Abstract

In a retrospective archive study, 64 adjudicated adult cases involving the murder or attempted murder of at least one parent, referred for forensic evaluations are described. Biographic, demographic, diagnostic, crime scene, psycholegal opinion, and disposition data are presented. Results indicated a 40% rate of insanity acquitees. Attempted parricide subjects were more likely to have inpatient psychiatric histories, witnesses present during the criminal act, nonresponsiveness towards their actions, competency raised, and a hospital disposition. Gender and ethnicity were found to have a significant effect on ultimate disposition. Fifty-four percent of the sample opined psychotic were sentenced to prison, suggesting other factors considered by judge and jury. Profile characteristics and typologies are presented. The findings are compared to studies involving parricide and legal strategies involving similar cases.

References

1.
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
.
Crime in the United States 1977–1986
.
US Government Printing Office
,
Washington, DC
.
2.
Dawson
J W
,
Langen
P A
.
Murder in families
.
US Dept. of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report
., Washington, DC.
3.
d'Orban
P T
,
O'Conner
A
.
Women who kill their parents
.
Br J Psychiatry
1989
;
154
:
27
-
33
.
4.
Fontaine
I
,
Deslauriers
A G
.
About 3 cases of matricide
.
Annales Medico-Psychologiques
 0003-4487
1994
;
152
:
497
-
510
.
5.
Green
C M
.
Matricide by sons
.
Med Sci Law
1981
;
21
(
3
):
207
-
14
.
6.
California Department of Justice, Division of Law Enforcement
.
Homicide in California, 1972, 1973, 1992
.
California Government Printing Office
,
Sacramento, CA
.
7.
Young
T J
.
Parricide rates and criminal street violence in the United States: is there a correlation?
Adolescence
 0001-8449
1993
;
28
(
109
):
171
-
2
.
8.
Megargee
E I
.
Psychological determinants and correlates of criminal violence
. In:
Wolfgang
M
,
Weiner
N A
, editors.
Criminal violence
.
Beverly Hills, CA
,
Sage
,
1982
;
201
-
35
.
9.
McKnight
C K
,
Mohr
J W
,
Quinsey
R E
,
Erochko
J
.
Matricide and mental illness
.
Can Psychiatr Assoc J
1966
;
11
(
2
):
99
-
106
.
10.
Sadoff
R L
.
Clinical observations on patricide
.
Psychoanal Q
1971
;
45
:
65
-
9
.
11.
Mass
R L
,
Prakash
R
,
Hollender
M H
,
Regan
W M
.
Double parricide-matricide and patricide: a comparison with other schizophrenic murders
.
Psychiatr Q
1984
;
56
:
286
-
90
.
12.
Lispon
C T
.
A case report of matricide (letter)
.
Am J Psychiatry
1986
;
143
:
112
-
3
.
13.
Chaimberlain
T
.
The dynamics of parricide
.
Am J Forensic Psychiatr
1986
;
7
:
11
-
23
.
14.
Mouridsen
S E
,
Tolstrup
K
.
Children who kill: a case study of matricide
.
J Child Psychol Psychiatr
1988
;
29
(
4
):
511
-
5
.
15.
Meloy
J R
.
Orestes in Southern California: a forensic case of matricide
.
J Psychiatr Law
1996
;
24
(
1
):
77
-
102
.
16.
Campion
J
,
Cravens
J M
,
Rotholc
A
,
Weinstein
H C
,
Coven
F
,
Alpert
M
.
A study of 15 matricidal men
.
Am J Psychiatry
1985
;
142
(
3
):
312
-
7
.
17.
Cravens
J M
,
Campion
J
,
Rotholc
A
,
Coven
F
,
Cravens
R A
.
A study of 10 men charged with patricide
.
Am J Psychiatry
1985
;
142
(
9
):
1089
-
92
.
18.
Singhal
S
,
Dutta
A
.
Who commits matricide?
Med Sci Law
1992
;
32
:
213
-
7
.
19.
Heide
K M
.
Parents who get killed and the children who kill them
.
J Interpersonal Violence
1993
;
8
(
4
):
531
-
44
.
20.
Dutton
