Historical methods are typically used to determine the 100-year seastates used in traditional design practice. In these methods, one fits a probability distribution to the historical record of Hs and wind speed. With the development of more rational design standards, interest has shifted to rare events-with annual exceedence probabilities of 10−4 or lower. If one uses historical methods to determine the seastates associated with these probabilities, one typically encounters high uncertainties as a result of limited sample size and modeling uncertainty associated with the choice of distribution shape. This paper presents the results from Phase-I of an industry-sponsored project aimed at the development of more reliable methods for the calculation of seastates (particularly Hs) associated with rare probabilities. These methods construct deductive (or physically based) probabilistic models of the storm characteristics and their effects, and then use these models (together with the laws of probability theory) to calculate the probabilities of rare seastates. The objective of this first (exploratory) phase was to develop and apply a deductive model for hurricanes affecting platform sites in the western Gulf of Mexico, compare the predictions of this model to those of the historical approach, investigate and compare the uncertainties in both approaches, and explore other benefits of using the deductive method. For the sake of efficiency and internal consistency, a simple parametric-hindcast method was used for both the deductive and historical approaches. Results from this project indicate that the deductive and historical methods predict identical values of Hs for annual exceedence probabilities of 10−2 per year. For lower probabilities (particularly for 10−4), the predictions by the deductive method are within the range of predictions by the historical method using different assumptions about distribution shape. The statistical uncertainty of the deductive method is comparable to that of the historical method (if the latter uses pooled data coming from the entire static region). If no pooling is performed with the historical method, the uncertainty in the deductive method is lower. In addition, the deductive method shows less sensitivity to distribution-shape assumptions. This paper also summarizes ongoing efforts to adapt the deductive approach to extra-tropical storms in the North Sea — which have more complicated wind fields than hurricanes — and to the entire Gulf of Mexico — with the associated geographical variation in storm rate and characteristics.
Skip Nav Destination
ASME 2004 23rd International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering
June 20–25, 2004
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Conference Sponsors:
- Ocean, Offshore, and Arctic Engineering Division
ISBN:
0-7918-3744-0
PROCEEDINGS PAPER
Comparison of Historical and Deductive Methods for the Calculation of Low-Probability Seastates in the Gulf of Mexico
Gabriel R. Toro,
Gabriel R. Toro
Risk Engineering, Inc., Acton, MA
Search for other works by this author on:
C. Allin Cornell,
C. Allin Cornell
Stanford University, Stanford, CA
Search for other works by this author on:
Vincent J. Cardone,
Vincent J. Cardone
OceanWeather, Inc., Cos Cob, CT
Search for other works by this author on:
David B. Driver
David B. Driver
BP America, Inc., Houston, TX
Search for other works by this author on:
Gabriel R. Toro
Risk Engineering, Inc., Acton, MA
C. Allin Cornell
Stanford University, Stanford, CA
Vincent J. Cardone
OceanWeather, Inc., Cos Cob, CT
David B. Driver
BP America, Inc., Houston, TX
Paper No:
OMAE2004-51634, pp. 629-636; 8 pages
Published Online:
December 22, 2008
Citation
Toro, GR, Cornell, CA, Cardone, VJ, & Driver, DB. "Comparison of Historical and Deductive Methods for the Calculation of Low-Probability Seastates in the Gulf of Mexico." Proceedings of the ASME 2004 23rd International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering. 23rd International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering, Volume 2. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. June 20–25, 2004. pp. 629-636. ASME. https://doi.org/10.1115/OMAE2004-51634
Download citation file:
13
Views
Related Proceedings Papers
Related Articles
Seasonal Modeling of Multivariate Distributions of Metocean Parameters With Application to Marine Operations
J. Offshore Mech. Arct. Eng (August,2004)
Extreme Gust Loading for Wind Turbines during Operation
J. Sol. Energy Eng (November,2001)
Alternative Environmental Contours for Marine Structural Design—A Comparison Study
J. Offshore Mech. Arct. Eng (October,2015)
Related Chapters
Learnings from the Performance of Fixed Steel Structures in Gulf of Mexico Hurricanes
Ageing and Life Extension of Offshore Facilities
A Multi-Channel Choose Policy Base on Conflict Estimating in Wireless Vehicular Networks
International Conference on Instrumentation, Measurement, Circuits and Systems (ICIMCS 2011)
Establishing Unmanning Criteria for a Jacket Structure on the NCS
Ageing and Life Extension of Offshore Facilities