Skip to Main Content
Skip Nav Destination
ASTM Selected Technical Papers
Safety in Ice Hockey: 6th Volume
By
Terry A. Smith
Terry A. Smith
Symposium Chairs and STP Editor
1
Dynamic Research, Inc.
,
Torrance, CA,
US
Search for other works by this author on:
Alan B. Ashare
Alan B. Ashare
Symposium Chairs and STP Editor
2
St. Elizabeth's Medical Center, Tufts University School of Medicine
,
Boston, MA,
US
Search for other works by this author on:
ISBN:
978-0-8031-7696-6
No. of Pages:
124
Publisher:
ASTM International
Publication date:
2020

This study examined gender differences in total symptoms and previous concussions for young adult ice hockey players . A sample of 2,472 players, ages 19 to 25, completed preseason baseline ImPACT© (immediate post-concussion assessment and cognitive testing) and were assigned to groups based on self-reported concussion history: none (male N = 595; female N = 136), one previous (male N = 791; female N = 144), two or more previous (male = 655; female = 161). Chi-square analysis determined gender differences in concussion history. Baseline Post-Concussion Symptom Scale (PCSS) total symptom and cluster scores (cognitive, physical, emotional, sleep) were compared across gender and concussion history using analysis of variance (ANOVA). There were significant differences in age (p = 0.002, η2 < 0.01) and gender proportion (p = 0.037, V = 0.04) across concussion groups. Hockey players with two or more concussions reported greater total (p = 0.001, η2 = 0.01), physical (p = 0.001 η2 = 0.01), cognitive (p = 0.001 η2 = 0.01), and sleep (p = 0.002 η2 = 0.01) symptom/cluster scores than those with a history of 0-1 concussion. Male hockey players reported more total (p = 0.002 η2 = 0.01), physical (p = 0.003 η2 = 0.01), and cognitive (p = 0.002 η2 = 0.01) symptom/cluster scores. Similar to previous research, females reported a greater number of concussions than their males, yet likelihood of sustaining at least one concussion was equal. Players sustaining two or more concussions felt more symptomatic than those with 0-1 concussion regardless of gender. Females reported more total, physical, and emotional symptoms, but not more cognitive and sleep symptoms, contrasting previous research showing greater symptoms across all symptom clusters. Sustaining concussions was not related to greater emotional symptoms regardless of gender.

1.
Broshek
D. K.
,
Kaushik
T.
,
Freeman
J. R.
,
Erlanger
D.
,
Webbe
F.
, and
Barth
J. T.
, “
Sex Differences in Outcome Following Sports-Related Concussion
,”
Journal of Neurosurgery
102
(
2005
): 856–863.
2.
Covassin
T.
and
Elbin
R. J.
, “
The Female Athlete: The Role of Gender in the Assessment and Management of Sport-Related Concussion
,”
Clinics in Sports Medicine
30
(
2011
): 125–131.
3.
Dick
R. W.
, “
Is There a Gender Difference in Concussion Incidence and Outcomes?
British Journal of Sports Medicine
43
,
Suppl. 1
(
2009
): i46–i50.
4.
Colvin
A. C.
,
Mullen
J.
,
Lovell
M. R.
,
West
R. V.
,
Collins
M. W.
, and
Groh
M.
, “
The Role of Concussion History and Gender in Recovery from Soccer-Related Concussion
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
37
(
2009
): 1699–1704.
5.
Covassin
T.
,
Moran
R.
, and
Elbin
R. J.
, “
Sex Differences in Reported Concussion Injury Rates and Time Loss from Participation: An Update of the National Collegiate Athletic Association Injury Surveillance Program from 2004–2005 through 2008–2009
,”
Journal of Athletic Training
51
(
2016
): 189–194.
6.
Covassin
T.
,
Moran
R.
, and
Wilhelm
K.
, “
Concussion Symptoms and Neurocognitive Performance of High School and College Athletes Who Incur Multiple Concussions
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
41
(
2013
): 2885–2889.
7.
Kontos
A. P.
,
Elbin
R. J.
,
Schatz
P.
,
Covassin
T.
,
Henry
L.
,
Pardini
J.
, and
Collins
M. W.
, “
A Revised Factor Structure for the Post-Concussion Symptom Scale: Baseline and Postconcussion Factors
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
40
(
2012
): 2375–2384.
8.
Bazarian
J. J.
,
Blyth
B.
,
Mookerjee
S.
,
He
H.
