Abstract

For many reasons, inpatient psychiatric units are increasingly faced with treatment and management of violent individuals. This fosters a need to consider potential institutional responses to patient violence. This paper focuses on one response—prosecution of these persons. The existing literature on this topic is reviewed. In addition, the case history of a difficult but successful prosecution of an assaultive patient is presented. This case highlighted the development of guidelines, which are outlined herein, for determining the appropriateness of seeking legal action against patients. The paper concludes with an assessment of the benefits and risks associated with patient prosecution.

Issue Section:
Research Papers
Keywords:
psychiatry, violence, jurisprudence, hospitals, patient assaults, prosecution, hospital policy

References

1.
Sosowsky
,
L.
, “
Crime and Violence Among Mental Patients Reconsidered in View of the New Legal Relationships Between the State and the Mentally Ill
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
135
,
1978
, pp.
33
-
42
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
2.
Melick
,
M. E.
,
Steadman
,
H. J.
, and
Cocozza
,
J. J.
, “
The Medicalization of Criminal Behavior Among Mental Patients
,”
Journal of Health and Social Behavior
 0022-1465, Vol.
20
,
1979
, pp.
228
-
237
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
3.
Huber
,
G. A.
,
Roth
,
L. H.
,
Appelbaum
,
P. S.
, et al, “
Hospitalization, Arrest, or Discharge: Important Legal and Clinical Issues in the Emergency Evaluation of Persons Believed Dangerous to Others
,”
Law and Contemporary Problems
, Vol.
45
,
1982
, pp.
99
-
123
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
4.
Johansen
,
K. H.
, “
The Impact of Patients with Chronic Character Pathology on a Hospital Inpatient Unit
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
34
,
1983
, pp.
842
-
846
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
5.
Miller
,
R. D.
 and
Maier
,
G. J.
, “
Factors Affecting the Decision to Prosecute Mental Patients for Criminal Behavior
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
38
,
1987
, pp.
50
-
55
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
6.
Miller
,
R. D.
,
Doren
,
D. M.
,
Van Rybroek
,
G.
, et al, “
Emerging Problems for Staff Associated with the Release of Potentially Dangerous Forensic Patients
,”
Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law
, Vol.
16
,
1988
, pp.
309
-
320
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
7.
Applebaum
,
P. S.
, “
The New Preventive Detention: Psychiatry's Problematic Responsibility for the Control of Violence
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
145
,
1988
, pp.
779
-
785
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
8.
Perlman
,
B. B.
, “
Prosecuting Patients
,” (letter),
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
38
,
1987
, p. 673.
9.
State v. Kyles, 166NJ, New Jersey Superior Court 343, Appeals Division,
1979
.
10.
Trenkner
,
T.
, “
Escape from Public Employee or Institution Other than Correctional or Law Enforcement Employee or Institution as Criminal Offense
,”
American Law Reports
, 3rd ed.,
1969
, pp.
625
-
654
.
11.
State v. Cummins, 168NJ, New Jersey Superior Court 429, 433 A2d 67, 69,
1979
.
12.
Schwarz
,
C. J.
 and
Greenfield
,
G. P.
, “
Charging a Patient with Assault of a Nurse on a Psychiatric Unit
,”
Canadian Psychiatric Association Journal
 0008-4824, Vol.
4
,
1978
, pp.
197
-
200
.
13.
Phelan
,
L. A.
,
Mills
,
M. J.
, and
Ryan
,
J. A.
, “
Prosecuting Psychiatric Patients for Assault
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
36
,
1985
, pp.
581
-
582
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
14.
Hoge
,
S. K.
 and
Gutheil
,
T. G.
, “
The Prosecution of Psychiatric Patients for Assaults on Staff: A Preliminary Empirical Study
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
38
,
1987
, pp.
44
-
49
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
15.
Mills
,
M. J.
,
Phelan
,
L. A.
, and
Ryan
,
J. A.
, “
In Reply
,” (letter),
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
36
,
1985
, pp.
1321
-
1322
.
16.
Rachlin
,
S.
, “
Toward a Definition of Staff Rights
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
33
,
1982
, pp.
60
-
61
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
17.
Stein
,
L. I.
 and
Diamond
,
R. J.
, “
The Chronic Mentally Ill and the Criminal Justice System: When to Call the Police
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
36
,
1985
, pp.
271
-
274
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
18.
Gutheil
,
T. G.
, “
Prosecuting Patients
,” (letter),
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
36
,
1985
, pp.
1320
-
1321
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
19.
Lion
,
R.
,
Snyder
,
W.
, and
Merrill
,
G.
, “
Underreporting of Assaults on Staff in a State Hospital
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol
32
,
1981
, pp.
497
-
498
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
20.
Tardiff
,
K.
 and
Sweillam
,
A.
, “
Assaultive Behavior Among Chronic Inpatients
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
139
,
1982
, pp.
212
-
215
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
21.
Madden
,
D. J.
,
Lion
,
J. R.
, and
Penna
,
M. W.
, “
Assaults on Psychiatrists by Patients
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
133
,
1976
, pp.
422
-
425
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
22.
Lanza
,
M. L.
, “
The Reactions of Nursing Staff to Physical Assault by a Patient
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
34
,
1983
, pp.
44
-
47
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
23.
Lion
,
J. R.
,
Madden
,
D. J.
, and
Christopher
,
R. L.
, “
A Violence Clinic: Three Years' Experience
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
133
,
1976
, pp.
432
-
435
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
24.
Brizer
,
D. A.
,
Convit
,
A.
,
Krakowski
,
M.
, et al, “
A Rating Scale for Reporting Violence on Psychiatric Wards
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
38
,
1987
, pp.
769
-
770
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
25.
Lion
,
J. R.
 and
Pasternak
,
S. A.
, “
Countertransference Reactions to Violent Patients
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
130
,
1973
, pp.
207
-
210
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
26.
Steadman
,
H. J.
 and
Cocozza
,
J. J.
, “
Public Perceptions of the Criminally Insane
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
29
,
1978
, pp.
457
-
459
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
27.
Oxford English Dictionary
,
Oxford University Press
,
Oxford, UK
,
1971
.
28.
Scott
,
J. R.
 and
Whitehead
,
J. J.
, “
An Administrative Approach to the Problem of Violence
,”
Journal of Mental Health Administration
 0092-8623, Vol.
8
,
1981
, pp.
36
-
40
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
29.
Perkins
,
R. M.
 and
Bayce
,
R. N.
,
Criminal Law: Cases and Materials
, 3rd ed.,
Foundation Press
,
New York
,
1982
.
30.
Clinical Treatment of the Violent Person
,
L. H.
 
Roth
, Ed.,
Guilford Press
,
New York
,
1987
.
31.
Halleck
,
S. L.
, “
The Concept of Responsibility in Psychotherapy
,”
American Journal of Psychotherapy
 0002-9564, Vol.
36
,
1982
, pp.
292
-
303
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
32.
Principles of Medical Ethics with Annotations Especially Applicable to Psychiatry
, Section 4, No. 14,
American Psychiatric Association
,
Washington, DC
,
1989
.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.