The stiffness of the external fixation highly influences the fracture healing pattern. In this work we study this aspect by means of a finite element model of a simple transverse mid-diaphyseal fracture of an ovine metatarsus fixed with a bilateral external fixator. In order to simulate the regenerative process, a previously developed mechanobiological model of bone fracture healing was implemented in three dimensions. This model is able to simulate tissue differentiation, bone regeneration, and callus growth. A physiological load of was applied and three different stiffnesses of the external fixator were simulated (2300, 1725, and ). The interfragmentary strain and load sharing mechanism between bone and the external fixator were compared to those recorded in previous experimental works. The effects of the stiffness on the callus shape and tissue distributions in the fracture site were also analyzed. We predicted that a lower stiffness of the fixator delays fracture healing and causes a larger callus, in correspondence to well-documented clinical observations.
1.
Goodship
, A. E.
, Watkins
, P. E.
, Rigby
, H. S.
, and Kenwright
, J.
, 1993, “The Role of Fixator Frame Stiffness in the Control of Fracture Healing. An Experimental Study
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 26
(9
), pp. 1027
–1035
.2.
Chao
, E. Y. S.
, Aro
, H. T.
, Lewallen
, D. G.
, and Kelly
, P. J.
, 1989, “The Effect of Rigidity on Fracture Healing in External Fixation
,” Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.
0009-921X, 241
, pp. 24
–35
.3.
Wu
, J. J.
, Shyr
, H. S.
, Chao
, E. Y.
, and Kelly
, P. J.
, 1984, “Comparison of Osteotomy Healing Under External Fixation Devices With Different Stiffness Characteristics
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Am. Vol.
0021-9355, Vol. 66
, pp. 1258
–1264
.4.
Klein
, P.
, Schell
, H.
, Streitparth
, F.
, Heller
, M.
, Kassi
, J. P.
, Kandziora
, F.
, Bragulla
, H.
, Haas
, N. P.
, and Duda
, G. N.
, 2003, “The Initial Phase of Fracture Healing is Specifically Sensitive to Mechanical Conditions
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 21
(4
), pp. 662
–669
.5.
Augat
, P.
, Margevicious
, K.
, Simon
, J.
, Wolf
, S.
, Suger
, G.
, and Claes
, L.
, 1998, “Local Tissue Properties in Bone Healing: Influence of Size and Stability of the Osteotomy Gap
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 16
, pp. 475
–481
.6.
McKibbin
, B.
, 1978, “The Biology of Fracture Healing in Long Bones
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Br. Vol.
0301-620X, Vol. 60B
(2
), pp. 150
–162
.7.
Claes
, L.
, Heigele
, C. A.
, Neidlinger-Wilke
, C.
, Kaspar
, D.
, Seidl
, W.
, Margevicius
, K.
, and Augat
, P.
, 1998, “Effects of Mechanical Factors on the Fracture Healing Process
,” Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.
0009-921X, 355S
, pp. 132
–147
.8.
Goodship
, A. E.
, 1992, “Mechanical Stimulus to Bone
,” Ann. Rheum. Dis.
0003-4967, 51
, pp. 4
–6
.9.
Claes
, L.
, Augat
, P.
, Suger
, G.
, and Wilke
, H. J.
, 1997, “Influence of Size and Stability of the Osteotomy Gap on the Success of Fracture Healing
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 15
(4
), pp. 577
–584
.10.
Lacroix
, D.
, and Prendergast
, P. J.
, 2002, “A Mechano-Regulation Model for Tissue Differentiation During Fracture Healing: Analysis of Gap Size and Loading
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 35
, pp. 1163
–1171
.11.
Kuiper
, J. H.
, Ashton
, B. A.
, and Richardson
, J. B.
, 2000, “Computer Simulation of Fracture Callus Formation and Stiffness Restoration
,” Proc. Proc. 12th Europ. Soc. Biomech
, P. J.
Prendergast
, T. C.
Lee
, and A. J.
Carr
, eds., p. 61
.12.
Carter
, D. R.
, Beaupré
, G. S.
, Giori
, N. J.
, and Helms
, J. A.
, 1998, “Mechanobiology of Skeletal Regeneration
,” Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.
0009-921X, 355S
, pp. 41
–55
.13.
Claes
, L. E.
, and Heigele
, C. A.
, 1999, “Magnitudes of Local Stress and Strain Along Bony Surfaces Predict the Course and Type of Fracture Healing
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 32
, pp. 255
–266
.14.
Gardner
, T. N.
, Stoll
, T.
, Marks
, L.
, Mishra
, S.
, and Tate
, M. K.
, 2000, “The Influence of Mechanical Stimulus on the Pattern of Tissue Differentiation in a Long Bone Fracture—an FEM Study
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 33
, pp. 415
–425
.15.
Bailón-Plaza
, A.
, and van der Meulen
, M. C.