, and
McDermott
M. P.
, “
Sex Differences in Outcome after Mild Traumatic Brain Injury
,”
Journal of Neurotrauma
27
(
2010
): 527–539.
9.
Covassin
T.
,
Elbin
R. J.
,
Harris
W.
,
Parker
T.
, and
Kontos
A.
, “
The Role of Age and Sex in Symptoms, Neurocognitive Performance, and Postural Stability in Athletes after Concussion
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
40
(
2012
): 1303–1312.
10.
Farace
E.
and
Alves
W. M.
, “
Do Women Fare Worse? A Metaanalysis of Gender Differences in Outcome after Traumatic Brain Injury
,”
Journal of Neurosurgery
93
(
2000
): 539–545.
11.
Moser
R. S.
,
Olek
L.
, and
Schatz
P.
, “
Gender Differences in Symptom Reporting on Baseline Sport Concussion Testing across the Youth Age Span
,”
Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology
34
(
2019
): 50–59.
12.
Covassin
T.
,
Swanik
C. B.
,
Sachs
M.
,
Kendrick
Z.
,
Schatz
P.
,
Zillmer
E.
, and
Kaminaris
C.
, “
Sex Differences in Baseline Neuropsychological Function and Concussion Symptoms of Collegiate Athletes
,”
British Journal of Sports Medicine
40
(
2006
): 923–927.
13.
Lovell
M. R.
,
Iverson
G. L.
,
Collins
M. W.
,
Podell
K.
,
Johnston
K. M.
,
Pardini
D.
,
Pardini
J.
,
Norwig
J.
, and
Maroon
J. C.
, “
Measurement of Symptoms Following Sports-Related Concussion: Reliability and Normative Data for the Post-Concussion Scale
,”
Applied Neuropsychology
13
(
2006
): 166–174.
14.
Kroenke
K.
and
Spitzer
R. L.
, “
Gender Differences in the Reporting of Physical and Somatoform Symptoms
,”
Psychosomatic Medicine
60
(
1998
): 150–155.
15.
Husky
M. M.
,
Mazure
C. M.
,
Maciejewski
P. K.
, and
Swendsen
J. D.
, “
Past Depression and Gender Interact to Influence Emotional Reactivity to Daily Life Stress
,”
Cognitive Therapy and Research
33
(
2009
): 264–271.
16.
Sigmon
S. T.
,
Pells
J. J.
,
Boulard
N. E.
,
Whitcomb-Smith
S.
,
Edenfield
T. M.
,
Hermann
B. A.
,
LaMattina
S. M.
,
Schartel
J. G.
, and
Kubik
E.
, “
Gender Differences in Self-Reports of Depression: The Response Bias Hypothesis Revisited
,”
Sex Roles
53
(
2005
): 401–411.
17.
Tanabe
T.
,
Snyder
A. R.
,,
Bay
R. C.
, and
McLeod
T. C.
V.
, “
Representative Values of Health-Related Quality of Life Among Female and Male Adolescent Athletes and the Impact of Gender
,”
Athletic Training and Sports Health Care
2
(
2010
): 106–112.
18.
Barth
J. T.
,
Freeman
J. R.
,
Broshek
D. K.
, and
Varney
R. N.
, “
Acceleration-Deceleration Sport-Related Concussion: The Gravity of It All
,”
Journal of Athletic Training
36
(
2001
): 253–256.
19.
Tierney
R. T.
,
Sitler
M. R.
,
Swanik
C. B.
,
Swanik
K. A.
,
Higgins
M.
, and
Torg
J.
, “
Gender Differences in Head–Neck Segment Dynamic Stabilization during Head Acceleration
,”
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
37
(
2005
): 272–279.
20.
Moser
R. S.
and
Schatz
P.
, “
Increased Symptom Reporting in Young Athletes Based on History of Previous Concussions
,”
Developmental Neuropsychology
42
(
2017
): 276–283.
21.
Hootman
J. M.
,
Dick
R.
, and
Agel
J.
, “
Epidemiology of Collegiate Injuries for 15 Sports: Summary and Recommendations for Injury Prevention Initiatives
,”
Journal of Athletic Training
42
(
2007
): 311–319.
22.
Iverson
G. L.
,
Lovell
M. R.
, and
Collins
M. W.
, “
Interpreting Change on ImPACT Following Sport Concussion
,”
Clinical Neuropsychology
17
(
2003
): 460–467.
23.
