The mandated switch of the overwhelming part of microelectronics assembly to lead-free soldering has left the manufacturers of many high reliability products, which are still exempt from the requirement to change, with a choice between imperfect alternatives. One of these involves the inclusion of lead-free BGAs and CSPs in a eutectic SnPb solder paste based reflow process. In order to assess the consequences of this for reliability it is not enough to subject samples to common accelerated tests. Mixing of the alloys is almost certain to affect the acceleration factors so that comparisons of test results may not reflect relative performances under service conditions. This was illustrated with for a set of model BGA components with 20 mil (0.5 mm) diameter SAC305 solder balls, which were reflow soldered onto printed circuit boards using a eutectic SnPb solder paste and tested in thermal cycling together with controls soldered with a SAC305 paste. Mixed joints were found to outperform pure SAC305 in −40/125°C tests but not in 0/100°C, and general trends suggest that mixed joints may compare more poorly in service.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
Nie
, L.
, and Pecht
, M.
, 2007, “Regulations and Market Trends in Lead-Free and Halogen-Free Electronics
,” Circuit World
, 33
(2
), pp. 4
–9
.2.
“The Lead Free Electronics Manhattan Project–Phase I,” www.navyb2pcoe.org/LFMP_book.pdfwww.navyb2pcoe.org/LFMP_book.pdf.
3.
Beair
, W.
, and Vuono
, W.
, 2008, “Lead Free to SnPb BGA Reballing Process and Reliability
,” Proceedings of the SMTA International
, pp. 379
–383
.4.
Li
, J.
, Poranki
, S.
, Abtew
, M.
, Kinyanjui
, R.
, and Srihari
, K.
, 2009, “Reliability Assessment of Reballed BGAs
,” Proceedings of the SMTA International
, pp. 93
–97
.5.
Pymento
, L. G.
, Davis
, W. T.
, Kelly
, M.
, Cole
, M.
, Wilcox
, J.
, Krystek
, P.
, and Grosskopf
, C.
, 2008, “Process Development with Temperature Sensitive Components in Server Applications
,” Proceedings of the APEX
, Las Vegas
.6.
Zhang
, T.
, Evans
, J.
, Mitchell
, C.
, and Zhi
, Z.
, 2009, “Reliability of Lead-Free BGA With SnPb Solder Paste for Harsh Environments
,” Proceedings of the SMTA/CAVE Symposium on AIMS Harsh Environment Electronics
, pp. 899
–906
.7.
Chatterji
, I.
, 2006, “Backward Compatibility, Are We Ready-A Case Study
,” Proceedings of the SMTA International
, pp. 416
–424
.8.
Coyle
, R.
, Read
, P.
, Kummerl
, S.
, Fleming
, D.
, Popowich
, R.
, and Chatterji
, I.
, 2008, “A Comprehensive Analysis of the Thermal Fatigue Reliability of SnPb and Pb Free Plastic Ball Grid Arrays (PBGA) Using Backward and Forward Compatible Assembly Processes
,” SMTA J.
, 21
(4
), pp. 33
–47
.9.
Borgesen
, P.
, Meilunas
, M.
, and Al-Momani
, E.
, 2009, “Effect of Dwell Time on the Life of Lead Free BGA Joints in Thermal Cycling
,” Proceedings of the SMTAI
.10.
Bieler
, T. R.
, Jiang
, H.
, Lehman
, L. P.
, Kirkpatrick
, T.
, and Cotts
, E. J.
, 2006, “Influence of Sn Grain Size and Orientation on the Thermomechanical Response and Reliability of Pb-free Solder Joints
,” Proceedings of the 2006 Electronic Components and Technology Conference
, pp. 1467
–7
.11.
Bieler
, T. R.
, Borgesen
, P.
, Xing
, Y.
, Lehman
, L.
, and Cotts
, E.
, 2007, “Correlation of Microstructure and Heterogeneous Failure in Pb Free Solder Joints
,” Pb-Free and RoHS-Compliant Materials and Processes for Microelectronics
, C. A.
Handwerker
, K.
Suganuma
, H. L.
Reynolds
, and J.
Bath
, eds., Materials Research Society
, Warrendale, PA
.12.
Arfaei
, B.
, Xing
, Y.
, Woods
, J.
, Wolcott
, J.
, Tumne
, P.
, Borgesen
, P.
, and Cotts
, E.
, 2008, “The Effect of Sn Grain Number and Orientation on the Shear Fatigue Life of SnAgCu Solder Joints
,” Proceedings of the Electronic Components and Technology Conference 2008
, pp. 459
–465
.13.
Borgesen
, P.
, Cotts
, E.
, Yin
, L.
, Kondos
, P. A.
, Roggeman
, B.
, Tumne
, P.
, Li
, J.
, and Srihari
, K.
, 2008, “Interconnect Reliability in Medical Microelectronics Applications
,” Proceedings of the SMTA Medical Electronics Symposium
, Anaheim (CD)
.14.
Bieler
, T. R.
, Hairong
, J.
, Lehman
, L. P.
, Kirkpatrick
, T.
, Cotts
, E. J.
, Nandagopal
, B.
, 2008, “Influence of Sn Grain Size and Orientation on the Thermomechanical Response and Reliability of Pb-free Solder Joints
,” IEEE Trans. Compon. Packag. Technol.
, 31
(2
), pp. 370
–381
.15.
Bartelo
, J.
, Cain
, S. R.
, Caletka
, D.
, Darbha
, K.
, Gosselin
, T.
, Henderson
, D. W.
, King
, D.
, Knadle
, K.
, Sarkhel
, A.
, Thiel
, G.
, Woychik
, C.
, Shih
, D. Y.
, Kang
, S.
, Puttlitz
, K.
, and Woods
, J.
, 2001, “Thermomechanical Fatigue Behavior of Selected Lead-Free solders
,” Proceedings of the IPC APEX
, 2001, pp. 1
–11
.16.
Tunga
, K.
, Kacker
, K.
, Pucha
, R. V.
, and Sitaraman
, S. K.
, 2004, “Accelerated Thermal Cycling: Is it Different for Lead-Free Solder?
,” Proceedings of the 2004 Electronic Components and Technology Conference
, pp. 1579
–1585
.17.
Kang
, S.
, Lauro
, P.
, Shih
, D.
, Henderson
, D.
, Gosselin
, T.
, Bartelo
, J.
, Cain
, S.
, Goldsmith
, C.
, Puttlitz
, K.
, and Hwang
, T.
, 2004, “Evaluation of Thermal Fatigue Life and Failure Mechanisms of Sn–Ag–Cu Solder Joints With Reduced Ag Contents
,” Proceedings of the 2004 Electronic Components and Technology Conference
, pp. 661
–667
.18.
Pan
, N.
, Henshall
, G.
, Lewis
, R.
, Benedetto
, E.
, and Rayner
, J.
, 2005, “An Acceleration Model for Sn-Ag-Cu Solder Joint Reliability Under Various Thermal Cycle Conditions
,” Proceedings of the SMTA International Conference
, Chicago, IL
, Sept. 25–29, 2005, pp. 876
–883
.19.
Bath
, J.
, Sethuraman
, S.
, Zhou
, X.
, Willie
, D.
, Hyland
, K.
, Newman
, K.
, Hu
, L.
, Love,
, D.
, Reynolds
, H.
, Koichi
, K.
, Chiang
, D.
, Chin
, V.
, Teng
, S.
, Ahmed
, M.
, Henshall
, G.
, Schroeder
, V.
, Lau
, J.
, Nguyen
, Q.
, Maheswari
, A.
, Cannis
, J.
, Clech
, J.-P.
, and Gibson
, C.
, 2005, “Reliability Evaluation of Lead-Free SnAgCu PBGA676 Components Using Tin-Lead and Lead-Free SnAgCu Solder Paste
,” Proceedings of the SMTA International Conference
, Chicago, IL
, Sept. 25–29, 2005, pp. 891
–917
.20.
Osterman
, M.
, Dasgupta
, A.
, and Han
, B.
, 2006, “A Strain Range Based Model for Life Assessment of Pb-Free SAC Solder Interconnects
,” Proceedings of the 2006 Electronic Components and Technology Conference
, pp. 884
–890
.21.
Vasudevan
, V.
, and Fan
, X.
, 2008, “An Acceleration Model for Pb-Free (SAC) Solder Joint Reliability Under Thermal Cycling
,” Proceedings of the 2008 Electronic Components and Technology Conference
, pp 139
–145
.22.
Cuddalorepatta
, G.
, and Dasgupta
, A.
, 2007, “Optimization of Dwell Time for Accelerated Thermal Cycling of Sn3.0Ag0.5Cu Pb-Free Interconnects
,” IISc Centenary-International Conference on Advances in Mechanical Engineering (IC-ICAME)
, July 2007, Bangalore, India
.23.
Borgesen
, P.
, and Meilunas
, M.
, in preparation.24.
Al-Momani
, E.
, Khasawneh
, M.
, and Borgesen
, P.
, “How to Assess the Effect of Time at Operating Temperature on the Service Life of Lead Free Solder Joints
,” ASME J. Electr. Packag. (submitted)
25.
Borgesen
, P.
, 2004-2010, AREA Consortium proprietary data
.26.
Borgesen
, P.
, and Meilunas
, M.
, “Effects of Solder Paste Volume and Reflow Profiles on the Thermal Cycling Performance of Mixed SnAgCu/SnPb Solder Joints
,” IEEE Trans. Compon. Packag. Technol.
, in press.27.
IPC–9701, 2004, “
Performance Test Methods and Qualification Requirements for Surface Mount Solder Attachments
,” IPC Standard.28.
Engelmaier
, 2004, W.
, 1983, “Fatigue Life of Leadless Chip Carrier Solder Joints During Power Cycling
,” IEEE Trans. Compon., Hybrids, Manuf. Technol.
, CHMT–6
(3
), p. 232
.Copyright © 2011
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
