A generalized solder joint fatigue life model for surface mount packages was previously published in [1,2]. The model is based on correlation to measured crack growth data on BGA joints during thermal cycling. It was subsequently discovered by Anderson et al. that the ANSYS™1 5.2 finite element code used in the model had an error in its method for calculating plastic work [3]. It was shown that significant error in life prediction could result by using a recent version of the code where the bug has been fixed. The error comes about since the original crack growth constants were derived based on plastic work calculations that had the bug. In this paper, crack initiation and growth constants are recalculated using ANSYS™ 5.6. In addition, several other model related issues are explored with respect to the crack growth correlations. For example, 3D slice models were compared to quarter symmetry models. Anand’s constitutive model was compared with Darveaux’s constitutive model. It was shown that the crack growth rate dependence on strain energy density always had an exponent of 1.10+/−0.15. This is in the range of the original correlation. The model was applied to several data sets of tape-based and laminate-based BGAs. The accuracy of absolute predictions is mostly within +/−2X. The accuracy of relative predictions is within +/−25%. However, the accuracy of absolute predictions could be off by a factor of 7 in the worst case, if the analyst uses a modeling procedure that is not consistent with that used for the crack growth correlation. The key to good accuracy is to maintain consistency in the modeling procedure.

Issue Section:
Technical Papers
Keywords:
soldering, fatigue cracks
Topics:
Fatigue life, Finite element analysis, Fracture (Materials), Constitutive equations, Solder joints, Simulation, Density
1.
Darveaux, R., Banerji, K., Mawer, A., and Dody, G., 1995, “Reliability of Plastic Ball Grid Array Assembly,” Ball Grid Array Technology, J. Lau ed, McGraw-Hill, New York.
2.
Darveaux, R., 1997, “Solder Joint Fatigue Life Model,” Proc. TMS.
3.
Anderson, T., Guven, I., Madenci, E., and Gustafsson, G., 1999, “The Necessity of Reexamining Previous Life Prediction Analyses of Solder Joints in Electronic Packages,” Proc. ECTC.
4.
Darveaux, R., 1995, “Optimizing the Reliability of Thin Small Outline Package (TSOP) Solder Joints,” Advances in Electronic Packaging 1995—Proc. ASME Interpack ’95, pp. 675–685.
5.
Mawer, A., Trent, J., Vo, N., Vo, T., Guo, Y., Seto, P., Bosley, L., and Darveaux, R., 1997, “Reliability Evaluation of a PBGA MCM for Automotive Applications,” Proc. SMI, pp. 125–132.
6.
Mawer, A., Cho, D., and Darveaux, R., 1996, “The Effect of PBGA Solder Pad Geometry on Solder Joint Reliability,” Proc. SMI, pp. 127–135.
7.
Fusaro, J., and Darveaux, R., 1996, “Reliability of Copper Baseplate High Current Power Modules,” Proc. ISHM Symposium.
8.
Amagai, M., 1998, “Chip Scale Package (CSP) Solder Joint Reliability and Modeling,” Proc. 36th International Reliability Physics Symposium, pp. 260–268.
9.
Johnson, Z., 1999, “Implementation of and Extensions to Darveaux’s Approach to Finite-Element Simulation of BGA Solder Joint Reliability,” Proc. ECTC.
10.
Darveaux, R., 2000, “Effect of Simulation Methodology on Solder Joint Crack Growth Correlation,” Proc. ECTC.
11.
Darveaux, R., 1993, “Crack Initiation and Growth in Surface Mount Solder Joints,” Proc. ISHM International Symposium on Microelectronics, pp. 86–97.
12.
Clech, J-P., Noctor, D. M., Manock, J. C., Lynott, G. W., and Bader, F. E., 1994, “Surface Mount Assembly Failure Statistics and Failure Free Time,” Proc. 44th IEEE ECTC.
13.
Mawer A., and Darveaux, R., 1993, “Calculation of Thermal Cycling and Application Fatigue Life of Plastic Ball Grid Array (PBGA) Package,” Proc. IEPS.
14.
Darveaux, R., and Mawer, A., 1995, “Thermal and Power Cycling Limits of Plastic Ball Grid Array (PBGA) Assemblies,” Proc. Surface Mount International, pp. 315–326.
15.
Petrucci, M., Johnson, R., Mawer, A., McQuiggin, T., Nelson, B., and Rosckes, D., 1993, “Feasibility Study of Ball Grid Array Packaging,” Proc. Nepcon East.
16.
Ejim, T., Holliday, A., Bader, F. E., and Gahr, S., 1995, “Designed Experiment to Determine Attachment Reliability Drivers for PBGA Packages,” Proc. SMI, pp. 385–392.
17.
Syed, A., Panczak, T., Darveaux, R., Lee, S. G., Lee, C. H., and Partridge, J., 1999, “Solder Joint Reliability of Chip Array BGA™,” Proc. SMTA, pp. 90–97.
18.
Darveaux, R., and Mawer, A., 1998, “Solder Joint Fatigue Life of fleXBGA™ Assemblies,” Proc. ECTC, pp. 707–712.
19.
Darveaux, R., Heckman, J., and Mawer, A., 1998, “Effect of Test Board Design on the 2nd Level Reliability of a Fine Pitch BGA Package,” Proc. SMI, pp. 105–111.
20.
Darveaux, R., Heckman, J., Syed, A., and Mawer, A., 2000, “Solder Joint Fatigue Life of Fine Pitch BGAs-Impact of Design and Material Choices,” Microelectron. Reliab.
21.
Anderson, T., Barut, A., Guven, I., and Madenci, E., 2000, “Revisit of Life Prediction Model for Solder Joints,” Proc. ECTC, pp. 1064–1069.
22.
Madenci, E., 2000, private communication, June 6.
23.
Gustafsson, G., Guven, I., Kradinov, V., and Madenci, E., 2000, “Finite Element Modeling of BGA Packages for Life Prediction,” Proc. ECTC, pp. 1059–1063.
Copyright © 2002
 by ASME
You do not currently have access to this content.