Iverson
G. L.
,
Lovell
M. R.
, and
Collins
M. W.
, “
Validity of ImPACT for Measuring Processing Speed Following Sports-Related Concussion
,”
Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology
27
(
2005
): 683–689.
24.
Lau
B. C.
,
Collins
M. W.
, and
Lovell
M. R.
, “
Sensitivity and Specificity of Subacute Computerized Neurocognitive Testing and Symptom Evaluation in Predicting Outcomes after Sports-Related Concussion
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
39
(
2011
): 1209–1216.
25.
Maerlender
A.
,
Flashman
L.
,
Kessler
A.
,
Kubhani
S.
,
Greenwald
R.
,
Tosteson
T.
, and
McAllister
T.
, “
Examination of the Construct Validity of ImPACT Computerized Test, Traditional, and Experimental Neuropsychological Measures
,”
Clinical Neuropsychology
24
(
2010
): 1309–1325.
26.
Maerlender
A.
,
Flashman
L.
,
Kessler
A.
,
Kumbhani
S.
,
Greenwald
R.
,
Tosteson
T.
, and
McAllister
T.
, “
Discriminant Construct Validity of ImPACT™: A Companion Study
,”
Clinical Neuropsychologist
27
(
2013
): 290–299.
27.
Elbin
R. J.
,
Schatz
P.
, and
Covassin
T.
, “
One-Year Test-Retest Reliability of the Online Version of ImPACT in High School Athletes
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
39
(
2011
): 2319–2324.
28.
Nakayama
Y.
,
Covassin
T.
,
Schatz
P.
,
Nogle
S.
, and
Kovan
J.
, “
Examination of the Test-Retest Reliability of a Computerized Neurocognitive Test Battery
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
42
(
2014
): 2000–2005.
29.
Schatz
P.
and
Ferris
C. S.
, “
One-Month Test-Retest Reliability of the ImPACT Test Battery
,”
Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology
28
(
2013
): 499–504.
30.
Broglio
S. P.
,
Macciocchi
S. N.
, and
Ferrara
M. S.
, “
Sensitivity of the Concussion Assessment Battery
,”
Neurosurgery
60
(
2007
): 1050–1058.
31.
Schatz
P.
,
Pardini
J. E.
,
Lovell
M. R.
,
Collins
M. W.
, and
Podell
K.
, “
Sensitivity and Specificity of the ImPACT Test Battery for Concussion in Athletes
,”
Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology
21
(
2006
): 91–99.
32.
Schatz
P.
and
Sandel
M.
, “
Sensitivity and Specificity of the Online Version of ImPACT in High School and Collegiate Athletes
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
41
(
2013
): 321–326.
33.
Lovell
M. R.
,
ImPACT Technical Manual: Online ImPACT 2007–2012
(
Pittsburgh, PA
:
ImPACT Applications, Inc.
,
2011
).
34.
Cohen
J.
, “
A Power Primer
,”
Psychological Bulletin
112
(
1992
): 155–159.
35.
Cohen
J.
,
Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences
, 2nd ed. (
San Diego, CA
:
Academic Press
,
1988
).
36.
Moser
R. S.
,
Schatz
P.
, and
Jordan
B. D.
, “
Prolonged Effects of Concussion in High School Athletes
,”
Neurosurgery
57
(
2005
): 300–306.
37.
Schatz
P.
,
Moser
R.
,
Covassin
T.
, and
Karpf
R.
, “
Early Indicators of Enduring Symptoms in High School Athletes with Multiple Previous Concussions
,”
Neurosurgery
68
(
2011
): 1562–1567.
38.
Solomon
G.
, “
Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy in Sports: A Historical and Narrative Review
,”
Developmental Neuropsychology
43
(
2018
): 279–311.
39.
Wojtowicz
M.
,
Iverson
G. L.
,
Silverberg
N. D.
,
Mannix
R.
,
Zafonte
R.
,
Maxwell
B.
, and
Berkner
P. D.
, “
Consistency of Self-Reported Concussion History in Adolescent Athletes
,”
Journal of Neurotrauma
34
(
2017
): 322–327.
40.
Van Kampen
D. A.
,
Lovell
M. R.
,
Pardini
J. E.
,
Collins
M. W.
, and
Fu
F. H.
, “
The ‘Value Added’ of Neurocognitive Testing after Sports-Related Concussion
,”
American Journal of Sports Medicine
34
(
2006
): 1630–1635.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this chapter.
Close Modal

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal