This paper presents both criticism and suggested changes to boiler efficiency standards associated with fossil-fired steam generators. These standards include the widely used ASME PTC 4.1, PTC 4 and DIN 1942, and others. The chief criticism is inconsistent application of thermodynamic principles. Specifically, conceptual errors are made with application of reference temperatures and the treatment of shaft powers. When using computed fuel flow as a touchstone, it becomes obvious that arbitrary use of reference temperatures and/or use of capricious energy credits cannot dictate a system’s computed fuel flow. Efficiency, calorific value and fuel flow must have fixed definitions concomitant with a system’s useful energy flow. Thermodynamics is not an arbitrary discipline, the computed fuel needs of a system must describe the actual. Boiler efficiency requires the same treatment, as an absolute value, as actual fuel feed and emission flow. Boiler efficiencies and associated calorific values have obvious standing when judging contractual obligations, for thermal performance monitoring, and for confirming carbon emissions. Note that a 0.5 to 1% change in efficiency may well have significant financial consequences when testing a new unit, or the on-going costs associated with fuel and carbon taxes. This paper demonstrates that errors greater than 2% are entirely possible if following the current standards. This paper appeals to the resolution of efficiency at the 0.1% level. The power plant engineer is encouraged to read the Introduction and Summary & Recommendations sections while the thermodynamicist is requested to throughly review and critique the mid-sections. The author hopes such reviews will advocate for improvement of these important industrial standards.
Skip Nav Destination
ASME 2009 Power Conference
July 21–23, 2009
Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA
Conference Sponsors:
- Power Division
ISBN:
978-0-7918-4350-5
PROCEEDINGS PAPER
Errors in Boiler Efficiency Standards Available to Purchase
Fred D. Lang
Fred D. Lang
Exergetic Systems, Inc., San Rafael, CA
Search for other works by this author on:
Fred D. Lang
Exergetic Systems, Inc., San Rafael, CA
Paper No:
POWER2009-81221, pp. 487-501; 15 pages
Published Online:
September 22, 2010
Citation
Lang, FD. "Errors in Boiler Efficiency Standards." Proceedings of the ASME 2009 Power Conference. ASME 2009 Power Conference. Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA. July 21–23, 2009. pp. 487-501. ASME. https://doi.org/10.1115/POWER2009-81221
Download citation file:
20
Views
Related Proceedings Papers
Related Articles
Advanced Coal-Fired Power Plants
J. Energy Resour. Technol (March,2001)
Thermodynamic Analysis and Comparison on Oxy-Fuel Power Generation Process
J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power (September,2009)
Generalized Thermodynamics of High-Temperature Combustion
Trans. ASME (August,1948)
Related Chapters
Combined Cycle Power Plant
Energy and Power Generation Handbook: Established and Emerging Technologies
A Utility Perspective of Wind Energy
Wind Turbine Technology: Fundamental Concepts in Wind Turbine Engineering, Second Edition
Basic Concepts
Design & Analysis of ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Components in the Creep Range