, 2003, “Beneficial Effects of Moderate, Early Loading and Adverse Effects of Delayed or Excessive Loading on Bone Healing
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 36
(8
), pp. 1069
–1077
.16.
Ament
, C.
, and Hofer
, E. P.
, 2000, “A Fuzzy Logic Model of Fracture Healing
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 33
, pp. 961
–968
.17.
Isaksson
, H.
, Wilson
, W.
, van Donkelaar
, C. C.
, Huiskes
, R.
, and Ito
, K.
, “Comparison of Biophysical Stimuli for Mechano-Regulation of Tissue Differentiation During Fracture Healing
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, DOI 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2005.01.037.18.
Prendergast
, P. J.
, Huiskes
, R.
, and Soballe
, K.
, 1997, “Biophysical Stimuli on Cells During Tissue Differentiation at Implant Interfaces
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 6
, pp. 539
–548
.19.
García-Aznar
, J.
, Kuiper
, J.
, Doblaré
, M.
, and Richardson
, J.
, “Computational Simulation of Fracture Healing.
,” Proceedings of the 13th Conference of European Society of Biomechanics
, Wroclaw, Poland
, pp. 394
–395
.20.
Gómez-Benito
, M. J.
, García-Aznar
, J. M.
, Kuiper
, J. H.
, and Doblaré
, M.
, 2005, “Influence of Fracture Gap Size on the Pattern of Long Bone Healing: A Computational Study
,” J. Theor. Biol.
0022-5193, 235
(1
), pp. 105
–119
.21.
Kaplan
, S. J.
, Hayes
, W. C.
, Mudan
, P.
, Lelli
, J. L.
, and White
, A. A.
, 1985, “Monitoring the Healing of a Tibial Osteotomy in the Rabbit Treated With External Fixation
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 3
(3
), pp. 325
–330
.22.
Prat
, J.
, Juan
, J.
, Vera
, P.
, Hoyos
, J.
, Dejoz
, R.
, Peris
, J. L.
, Sanchez-Lacuesta
, J.
, and Comin
, M.
, 1994, “Load Transmission Through the Callus Site With External Fixation Systems: Theoretical and Experimental Analysis
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 27
(4
), pp. 469
–478
.23.
Bishop
, N. E.
, Tami
, I.
, Schneider
, E.
, and Ito
, K.
, 2002, “In Vivo Comparison of Early Fracture Healing Under Deviatoric and Volumetric Deformation
,” Acta of Bioengin. Biomech.
, 4
(S1
), pp. 754
–755
.24.
Kelly
, D. J.
, and Prendergast
, P. J.
, 2005, “Mechano-Regulation of Stem Cell Differentiation and Tissue Regeneration in Osteochondral Defects
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 38
(7
), pp. 1413
–1422
.25.
Lacroix
, D.
, and Prendergast
, P. J.
, 2002, “Three-Dimensional Simulation of Fracture Repair in the Human Tibia
,” Comput. Methods Biomech. Biomed. Eng.
1025-5842, 5
(5
), pp. 369
–376
.26.
Simon
, U.
, Augat
, P.
, Forster
, E.
, Breuer
, H.
, and Claes
, L.
, 2004, “Fracture Healing Under Non-Axisymmetrical Loading Conditions
,” Proc. Sixth International Symposium on Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering
.27.
Postacchini
, F.
, Gumina
, S.
, Perugia
, D.
, and De Martino
, C.
, 1995, “Early Fracture Callus in the Diaphysis of Human Long Bones
,” Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.
0009-921X, 310
, pp. 218
–228
.28.
Bland
, Y. S.
, Critchlow
, M. A.
, and E.
, A. D.
, 1999, “The Expression of the Fibrillar Collagen Genes During Fracture Healing
,” Histochem. J.
0018-2214, 31
, pp. 797
–809
.29.
Wilsman
, N. J.
, Farnum
, C. E.
, Leiferman
, E. M.
, Fry
, M.
, and Barreto
, C.
, 1996, “Differential Growth by Growth Plates as a Function of Multiple Parameters of Chondrocytic Kinetics
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 14
, pp. 927
–936
.30.
Beaupré
, G. S.
, Orr
, T. E.
, and Carter
, D. R.
, 1990, “An Approach for Time-Dependent Bone Modeling and Remodeling—Theoretical Development
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 8
, pp. 551
–651
.31.
Beaupré
, G. S.
, Orr
, T. E.
, and Carter
, D. R.
, 1990, “An Approach for Time-Dependent Bone Modeling and Remodeling—Application: A Preliminary Remodeling Simulation
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 8
, pp. 662
–670
.32.
Hibbit, Karlsson and Sorensen, Inc.
, 2002, Theory Manual, v. 6.3
HKS Inc. Pawtucket, RI, USA.33.
Mücke
, E.
