Abstract
This study assesses the accuracy and reliability of 17 individual morphological traits of the pelvis frequently used to determine the sex of human skeletal remains. A sample of 49 right and left adult hip bones and sacra of documented individuals were available from an historic church cemetery dating from the 19th century. A hypothetical ranking of the accuracy of traits was drawn from the literature. Next, individual traits were evaluated for precision and accuracy of observations, and combinations of two and three traits were evaluated for their collective effectiveness as sex indicators. The effect of age on the accuracy of traits for sex determination was also examined. Precision of traits was generally good. Several combinations of three criteria produced higher levels of accuracy than the trait list as a whole. A total of six traits was judged to be most effective as sex discriminators because of low intraobserver error levels and better than 83% accuracy rates. There was no indication of an age effect on the precision or accuracy of these traits although sample sizes are small.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
Meindl
, R. S.
, Lovejoy
, C. O.
, Mensforth
, R. P.
, and Don Carlos
, L.
, “Accuracy and Direction of Error in the Sexing of the Skeleton: Implications for Paleodemography
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 68
, No. 1
, 1985
, pp. 79
-85
.2.
Stewart
, T. D.
, “Sex Determination of the Skeleton By Guess and By Measurement
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 12
, No. 3
, 1954
, pp. 385
-392
.3.
Weiss
, K. M.
, “On the Systematic Bias in Skeletal Sexing
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 37
, No. 2
, 1972
, pp. 239
-250
.4.
Giles
, E.
and Elliot
, O.
, “Sex Determination by Discriminant Function Analysis of Crania
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 21
, No. 1
, 1963
, pp. 53
-68
.5.
Buikstra
, J. E.
and Mielke
, J. H.
, “Demography, Diet, and Health
,” The Analysis of Prehistoric Diets
, R. I.
Gilbert
and J. H.
Mielke
, Eds.) Academic Press
, New York
, 1985
, pp. 359
-422
.6.
Steele
, D. G.
and Bramblett
, C. A.
, The Anatomy and Biology of the Human Skeleton
, College Station, Texas A&M University Press
, 1988
.7.
Henke
, W.
, “On the Method of Discriminant Function Analysis for Sex Determination of the Skull
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 6
, 1977
, pp. 95
-100
.8.
Kajanoja
, P.
, “Sex Determination of Finnish Crania by Discriminant Function Analysis
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 24
, No. 1
, 1966
, pp. 29
-34
.9.
Keen
, J. A.
, “A Study of the Differences Between Male and Female Skulls
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 8
N.S., No. 1
, 1950
, pp. 65
-79
.10.
Kelley
, M. A.
, “Sex Determination with Fragmented Skeletal Remains
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 24
, No. 1
, 1979
a, pp. 154
-158
.11.
Richman
, E. A.
, Michel
, M. E.
, Schulter-Ellis
, F. P.
, and Corruccini
, R. S.
, “Determination of Sex by Discriminant Function Analysis of Postcranial Skeletal Measurements
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 24
, No. 1
, 1979
, pp. 159
-163
.12.
Washburn
, S.
, “Sex Differences in the Pubic Bone
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 6
, No. 3
, 1948
, pp. 199
-207
.13.
St. Hoyme
, L. E.
and Íşcan
, M. Y.
, “Determination of Sex and Race: Accuracy and Assumptions
,” Reconstruction of Life from the Skeleton
, M. Y.
Íşcan
and K. A. R.
Kennedy
, Eds., Alan R. Liss, Inc.
, New York
, 1989
, pp. 53
-93
.14.
El-Najjar
, M. Y.
and McWilliams
, K. R.
, Forensic Anthropology: The Structure, Morphology, and Variation of Human Bone and Dentition
, Springfield, Ill.
, Charles C Thomas
, 1978
.15.
Novotny
, V.
