Abstract
This paper establishes a logical framework for taking account of peak areas when interpreting mixed DNA STR profiles. The principles apply wherever such data are available but they are illustrated here by means of data which have been collected from made up mixtures of known concentrations analyzed at short tandem repeat loci. The data have led to some modeling assumptions which are used for numerical examples. In actual casework the proportions of the various components will not be known and there is a discussion of whether they should be allowed for by integrating over a prior distribution. This is a conceptual paper, rather than a prescription for casework, and the scope for further work is outlined.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
Keywords:
forensic science,
interpretation,
DNA,
profiling,
STR,
PCR,
mixtures,
probability,
statistics,
Bayesian
References
1.
Evett
I W
, Buffery
C
, Willott
G
, Stoney
D A
. A guide to interpreting single locus profiles of DNA mixtures in forensic cases
. J Forensic Sci Soc
1991
;31
:41
-7
.2.
National Research Council
. The evaluation of DNA evidence
. National Academy Press
1996
. Washington DC
.3.
Weir
B S
, Triggs
C M
, Starling
L
, Stowell
L I
, Walsh
K AJ
, Buckleton
J
. Interpreting DNA mixtures
. J Forensic Sci
. In press.4.
Sparkes
R
, Kimpton
C
, Watson
S
, Oldroyd
N
, Clayton
T
, Barnett
L
, et al. The validation of a 7-locus multiplex STR test for use in forensic casework (I): Mixtures, ageing, degradation and species studies
. Int J Leg Med
1996
;109
:186
-94
.5.
Kimpton
C P
, Oldroyd
N J
, Watson
S K
, Frazier
R RE
, Johnson
P E
, Millican
E S
, et al. Validation of highly discriminating multiplex short tandem repeat amplification systems for individual identification
. Electrophoresis
0173-0835 1996
;17
:1283
-93
.6.
Oldroyd
N J
, Urquhart
A J
, Kimpton
C P
, Millican
E S
, Watson
S K
, Downes
T
, et al. A highly discriminating octoplex short tandem repeat polymerase chain reaction system suitable of human individual identification
. Electrophoresis
0173-0835 1995
;16
:334
-7
.7.
Evett
I W
, Gill
P D
, Lambert
J A
, Oldroyd
N
, Frazier
R
, Watson
S
, et al. Statistical analysis of data for three British ethnic groups from a new STR multiplex
. Int J Leg Med
. 1997
;110
:5
-9
.8.
Gill
P
, Urquhart
A
, Millican
E
, Oldroyd
N
, Sparkes
R
, Kimpton
C
. A new method of STR interpretation using inferential logic—development of a criminal intelligence database
. Int J Leg Med
1996
;109
:14
-22
.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.