, 1993, “Shapes and Implementations in Three-Dimensional Geometry
,” Ph.D. thesis, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.34.
Augat
, P.
, Burger
, J.
, Schorlemmer
, S.
, Henke
, T.
, Peraus
, M.
, and Claes
, L.
, 2003, “Shear Movement at the Fracture Site Delays Healing in a Diaphyseal Fracture Model
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 21
, pp. 1011
–1017
.35.
Einhorn
, T. A.
, 1998, “The Cell and Molecular Biology of Fracture Healing
,” Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.
0009-921X, 355
, pp. S7
–S21
.36.
Duda
, G. N.
, Eckert-Hübner
, K.
, Sokiranski
, R.
, Kreutner
, A.
, Miller
, R.
, and Claes
, L.
, 1998, “Analysis of Inter-Fragmentary Movement as a Function of Musculoskeletal Loading Conditions in Sheep
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 31
(3
), pp. 201
–210
.37.
Yang
, L.
, Nayagam
, S.
, and Saleh
, M.
, 2003, “Stiffness Characteristics and Inter-Fragmentary Displacements With Different Hybrid External Fixators
,” Clin. Biomech. (Bristol, Avon)
0268-0033, 18
(2
), pp. 166
–172
.38.
Carpenter
, J. E.
, Hipp
, J. A.
, Gerhart
, T. N.
, Rudman
, C. G.
, Hayes
, W. C.
, and Trippel
, S. B.
, 1992, “Failure of Growth Hormone to Alter Biomechanics of Fracture-Healing in a Rabbit Model
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Am. Vol.
0021-9355, 74A
(3
), pp. 359
–367
.39.
Jenkis
, P.
, and Nokes
, L.
, 1994, “The Use of Gauges to Measure Bone Fracture Healing. A Review
,” Curr. Orthop.
, 8
, pp. 116
–118
.40.
Crelin
, E. S.
, White
, A. A.
, Panjabi
, M. M.
, and Southwick
, W. O.
, 1978, “Microscopic Changes in Fractures Rabbit Tibias
,” Conn Med.
0010-6178, 42
(9
), pp. 561
–569
.41.
Ashhurst
, D. E.
, 1986, “The Influence of Mechanical Stability on the Healing of Experimental Fractures in the Rabbit: A Microscopical Study
,” Ser. B, 313
, pp. 271
–302
.42.
Kenwright
, J.
, and Goodship
, A. E.
, 1989, “Controlled Mechanical Stimulation in the Treatment of Tibial Fractures
,” Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.
0009-921X, 241
, pp. 36
–47
.43.
Williams
, E. A.
, Rand
, J. A.
, An
, K. N.
, Chao
, E. Y. S.
, and Kelly
, P. J.
, 1989, “The Early Healing of Tibial Osteotomies Stabilized by One-Plane and Two-Plane External Fixation
,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Am. Vol.
0021-9355, Vol. 69
, pp. 355
–365
.44.
Goodship
, A. E.
, Lanyon
, L. E.
, Nicopoulos
, A.
, and O’Connor
, J. A.
, 1978, “A Technique for Investigating the Response of Bone to Changes in its Mechanical Environment
,” J. Physiol. (London)
0022-3751, 277
, p. 39
.45.
Gardner
, T. N.
, and Mishra
, S.
, 2003, “The Biomechanical Environment of a Bone Fracture and its Influence Upon the Morphology of Healing
,” Med. Eng. Phys.
1350-4533, 25
, pp. 455
–464
.46.
Martin
, R. B.
, Burr
, D. B.
, and Sharkey
, N. A.
, 1998, Skeletal Tissue Mechanics
, Springer-Verlarg
, New York
.47.
Griffin
, L. V.
, Gibeling
, J. C.
, Martin
, R.
, Gibson
, V.
, and Stover
, S.
, 1997, “Model of Flexural Fatigue Damage Accumulation for Cortical Bone
,” J. Orthop. Res.
0736-0266, 15
(4
), pp. 607
–614
.48.
Sasaki
, N.
, and Odajima
, S.
, 1996, “Elongation Mechanism of Collagen Fibrils and Force-Strain Relations of Tendon at Each Level of Structural Hierarchy
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 29
, pp. 1131
–1136
.49.
Farquhar
, T.
, Dawson
, P.
, and Torzilli
, P.
, 1990, “A Microstructural Model for the Anisotropic Drained Stiffness of Articular Cartilage
,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng.
0148-0731, 112
, pp. 414
–425
.50.
Simha
, N. K.
, Fedewa
, M.
, Leo
, P. H.
, Lewis
, J. L.
, and Oegema
, T.
, 1999, “A Composites Theory Predicts the Dependence of Stiffness of Cartilage Culture Tissues on Collagen Volume Fraction
,” J. Biomech.
0021-9290, 32
, pp. 503
–509
.Copyright © 2006
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
