, editor. Forensic osteology: advances in the identification of human remains
, Second Edition. Springfield
: Charles C. Thomas
, 1998
;389
–409
.15.
Rao
V J
, Hart
R H
. Tool mark in cartilage of stabbing victim
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 1983
;28
(3
):794
–9
.16.
Maples
W R
. Trauma analysis by the forensic anthropologist
. In: Reichs
K J
, editor. Forensic osteology: advances in the identification of human remains
. Springfield
: Charles C. Thomas
,1986
;218
–28
.17.
Wenham
S J
. Anatomical interpretation of Anglo-Saxon weapon injuries
. In: Hawkes
S J
, editor. Weapons and warfare in Anglo Saxon England
. Oxford Univ Committee Archaeol Monogr, 1990
;21:123–39.18.
Houck
M M
. Skeletal trauma and the individualization of knife marks in bone
. In: Reichs
K J
, editor. Forensic osteology: advances in the identification of human remains
, Second Edition. Springfield
: Charles C. Thomas
, 1998
;410
–24
.19.
Burd
D Q
, R S
Greene
. Tool mark examination techniques
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 1957
; 2
:297
–310
.20.
Bromage
T G
, Boyde
A
. Microscopic criteria for the determination of directionality of cutmarks on bone
. Am J Phys Anthropol
0002-9483 1984
;65
:359
–66
.21.
Stirland
A
. Patterns of trauma in a unique medieval parish cemetery
. Int J Osteoarchaeol
1996
;6
:92
–100
.22.
Shipman
P
, Rose
J
. Early hominid hunting, butchering and carcassprocessing behaviors: approaches to the fossil record
. J Anthropol Archaeol
0002-9165 1983
;2
:57
–98
.23.
Nokes
L D
, Green
M
. The use of scanning electron microscopy in the dating of skeletal remains
. J Forensic Sci Soc
0015-7368 1987
;27
(6
):413
–6
.24.
Wakely
J
, Bruce
M F
. Interpreting signs of trauma on a human axis vertebra
. J Anat
0021-8782 1989
;167
:265.
This content is only available via PDF.
Copyright © 2005 by ASTM
You do not currently have access to this content.