D G
,
Yamini
S
.
Adolescent parricide: an integration of social cognitive theory and clinical view of projective-introjective cycling
.
Am J Orthopsychiatry
1995
;
65
(
1
):
39
-
47
.
21.
Heide
K M
.
Evidence of child maltreatment among adolescent parricide offenders
.
Int J Offender Therapy Comparative Crim
1994
;
38
:
151
-
62
.
22.
Heide
K M
.
Why kids kill parents: child abuse and adolescent homicide
.
Thousand Oaks
,
Sage
,
1995
.
23.
Mones
P A
.
When a child kills: abused children who kill their parents
.
New York
,
Pocket Books
,
1991
.
24.
Millaud
F
,
Auclair
N
,
Meunier
D
.
Parricide and mental illness
.
Int J Law Psychiatr
1996
;
19
(
2
):
173
-
82
.
25.
Newhill
C E
.
Parricide
.
J Family Violence
1991
;
6
(
4
):
375
-
94
.
26.
Meloy
J R
.
Violent attachments
.
Northvale
,
Aronson
,
1992
.
27.
Straus
M L
.
Domestic violence and homicide antecedents
.
Bulletin of the NY Academy of Med
1986
;
62
(
5
):
446
-
65
.
28.
Mann
,
C R
.
When women kill
.
Albany
,
SUNY Press
,
1996
.
29.
Van Sambeek
M J
.
Parricide as self-defense
.
Law Inequality Justice
1988
;
7
:
87
-
98
.
30.
Moreno
J A
.
Killing daddy: developing a self-defense strategy for the abused child
.
Univ Pennsylvania Law Rev
1989
;
137
:
1281
-
307
.
31.
Smith
S C
.
Abuse children who kill abusive parents: moving towards an appropriate legal response
.
Catholic Univ Law Rev
1992
;
42
:
141
-
78
.
32.
Shoop
J G
.
Self-defense claims gain acceptance in parricide cases
.
Trial
1993
;
29
:
11
-
2
.
33.
Molitor
M K
.
The “battered child syndrome” as self-defense evidence in parricide cases: recent developments and a possible approach
.
Wayne Law Rev
1993
;
40
(
1
):
237
-
60
.
34.
James
J R
.
Turning the tables: redefining self-defense theory for children who kill their parents
.
Law Psychology Rev
1994
;
18
:
393
-
408
.
35.
Blodgett
N
.
Self-defense: parricide defendants cite sexual abuse as justification
.
Am Bar Assoc
01
06
1987
.
36.
Scott
M A
.
Self-defense and the child parricide defendant: should courts make a distinction between the battered woman and the battered child?
Drake Law Rev
1996
;
44
(
2
):
351
-
75
.
37.
Goodwin
M R
.
Parricide: States are beginning to recognize that abused children who kill their parents should be afforded the right to assert a claim of self-defense
.
Southwestern Law Rev
1996
;
25
(
2
):
429
-
60
.
38.
Hays
W L
.
Analyzing qualitative data: chi-squared tests
. In:
Statistics
, 3rd edition.
New York
,
CBS College Publishing
,
1981
;
552
-
5
.
39.
US Department of Justice
.
Crime in the United States
.
Washington, DC
,
US Government Printing Office
1993
.
40.
California Department of Corrections Facts. Communications Office: California Department of Corrections.
01
09
1996
.
41.
Beck
A
,
Gilliard
D
,
Greenfeld
L
,
Harlow
C
,
Hester
T
,
Jankowski
L
, et al
:
Survey of state prison inmates, 1991
.
Washington, DC
,
Bureau of Justice Statistics
,
1993
.
42.
Farrington
D P
,
Games
G C
,
Lambert
S
.
The concentration of offending in families
.
Legal and Criminological Psychology
,
1996
;
1
,
47
-
63
.
43.
Appelbaum
P S
,
Gutheil
T G
.
Clinical Handbook of Psychiatry and the Law
, 2nd Ed.
Baltimore
,
Williams & Wilkins
,
1991
.
44.
Melton
G B
,
Petrilia
J
,
Poythress
N G
,
Slobogin
C
.
Psychological evaluations for the court: a handbook for mental health professionals and lawyers
.
New York
,
Guildford Press
,
1987
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.