ABSTRACT

The standard spacing factor developed by Powers is typically used to evaluate the quality of the air void system in hardened concrete, but it does not always correlate with durability of the concrete. Several air void spacing equations, which are also applicable when polymeric microspheres are used in place of air entrainment, have been proposed because of the need for a more robust and comprehensive basis to evaluate the quality of the air void system. However, the spacing parameters provided by the various proposed equations, when used as sole measures in predicting the frost resistance of concrete, do not seem to do any better than the standard spacing factor. Dispersion and spatial distribution have been shown to be effective ways of describing air void or microsphere systems in hardened concrete because they have been quantified to establish criteria to assess the frost resistance of concrete. In this paper, dispersion and distribution factors are further elaborated upon to explain how they characterize zones that are protected by air voids or microspheres in the concrete. Criteria to assess the durability of concrete under rapid cycles of freezing and thawing based on the dispersion and distribution factors are linked to the exposure classes defined in the ACI 318 Code and in the recently proposed Unified Durability Guidance in ACI Committee Documents.

References

1.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
Compliance Concept in Protection of Concrete from Freezing-and-Thawing Damage
,”
ACI Materials Journal
117
, no. 
6
(November
2020
):
187
200
,
2.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
A New Way to Deliver Protection from Freezing-and-Thawing Damage
,”
ACI Concrete International
43
, no. 
1
(January
2021
):
27
33
.
3.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
Microspheres in Hardened Concrete
,”
ACI Concrete International
44
, no. 
3
(March
2022
):
43
50
.
4.
T. C.
 
Powers
, “
Air Requirement of Frost Resistant Concrete
,”
Highway Research Board Proceedings
29
(
1949
):
184
202
.
5.
R. E.
 
Philleo
, “
A Method for Analyzing Void Distribution in Air-Entrained Concrete
,”
Cement, Concrete and Aggregates
5
, no. 
2
(January
1983
):
128
130
,
6.
B.
 
Lu
and
S.
 
Torquato
, “
Nearest-Surface Distribution Functions for Polydispersed Particle Systems
,”
Physical Review A
45
, no. 
8
(April
1992
):
5530
5544
,
7.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
Mean Spacing of Air Voids in Hardened Concrete
,”
ACI Materials Journal
90
, no. 
2
(March
1993
):
174
181
,
8.
K. C.
 
Hover
,
K.
 
Natesaiyer
,
M.
 
Simon
, and
K.
 
Snyder
, “
Discussion of: ‘Mean Spacing of Air Voids in Hardened Concrete’ by E. K. Attiogbe
,”
ACI Materials Journal
91
, no. 
1
(January
1994
):
121
127
.
9.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
Volume Fraction of Protected Paste and Mean Spacing of Air Voids
,”
ACI Materials Journal
94
, no. 
6
(November
1997
):
588
591
,
10.
R.
 
Pleau
and
M.
 
Pigeon
, “
The Use of the Flow Length Concept to Assess the Efficiency of Air Entrainment with Regards to Frost Durability: Part 1 – Description of the Test Method
,”
Cement, Concrete and Aggregates
18
, no. 
1
(June
1996
):
19
29
,
11.
Standard Test Method for Microscopical Determination of Parameters of the Air-Void System in Hardened Concrete
(Superseded), ASTM C457/C457M-16 (
West Conshohocken, PA
:
ASTM International
, approved December 1,
2016
), https://doi.org/10.1520/C0457_C0457M-16
12.
M. T.
 
Hasholt
, “
Air Void Structure and Frost Resistance: A Challenge to Powers’ Spacing Factor
,”
Materials and Structures
47
, no. 
5
(May
2014
):
911
923
,
13.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
Predicting Freeze-Thaw Durability of Concrete – A New Approach
,”
ACI Materials Journal
93
, no. 
5
(September
1996
):
457
464
,
14.
K. A.
 
Snyder
, “
A Numerical Test of Air Void Spacing Equations
,”
Advanced Cement Based Materials
8
, no. 
1
(July
1998
):
28
44
,
15.
N. P.
 
Mayercsik
,
R.
 
Felice
,
M. T.
 
Ley
, and
K. E.
 
