Abstract

Recently, a new concept of behavior and the law has emerged which looks beyond the defendant's satisfaction of the elements which define the charge. This formulation, which considers not simply the objective facts but motive, intent, and circumstance, has marked a legal shift from diminished capacity to diminished responsibility. Still in evolution, this trend has challenged the relationship between law and the behavioral sciences, and prompted serious reconsideration of the role of each. This paper examines the landmarks of the movement, considers its implications, and looks to the future.

Issue Section:
Research Papers
Keywords:
forensic science, syndromes, psychological profiles, insanity, diminished responsibility, drug abuse, post-traumatic stress disorder, multiple personality disorder, battered woman syndrome, abuse excuse

References

1.
Insanity Defense Reform Act of 1984
, U.S.C. Title 18 § 17, 3006A, 4241.
2.
Commonwealth v. Mulica
, 520 N.E. 2d 134 (Mass.
1988
).
3.
United States v. Shorter
, 809 F.2d 54 (D.C. Cir.
1987
).
4.
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
. 4th ed.
Washington
,
American Psychiatric Association
,
1994
;
424
-
29
(DSM 309.81).
5.
van der Kolk
 
B A
,
McFarlane
 
A C
,
Weisaeth
 
L
, editors.
Traumatic stress
.
New York
,
Guilford Press
,
1996
;560.
6.
Walker
 
L E
.
The battered woman
.
New York
,
Harper & Row
,
1979
.
7.
State v. Kelly
, 478 A.2d 364 (N.J.
1984
).
8.
Wallace
 
D
.
The syndrome syndrome
.
University of Florida Law Review
1985
;
37
:
1035
-
58
.
9.
McCord
 
D
.
Syndromes, profiles and other mental exotica
.
Oregon Law Review
1987
;
66
:
19
-
108
.
10.
Buyse
 
M L
, editor.
Birth defects encyclopedia
.
Cambridge
,
Blackwell Scientific Publications
,
1990
;
281
-
82
.
11.
Matter of Andre E. (E.E.)
.
New York Law Journal
1996
;
215
:30.
12.
Kulynych
 
J
.
Brain, mind, and criminal behavior
.
Jurimetrics
1996
;
36
:
235
-
44
.
13.
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
. 4th ed.
Washington
,
American Psychiatric Association
,
1994
;
101
-
03
(DSM 307.23).
14.
State v. Koss
, 551 N.E.2d 970 (Ohio
1990
).
15.
Jones
 
A
.
Women who kill
.
Boston
,
Beacon Press
,
1996
.
16.
Browne
 
A
.
When battered women kill
.
New York
,
Free Press
,
1987
;175.
17.
Commonwealth v. Grimshaw
, 590 N.E.2d 681 (Mass.
1992
).
18.
Commonwealth v. Herd
, 604 N.E.2d 1294 (Mass.
1992
).
19.
Simon
 
R I
, editor.
Posttraumatic stress disorder in litigation
.
Washington
,
American Psychiatric Press
,
1995
.
20.
Sparr
 
L F
.
Post-traumatic stress disorder
.
Neurologic Clinics
 0733-8619
1995
;
13
:
413
-
29
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
21.
Slovenko
 
R
.
Legal aspects of post-traumatic stress disorder
.
Psychiatric Clinics of North America
 0193-953X.
1994
;
17
:
439
-
46
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
22.
Stone
 
A A
.
Post-traumatic stress disorder and the law
.
Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry & the Law
.
1993
;
21
:
23
-
36
.
23.
Orr
 
S P
,
Pitman
 
R K
.
Psychophysiologic assessment of attempts to simulate posttraumatic stress disorder
.
Biological Psychiatry
 0006-3223
1993
;
33
:
127
-
9
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
24.
Rosenberg
 
J E
,
Resnick
 
P J
.
The detection of malingered post-traumatic stress disorder
.
Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
. 1995 February 13–18,
Seattle (WA)
.
25.
Commonwealth v. Delaney
, 616 N.E.2d 111 (Mass.App.Ct.
1993
), affirmed, Commonwealth v. Delaney, 639 N.E.2d 710 (Mass.
1994
).
26.
Commonwealth v. Roman
, 606 N.E.2d 1333 (Mass.
1993
).
27.
Slovenko
 
R
.
Multiple personality
.
Medicine and Law
 0723-1393
1995
;
14
:
623
-
9
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
28.
Gazzaniga
 