, “Sex Determination of the Pelvic Bone; A Systems Approach
,” Anthropologie
, Vol. 24
, Nos. 2–3
, pp. 197
-206
.16.
Phenice
, T. W.
, “A Newly Developed Visual Method of Sexing the Os Pubis
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 30
, No. 2
, 1969
, pp. 297
-302
.17.
Sutherland
, L. D.
and Suchey
, J. M.
, “Use of the Ventral Arc in Sex Determination
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 36
, No. 2
, 1991
, pp. 501
-511
.18.
Lovell
, N. C.
, “Test of Phenice's Technique for Determining Sex from the Os Pubis
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 79
, No. 1
, 1989
, pp. 117
-120
.19.
Houghton
, P.
, “The Relationship of the Pre-auricular Groove of the Ilium to Pregnancy
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 41
, No. 3
, 1974
, pp. 381
-389
.20.
Kelley
, M. A.
, “Parturition and Pelvic Changes
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 51
, No. 4
, 1979
b, pp. 541
-546
.21.
Dunlap
, S. S.
“The Preauricular Sulcus in a Cadaver Population
,” presented at the Fifty-first Meeting of the American Association of Physical Anthropology
, 1982
.22.
Suchey
, J. M.
, Wiseley
, D. V.
, Green
, R. F.
, and Noguchi
, T. T.
, “Analysis of Dorsal Pitting in the Os Pubis in an Extensive Sample of Modern American Females
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 51
, No. 4
, 1979
, pp. 517
-540
.23.
Cox
, M.
, “Skeletal Markers of Parturition
,” Presented at the 10th Hrdlicka Conference
, Liblice, Czech Republic
, 1989
.24.
Tague
, R. G.
, “Variation in Pelvic Size Between Males and Females
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 80
, No. 1
, 1989
, pp. 59
-71
.25.
Saunders
, S.
, Herring
, A.
, Sawchuk
, L.
, and Boyce
, G.
, “The 19th Century Cemetery at St. Thomas' Anglican Church, Belleville: Skeletons, Parish Records and Censuses
,” presented at the Sixty-Second Annual Meeting of the American Association for Physical Anthropology
, 04
1993
.26.
Herring
, A.
, Saunders
, S.
, and Boyce
, G.
, “Bones and Burial Registers: Infant Mortality in a 19th Century Cemetery from Upper Canada
,” Northeast Historical Archeology
, Vol. 20
.27.
Coleman
, W. H.
, “Sex Differences in the Growth of the Human Bony Pelvis
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 31
, No. 2
, 1969
, pp. 125
-152
.28.
St. Hoyme
, L. E.
, “Sex Differentiation in the Posterior Pelvis
,” Collegium Anthropologica
, Vol. 8
, 1984
, pp. 139
-153
.29.
Rogers
, T.
, “Sex Determination and Age Estimation: Skeletal Evidence from St. Thomas' Cemetery, Belleville, Ontario
,” Master's Thesis, McMaster University
, 1991
.30.
Nichol
, C. R.
and Turner
, C. G.
, “Intra- and Interobserver Concordance in Classifying Dental Morphology
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 69
, No. 3
, 1986
, pp. 299
-315
.31.
Tague
, R. G.
, “Bone Resorption of the Pubis and Preauricular Area in Humans and Nonhuman Mammals
,” American Journal of Physical Anthropology
0002-9483, Vol. 76
, No. 2
, 1988
, pp. 251
-267
.32.
Sutherland
, L. D.
and Suchey
, J. M.
, “Use of the Ventral Arc in Sex Determination of the Os Pubis
,” presented at the Thirty-ninth Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, San Diego, California
, 1987
.33.
McLaughlin
, S. M.
and Bruce
, M. F.
“The Accuracy of Sex Identification in European Skeletal Remains Using the Phenice Criteria
,” Journal of Forensic Sciences
0022-1198, Vol. 35
, No. 6
, 1990
, pp. 1384
-1392
.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.