Kurtis
, “
A Probabilistic Technique for Entrained Air Void Analysis in Hardened Concrete
,”
Cement and Concrete Research
59
(May
2014
):
16
23
,
16.
K.
 
Lyu
,
E. J.
 
Garboczi
, and
X.
 
Liu
, “
A Quantitative Characterization of Spatial Arrangement of Air Voids in Mortars via X-ray CT and Numerical Calculations
,”
Construction and Building Materials
360
(December
2022
):
129550
,
17.
J.
 
Clifford
, “
What Is the Difference between Particle Distribution and Dispersion in Thermally Conductive Adhesives?
” C-Therm,
2023
, https://ctherm.com/resources/newsroom/blog/dispersion_and_distribution/
18.
S.
 
Fakirov
, “
Polymer Nanocomposites: Why Their Mechanical Performance Does Not Justify the Expectation and a Possible Solution to the Problem?
eXPRESS Polymer Letters
14
, no. 
5
(
2020
):
436
466
,
19.
Standard Test Method for Resistance of Concrete to Rapid Freezing and Thawing
(Withdrawn), ASTM C666/C666M-15 (
West Conshohocken, PA
:
ASTM International
, approved February 1,
2015
), https://doi.org/10.1520/C0666_C0666M-15
20.
Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary
, ACI 318R-19 (
Farmington Hills, MI
:
American Concrete Institute
,
2019
).
21.
K. S. T.
 
Chopperla
,
S.
 
Smith
,
T.
 
Drimalas
,
N. P.
 
Vaddey
,
A.
 
Bentivegna
,
K. E.
 
Kurtis
,
M. D. A.
 
Thomas
, and
J. H.
 
Ideker
, “
Unified Durability Guidance in ACI Committee Documents
,”
ACI Materials Journal
119
, no. 
2
(March
2022
):
29
41
,
22.
K.
 
Snyder
,
K.
 
Natesaiyer
, and
K.
 
Hover
, “
The Stereological and Statistical Properties of Entrained Air Voids in Concrete: A Mathematical Basis for Air Void System Characterization
,” in
Materials Science of Concrete VI
, ed.
S.
 
Mindess
and
J. P.
 
Skalny
(
Hoboken, NJ
:
Wiley
,
2001
),
129
214
.
23.
E. E.
 
Underwood
,
Quantitative Stereology
(
Boston, MA
:
Addison-Wesley Educational Publishers Inc.
,
1970
).
24.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
Predicting the Magnitude of Microsphere Parameters Obtained from Microscopical Examination of Hardened Concrete
,”
Journal of Testing and Evaluation
51
, no. 
5
(September/October
2023
):
3418
3434
,
25.
K.
 
Lyu
,
E. J.
 
Garboczi
,
Y.
 
Gao
,
C.
 
Miao
, and
X.
 
Liu
, “
Relationship between Fine Aggregate Size and the Air Void System of Six Mortars: I. Air Void Content and Diameter Distribution
,”
Cement and Concrete Composites
131
(August
2022
):
104599
,
26.
K.
 
Obla
,
H.
 
Kim
, and
C. L.
 
Lobo
, “
Criteria for Freeze-Thaw Resistant Concrete Mixtures
,”
Advances in Civil Engineering Materials
5
, no. 
2
(December
2016
):
119
141
,
27.
D.
 
Jana
,
B.
 
Erlin
, and
M. F.
 
Pistilli
, “
A Closer Look at Entrained Air in Concrete
,”
Concrete International
27
, no. 
7
(July
2005
):
31
34
.
28.
E. K.
 
Attiogbe
, “
Air Content and Freezing-and-Thawing Durability
,”
Concrete International
44
, no. 
2
(February
2022
):
59
60
.
29.
M. T.
 
Ley
,
D.
 
Welchel
,
J.
 
Peery
,
S.
 
Khatibmasjedi
, and
J.
 
LeFlore
, “
Determining the Air-Void Distribution in Fresh Concrete with the Sequential Air Method
,”
Construction and Building Materials
150
(September
2017
):
723
737
,
30.
Standard Method of Testing for Characterizing of the Air-Void System of Freshly Mixed Concrete by the Sequential Pressure Method
, AASHTO TP 118 (
Washington, DC
:
American Association of State and Highway and Transportation Officials
,
2017
).
You do not currently have access to this content.