M S
.
Nature's mind
.
New York
,
Basic Books
,
1992
.
29.
United States v. Denny-Shaffer
, 2 F.3d 999 (10th Cir.
1993
).
30.
Green
 
T A
.
Verdict according to conscience
.
Chicago
,
University of Chicago Press
,
1985
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
31.
Toobin
 
J
.
The man who kept going free
.
The New Yorker
1994 March
7
;
38
-
53
.
32.
Creagan
 
M K
.
Jury nullification
.
Case Western Reserve Law Review
1993
;
43
:
1101
-
50
.
33.
Weinstein
 
J B
.
Considering jury ‘nullification’
.
American Criminal Law Review
1993
;
30
:
239
-
54
.
34.
State v. Allewalt
, 517 A.2d 741 (Md.
1986
).
35.
Frazier
 
P A
,
Borgida
 
E
.
Rape trauma syndrome: Law and Human Behavior
1992
;
16
:
293
-
311
.
36.
State v. W.L.
, 650 A.2d 1035 (N.J. Super
1995
).
37.
Maryland v. Craig
, 497 U.S. 836 (
1990
).
38.
McAuliffe
,
J.
,
concurring
, 517 A.2d 741, 759 (Md.,
1986
).
39.
State v. Black
, 745 P.2d 12, 17–18 (Wash.
1987
).
40.
United States v. Chancey
, 715 F.2d 543, 547 (Fla.
1983
).
41.
United States v. Peralta
, 941 F.2d 1003 (Cal.
1991
).
42.
Coughlin
 
A M
.
Excusing women
.
California Law Review
 0008-1221
1994
;
82
:
1
-
93
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
43.
Copp
 
K M
.
Black rage
.
John Marshall Law Review
1995
;
29
:
205
-
38
.
44.
Falk
 
P J
.
Novel theories of criminal defense based upon the toxicity of the social environment
.
North Carolina Law Review
1996
;
74
:
731
-
811
.
45.
Maguigan
 
H
.
Cultural evidence and male violence
.
New York University Law Review
1995
;
70
:
36
-
99
.
46.
Tesner
 
M A
.
Racial paranoia as a defense to crimes of violence
.
Boston College Third World Law Journal
1991
;
11
:
307
-
33
.
47.
Coleman
 
D L
.
Individualizing justice through multiculturalism
.
Columbia Law Review
 0010-1958
1996
;
96
:
1093
-
167
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
48.
People v. Peterson
, 537 N.W.2d 857 (Mich.
1995
).
49.
State v. W.L.
, 650 A.2d 1035 (N.J. Super.
1995
).
50.
People v. Patino
, 32 Cal.Rptr.2d 345 (Ct. App.
1994
).
51.
State v. Davis
, 581 N.E.2d 604 (Ohio Ct. Appl.
1989
).
52.
State v. Freeney
, 637 A.2d 1088 (Conn.
1994
).
53.
Commonwealth v. Hudson
, 631 N.E.2d 50 (Mass.
1994
).
54.
People v. Taylor
, 536 N.Y.S.2d 825 (
1988
).
55.
Gilstrap v. State
, 450 S.E.2d 436 (Ga. Appl.
1994
).
56.
Knight v. State
, 426 S.E.2d 1 (Ga. Appl.
1992
).
57.
Jennette v. State
, 398 S.E.2d 734 (Ga. App.
1990
).
58.
State v. Woods
, 484 N.E.2d 773 (Ohio Com. Pl.
1984
).
59.
United States v. Hill
, 655 F.2d 512 (Pa.
1981
).
60.
Moore
 
C D
.
The elusive foundation of the entrapment defense
.
Northwestern University Law Review
1995
;
89
:
1151
-
88
.
61.
United States v. DiDomenico
, 985 F.2d 1159 (Conn.
1993
).
62.
Hartless v. State
, 611 A.2d 581 (Md.
1992
).
63.
People v. Watkins
, 440 N.W.2d 36 (Mich. App.
1989
).
64.
State v. Hensley
, 655 S.W.2d 810 (Mo. App.
1983
).
65.
Green
 
E D
,
Nesson
 
C R
, editors.
Federal Rules of Evidence
.
Boston
,
Little, Brown
,
1966
;
51
-
58
.
66.
Mendez
 
