Abstract

Psychiatrists have made significant contributions to our understanding of the phenomenon of suicide and are generally regarded as experts in all matters relating to suicide. When a legal determination must be made as to whether an individual has died as a result of suicide or by accidental (or any other) means, psychiatrists are often called upon to proffer their expert opinion to assist the courts to resolve the matter. Two case illustrations are presented and analyzed in which psychiatrists were called upon to make such retrospective determinations of suicide. The question is raised as to whether psychiatrists may sometimes exceed the limits of their scientific expertise in making such determinations.

Issue Section:
Research Papers
Keywords:
psychiatry, jurisprudence, suicide

References

1.
Menninger
,
K.
,
Man Against Himself
,
Harcourt
,
Brace, New York
,
1938
.
2.
Stengel
,
E.
,
Suicide and Attempted Suicide
,
Penguin Books
,
London
,
1964
.
3.
Choron
,
J.
,
Suicide
,
Scribner's
,
New York
,
1972
.
4.
Shader
,
R.
,
Assessment of Suicide Risk
,” in
Manual of Psychiatric Therapeutics
,
R.
 
Shader
, Ed.,
Little, Brown and Company
,
Boston
,
1975
.
5.
Motto
,
J. A.
,
Heilbron
,
D. C.
, and
Juster
,
R. P.
, “
Development of a Clinical Instrument to Estimate Suicide Risk
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
142
, No.
6
,
06
1985
, pp.
680
-
686
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
6.
Barry
,
J. V.
, “
Suicide and the Law
,”
Melbourne University Law Review
, Vol.
5
, No.
1
,
1965
.
7.
Szasz
,
T.
, “
The Ethics of Suicide
,”
Antioch Review
, Vol.
7
, No.
17
,
1971
.
8.
Londsdorf
,
R.
, “
Legal Aspects of Suicide
,” in
Suicidal Behaviors
,
H. L. P.
 
Resnik
, Ed.,
Little, Brown and Company
,
Boston
,
1968
.
9.
Dawidoff
,
D.
,
The Malpractice of Psychiatrists
,
Charles C Thomas
,
Springfield, IL
,
1973
, pp.
56
-
58
.
10.
Strasberg v. Equitable Life Assurance Society of United States
, 117 N.Y.S.2d 236 (
1952
).
11.
Kent v. New England Mutual Life Insurance Company
, 277 N.Y.S.2d 788, 792 (
1966
).
12.
Curphey
,
T. J.
, “
The Psychological Autopsy
,”
Bulletin of Suicidology
,
07
1968
.
13.
Jansson
,
B.
, “
Drug Automatism as a Cause of Pseudo Suicide
,”
Postgraduate Medicine
 0032-5481, Vol.
30
,
1961
, p.
A
-
34
.
14.
Ettlinger
,
R. W.
 and
Flordh
,
P.
, “
Attempted Suicide: Experience of 500 Cases at a General Hospital
,”
Acta Psychiatrica et Neurologica Scandinavia
, Supplement, Vol.
103
,
1955
, pp.
1
-
45
.
15.
Durkheim
,
D.
,
Suicide
, 2nd ed.,
Free Press
,
Glencoe, IL
,
1951
.
16.
Freud
,
S.
, “
Mourning and Melancholia
,” in
Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud
, Vol.
14
,
J.
 
Strachey
, Ed. and translator,
Hogarth Press
,
London
,
1961
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
 
17.
Comer
,
J.
, “
Black Suicide: A Hidden Urban Crisis
,”
Urban Health
 0191-8257, Vol.
2
,
1973
, pp.
41
-
43
.
18.
Hendin
,
H.
,
Suicide and Scandinavia
,
Grune and Stratton
,
New York
,
1964
.
19.
Goldstein
,
R. L.
, “
Credibility and Incredibility: The Psychiatric Examination of the Complaining Witness
,”
American Journal of Psychiatry
 0002-953X, Vol.
137
, No.
10
,
1980
, pp.
1238
-
1240
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
20.
Goldstein
,
R. L.
, “
Sanctum Sanctorum: The Psychiatrist's Role in Posttrial Competency Examination of Jurors
,”
Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law
, Vol.
13
, No.
2
,
1985
, pp.
191
-
196
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
21.
Stone
,
A. A.
, “
Comment on Goldstein's Posttrial Competency Examination of Jurors
,”
Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law
, Vol.
13
, No.
2
,
1985
, pp.
197
-
199
.
22.
Perr
,
I. N.
, “
The Insanity Defense: The Case for Abolition
,”
Hospital and Community Psychiatry
 0022-1597, Vol.
36
,
1985
, pp.
51
-
53
.
Google Scholar
PubMed
 
23.
Rappeport
,
J.
, “
Ethics and Forensic Psychiatry
,” in
Psychiatric Ethics
,
S.
 
Bloch
 and
P.
 
Chodoff
, Eds.,
Oxford University Press
,
Oxford
,
1981
, pp.
255
-
276
.
24.
Stone
,
A. A.
, “
The Ethics of Forensic Psychiatry: A View from the Ivory Tower
,” in
Law, Psychiatry, and Morality
,
A. A.
 
Stone
, Ed.
American Psychiatric Press
,
Washington, DC
,
1984
, pp.
57
-
75
.
25.
Dorpat
,
T. L.
, “
Drug Automatism, Barbiturate Poisoning and Suicide Behavior
,”
Archives of General Psychiatry
 0003-990X, Vol.
31
,
1974
, pp.
216
-
220
.
Google Scholar
Crossref
Search ADS
PubMed
 
26.
Goldstein
,
R. L.
, “
The Twilight Zone Between Scientific Certainty and Legal Sufficiency: Should a Jury Determine the Causation of Schizophrenia?
,”
Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law
, in press.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.