The fatigue life behavior and internal surface conditions of inherently damped Additive Manufactured (AM) specimens subjected to vibration bending are under investigation. This study supports research that demonstrated 95% vibration suppression due to damping capability of AM components with 1–3% internal volume of unfused powder. The damping demonstrations have been carried out using laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) specimens of various thicknesses, lengths, and unfused internal powder configurations. In addition, damping is shown to be achievable with both nickel-based alloys and stainless steel specimens. Despite the promise of this method, the viability of fatigue performance is unknown. The following effort aims to address this structural integrity issue; specifically, this study explores whether internal pocket roughness or erosion caused by powder particle motion induces a fatigue life debit. These concerns are addressed by comparing the fatigue behaviors of unfused powder pocket and fully-fused nickel based alloy 718 specimens. Microscopy results confirmed a long suspected powder interaction phenomena as well as appearances of erosion. Furthermore, fractography supports that fatigue failures initiate near the surface of maximum strain/stress at porous features consistent with stock (non-optimized) LPBF process parameters.