M A
.
The law of evidence and the search for a stable personality
.
Emory Law Journal
1996
;
45
:
221
-
38
.
67.
People v. McAlpin
, 812 P.2d 563 (Cal.
1991
).
68.
People v. Stoll
, 783 P.2d 698 (Cal.
1989
).
69.
State v. Arnold
, 421 A.2d 932 (Me.
1980
).
70.
State v. Screpesi
, 611 A.2d 34 (Del. Super
1991
).
71.
Stano v. Dugger
, 883 F.2d 900 (Fla.
1989
).
72.
Clenney v. State
, 344 S.E.2d 216 (Ga.
1986
).
73.
People v. Moya
, 350 P.2d 112 (Cal.
1960
).
74.
People v. Masor
, 578 N.E.2d 1176 (Ill. Ct. App.
1991
).
75.
Mueller
 
C B
,
Kirkpatrick
 
L C
.
Evidence Under the Rules
, 3rd ed.
Boston
,
Little, Brown
,
1996
;
677
-
9
.
76.
State v. Hunt
, 555 A.2d 369 (Vt.
1988
).
77.
United States v. Banks
, 36 M.J. 150 (CMA,
1992
).
78.
State v. Clements
, 770 P.2d 447, 448 (Kan.
1989
).
79.
United States v. Gillespie
, 852 F.2d 475 (Cal.
1988
).
80.
Sloan v. State
, 522 A.2d 1364 (Md. Ct. App.
1987
).
81.
Sanders v. State
, 303 S.E.2d 13 (Ga.
1983
).
82.
State v. Percy
, 507 A.2d 955 (Vt.
1986
).
83.
State v. McCoy
, 294 N.E.2d 242 (Ohio Ct. App.
1973
).
84.
United States v. Gillespie
, 852 F.2d 475 (Cal.
1988
).
85.
State v. Hunt
, 555 A.2d 369 (Vt.
1988
).
86.
State v. Briggs
, 776 P.2d 1347 (Wash. Ct. App.
1989
).
87.
People v. McAlpin
, 812 P.2d 563 (Cal.
1991
).
88.
Becton
 
C L
.
The drug courier profile
.
North Carolina Law Review
1987
;
65
:
417
-
80
.
89.
United States v. Sokolow
, 490 U.S. 1 (
1989
).
90.
Terry v. Ohio
, 392 U.S. 1 (
1968
).
91.
People v. Hubbard
, 530 N.W.2d 130 (Mich. Ct. Appl.
1995
).
92.
United States v. Williams
, 957 F.2d 1238 (5th Cir.
1992
).
93.
United States v. Wilson
, 930 F.2d 616 (Minn.
1991
).
94.
United States v. Beltran-Rios
, 878 F.2d 1208 (Cal.
1989
).
95.
United States v. Hernandez-Cuartas
, 717 F.2d 552 (Fla.
1983
).
96.
Crace
 
J
.
Inside the criminal mind
.
New Statesman & Society
1995 Feb
17
;29 (1995 WL 14340484).
97.
Guardian (London)
1995 Sept. 15 (1995 WL 9944184, 9944234, 9944240, 9944195 and 9944268).
98.
Yoder
 
E M
, Jr..
Olympic Park bombing
.
San Diego Union Tribune
02
08
1996
; B8.
99.
Sack
 
K
.
Jewell lambastes FBI, media for 88-day ordeal as suspect
.
Austin American-Statesman
29
10
1996
; A1.
100.
United States v. Hernandez-Cuartas
, 717 F.2d 552 (Fla.
1983
).
101.
People v. Lopez
, 26 Cal. Rptr. 2d 741 (Ct. App.
1994
).
102.
United States v. Robinson
, 978 F.2d 1554 (N.M.
1992
).
103.
United States v. Wilson
, 930 F.2d 616 (Minn.
1991
).
104.
United States v. Beltran-Rios
, 878 F.2d 1206 (Cal.
1989
).
105.
United States v. Khan
, 787 F.2d 28 (N.Y.
1986
).
106.
Wilson v. State
, 871 P.2d 46 (Okl.
1994
).
107.
State v. Percy
, 507 A.2d 955 (Vt.
1986
).
108.
State v. Hicks
, 649 P.2d 267 (Ariz.
1982
).
109.
Hadden v. State
, 670 So.2d 77 (Fla. Ct. App.
1996
).
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.